Abstract:Abstract Growth factors regulate cell fates, including their proliferation, differentiation, survival, and death, according to the cell type. Even when the response to a specific growth factor is deterministic for collective cell behavior, significant levels of fluctuation are often observed between single cells. Statistical analyses of single-cell responses provide insights into the mechanism of cell fate decisions but very little is known about the distributions of the internal states of cells responding to growth factors. Using multi-color immunofluorescent staining, we have here detected the phosphorylation of seven elements in the early response of the ERBB–RAS–MAPK system to two growth factors. Among these seven elements, five were analyzed simultaneously in distinct combinations in the same single cells. Although principle component analysis suggested cell-type and input specific phosphorylation patterns, cell-to-cell fluctuation was large. Mutual information analysis suggested that cells use multitrack (bush-like) signal transduction pathways under conditions in which clear cell fate changes have been reported. The clustering of single-cell response patterns indicated that the fate change in a cell population correlates with the large entropy of the response, suggesting a bet-hedging strategy is used in decision making. A comparison of true and randomized datasets further indicated that this large variation is not produced by simple reaction noise, but is defined by the properties of the signal-processing network. Author Summary How extracellular signals, such as growth factors (GFs), induce fate changes in biological cells is still not fully understood. Some GFs induce cell proliferation and others induce differentiation by stimulating a common reaction network. Although the response to each GF is reproducible for a cell population, not all single cells respond similarly. The question that arises is whether a certain GF conducts all the responding cells in the same direction during a fate change, or if it initially stimulates a variety of behaviors among single cells, from which the cells that move in the appropriate direction are later selected. Our current statistical analysis of single-cell responses suggests that the latter process, which is called a bet-hedging mechanism is plausible. The complex pathways of signal transmission seem to be responsible for this bet-hedging.

Dynamics and heterogeneity of Erk-induced immediate-early gene expression

Common modes of ERK induction resolve into context specific signalling via a combination of signal duration and cell type specific transcriptional repression

Engineering combinatorial and dynamic decoders using synthetic immediate-early genes

Common modes of ERK induction resolve into context-specific signalling via emergent networks and cell-type-specific transcriptional repression

Dependence of MAPK mediated signaling on Erk isoforms and differences in nuclear shuttling

Combinatorial expression of immediate early genes in single neurons.

Deciphering the History of ERK Activity from Fixed-Cell Immunofluorescence Measurements

Disrupted developmental signaling induces novel transcriptional states

Time-varying stimuli that prolong IKK activation promote nuclear remodeling and mechanistic switching of NF-κB dynamics

Sensitivity analysis predicts that the ERK-pMEK interaction regulates ERK nuclear translocation

Cytokine combinations for human blood stem cell expansion induce cell-type– and cytokine-specific signaling dynamics

Dynamics and control of the ERK signaling pathway: Sensitivity, bistability, and oscillations

Computational modeling of the dynamics of the MAP kinase cascade activated by surface and internalized EGF receptors

Probing the Heterogeneity of Protein Kinase Activation in Cells by Super-resolution Microscopy.

Dynamic model and regulatory mechanism of integrated ERK signal pathway activated by epidermal growth factor

Cell‐specific responses to the cytokine TGF β are determined by variability in protein levels

Specific Regulation of Immediate Early Genes by Patterned Neuronal Activity

Cell-to-cell diversification in ERBB-RAS-MAPK signal transduction that produces cell-type specific growth factor responses

Capturing and Understanding the Dynamics and Heterogeneity of Gene Expression in the Living Cell

Biphasic Response of Protein Kinase A to Cyclic Adenosine Monophosphate Triggers Distinct Epithelial Phenotypes

Inference of Intercellular Communications and Multilayer Gene-Regulations of Epithelial–Mesenchymal Transition From Single-Cell Transcriptomic Data