Abstract:Abstract The ability to make rational decisions is one of mankind’s unique attributes. A characteristic of the formal techniques that have been used for decision making is the selection of the best alternative with respect to a certain figure of merit. One of the most critical problems in engineering design is making early decisions on a sound basis. However, the early stages of design are also the most uncertain, and obtaining precise information upon which to base design decisions is usually impossible. The need for a methodology to represent and manipulate imprecision is greatest in the early, preliminary stages of engineering design, where the designer is most unsure of the final dimensions and shape, material properties, and performance of the completed design. Utility Theory provides an analytical way to aid the decisions in engineering design. By exchanging from objective to attribute and expressing these attitudes mathematically, a utility based attribute function (Utility Function) can be set up to describe the attitude of a decision-maker with regard to his/her preference. In this work, the Aspiration-level Interactive Method (AIM), a goal-seeking method based on identifying non-dominated solutions, is used along with Utility Theory to compensate for the limitations of utility theory in forming a meaningful group preference. This work is an initial attempt to integrate two methodologies from the field of decision theory in order to provide rational decision support for design problems where a hierarchy of decision making is required. The hierarchy, in this paper, is characterized by multiple designers at the lower level who report to one manager. The designers each have different preferences and values, while the manager is driven by project goals and specifications. The approach presented generates feasible and preferred design combinations for further analysis in the detailed design phase.

A constraint-based approach to feasibility assessment in preliminary design

A New Method for Feasibility Analysis of Steady Constrained Optimization Systems

A Relative Feasibility Degree Based Approach for Constrained Optimization Problems.

Studying on the Technique of Integration Analysis to Rigid-Flexible Mixture Virtual Prototyping in Complex Mechanic System

A constraint-driven conceptual design approach for product based on function-behavior-structure design process

A probabilistic approach for examining aircraft concept feasibility and viability

Research on intelligent product conceptual design based on cognitive process

Generation and Mapping of Minimally-Restrictive Manufacturability Constraints for Mechanical Design Problems

A 2-Phase Aspiration-Level and Utility Theory Approach to Large Scale Design

Constraining the Feasible Design Space in Bayesian Optimization With User Feedback

Framework for metamodel-based design optimization considering product performance and assembly process complexity

Application of Failure Modes and Effects Analysis in the Engineering Design Process

A new integrated decision-making approach for design alternative selection for supporting complex product development

Eco-performance evaluation of product designs – an integrated fuzzy complex proportional assessment with life cycle assessment

Modeling of Functional Construction Requirements for Constructability Analysis

Constraint Handling in Bayesian Optimization -- A Comparative Study of Support Vector Machine, Augmented Lagrangian and Expected Feasible Improvement

A Relative Equilibrium Decision Approach for Concept Design Through Fuzzy Cooperative Game Theory

A generalized methodology for multidisciplinary design optimization using surrogate modelling and multifidelity analysis

An integrated product conceptual scheme decision approach based on Shapley value method and fuzzy logic for economic-technical objectives trade-off under uncertainty

Structural optimization based on CAD–CAE integration and metamodeling techniques

An Evaluation Method for Schemes of Mechanical Product Conceptual Design with Incomplete Multi-Technique-Parameters