Collateral Monetary Policy, Regional Financial Development, and Nonfi nancial Firms' Shadow Banking Activities

Chao Yuan,Hai Jiang,Jiawen Ren,Nikos Kapitsinis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/cwe.12552

IF: 2.451

2024-09-23

China & World Economy

Abstract:China &World Economy, Volume 32, Issue 5, Page 166-196, September-October 2024.

economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The Study Between Shadow Banking and Financial Fragility in China: an Empirical Analysis Based on the Co-Integration Test and Error Correction Model

Xiao-Peng Zou,Yu-Xiao Pang,Hui-Lin Zhu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11135-012-9725-0

2012-01-01

Quality & Quantity

Abstract:The rapid development of shadow banking manifesting systematic risk has attracted increasing attention recently, but there exists a lack of empirical research in this field. This article applies co-integration analysis and error correction model using annual data during the 2001–2010 period to test the short-term fluctuation and long-term equilibrium between expansion velocity of shadow banking and financial fragility, and puts forward corresponding policy recommendations.
China's Financial System: Past, Present, and Future

Franklin Allen,Jun Qian,Meijun Qian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.978485

2007-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We examine the role of China's financial system in supporting economic growth, and explore directions of future development. First, the current financial system is dominated by a large but inefficient banking sector. Reducing the amount of non-performing loans among the major banks to normal levels is the most critical task for reforming the financial system in the short run. Second, the role of the stock market in allocating resources in the economy has been limited and ineffective. Further development of China's financial markets is the most important task in the long-term. Third, the most successful part of the financial system, in terms of supporting the growth of the overall economy, is a non-standard sector that consists of alternative financing channels, governance mechanisms, and institutions. This sector should co-exist with banks and markets in the future in order to continue to support the growth of the Hybrid Sector (non-state, non-listed firms). Finally, in order to sustain stable economic growth, China should aim to prevent and halt damaging financial crises, including a banking sector crisis, a real estate or stock market crash, and a "twin crisis" in the currency market and banking sector.
Shadow banking and the bank lending channel of monetary policy in China

Xiaoqiang Cheng,Yabin Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jimonfin.2022.102710

IF: 2.762

2022-11-01

Journal of International Money and Finance

Abstract:We study how shadow banking affects the effectiveness of monetary policy in China. Using novel data on bank-issued off-balance sheet wealth management products (WMPs), we show that banks improve their on-balance sheet risk profile by issuing WMPs. This in turn lowers the sensitivity of banks’ wholesale funding cost to monetary policy and reduces the effectiveness of the bank lending channel. The effect of our mechanism on total credit is quantitatively similar to the effect arising from the substitution between traditional loans and shadow banking loans previously analyzed in the literature. The channel documented in this paper has novel implications for the regulation of banks’ off-balance sheet activities and market-based funding.

business, finance
Shadow Banks and the Collateral Multiplier

Thomas Michl,Hyun Woong Park

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/s41302-022-00224-z

Abstract:With an emphasis on contributing to macroeconomic pedagogy, we examine the collateral multiplier by comparing it to the traditional money multiplier in a simplified framework of traditional banking and shadow banking in which government bonds are the core assets. While the money multiplier is a measure of the ability of the banking system to intermediate sovereign debt by creating deposits, the collateral multiplier is a measure of the shadow banking system's ability to intermediate sovereign debt by creating shadow money. It also measures the degree of reuse of sovereign debt as collateral. In this setup, the collateral multiplier is defined as the ratio between dealer banks' matched book repo activity relative to their trading book. Using the New York Fed's Primary Dealer Statistics data, we empirically estimate the collateral multiplier for US Treasury repo collateral. Our model and empirical results shed light on the transmission mechanisms of monetary policy channeled through shadow banks and on the US Treasuries market turmoil induced by COVID-19 in March 2020.
The Collateral Channel of Monetary Policy: Evidence from China

Hanming Fang,Yongqin Wang,Xian Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3546145

2020-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Collateral-based monetary policy tools have been used extensively by major central banks. Lack of proper policy counterfactuals, however, makes it difficult to empirically identify their causal effects on the financial market and the real economy. We exploit a quasi-natural experiment in China, where dual-listed bonds are traded in two mostly segmented markets: the interbank market regulated by the Central Bank, and the exchange market regulated by the securities regulator. During a policy shift in our study period, China's Central Bank included a class of previously ineligible bonds in the interbank market to become eligible collateral for financial institutions to borrow money from its Medium-Term Lending Facility (MLF). This policy shift allows us to implement a triple-difference strategy to estimate the causal impact of the collateral-based unconventional monetary policy. We find that in the secondary market the policy reduced the spreads of the newly collateralizable bonds in the treatment market (the interbank market) by 42-62 basis points. We also find that there is a pass-through effect from the secondary market to the primary market: the spreads of the treated bonds newly issued in the interbank market were reduced by 54 basis points.
'One system, two shadows': A local public Finance perspective on China's shadow banking system

Shidai Zhang,Kellee S. Tsai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chieco.2024.102209

IF: 4.744

2024-05-23

China Economic Review

Abstract:Why does shadow banking persist in China despite repeated policy efforts to contain it? While studies of informal finance have traditionally emphasized the credit needs of private businesses as a demand-side explanation, this study contends that China's local public finance also constitutes an important driver for shadow banking. Based on document research and administrative data, we find that China's shadow banking system has bifurcated into two segments since the Global Financial Crisis (GFC). One is the ' entrepreneurial shadow' that has long provided informal credit to the private sector, especially small- and medium-sized enterprises. The other is a ' fiscal shadow ', which serves property developers and local government financing vehicles (LGFVs), the two pillars of China's land-based local public finance regime. Property developers are major contributors to local fiscal revenues through the land economy, while LGFVs function as off-balance sheet backdoor financing intermediaries for local governments. Although localities have borrowed from unconventional sources throughout the reform era, the central government's GFC stimulus plan marked a turning point by fueling a debt-financed real estate and infrastructure construction boom. Property developers and LGFVs were launched onto a highly leveraged model of feverish expansion for over a decade. When the central government abruptly reversed its course by restricting the availability of formal credit, they became further entangled into the fiscal shadow for refinancing. Local public finance has thus become reliant on shadow banking, despite subsequent policy efforts to curb such activity. Our findings suggest the need for a more integrated analytic and regulatory framework that recognizes the mutual dependence between shadow banking and local debt – two major sources of systemic financial risks in China.

economics
A Comparative Study of Shadow Banking Activities of Non-Financial Firms in Transition Economies

Julan Du,Chang Li,Yongqin Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chieco.2016.09.001

IF: 4.744

2016-01-01

China Economic Review

Abstract:Shadow banking activities in transition economies have drawn scant attention in the literature. This paper examines a particular form of shadow banking business embedded in the operation of non-financial firms in China and transition economies in Central and Eastern Europe (CEE), in which firms borrow in order to lend. We verify its existence, especially in China and Russia, by two strategies to track the abnormal correlations between financial accounts. By exploring the national/regional variations, we find that a better development of financial market and legal system deters firms in both CEE and China from engaging in re-lending business. We also confirm that Chinese firms participate less actively in re-lending if they have better growth prospects and are located in cities with better development of high-tech industries.
Regulatory Arbitrage, Shadow Banking and Monetary Policy in China

Vo Phuong Mai Le,Kent Matthews,David Meenagh,Patrick Minford,Zhiguo Xiao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.intfin.2022.101640

IF: 4.217

2022-01-01

Journal of International Financial Markets Institutions and Money

Abstract:Regulatory arbitrage is a persuasive explanation for the rapid growth in shadow bank credit. In China, the distortions caused by government support to state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and preferential lending by state-owned banks have created an environment for the development of shadow banks that lend to small and medium enterprises (SMEs). The imposition of a loan-todeposit ratio (LDR) cap of 75% in 2009-2015 gave an additional boost to the growth of shadow bank credit by providing an incentive for conventional banks to bypass regulation and lend to SMEs via the shadow banks. The result is that shadow bank credit varied contra-cyclically to regular commercial bank credit in response to monetary policy shocks, dampening the effectiveness of monetary policy during the period of the LDR cap. This paper presents a model of the Chinese economy using a DSGE framework that accommodates a banking sector which isolates the effects of lending to SMEs by shadow banks. The model which is estimated by the method of indirect inference, allows for bank and shadow bank lending to affect the credit premium on private investment. We show that in general regular bank credit and shadow bank credit varies pro-cyclically with monetary policy but varies contra-cyclically when a LDR cap is imposed. The findings have implications for the policy of de-leveraging followed by China.
Shadow Banks, Banking Policies and China’s Macroeconomic Fluctuations

Patrick Minford

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jimonfin.2021.102415

IF: 2.762

2021-01-01

Journal of International Money and Finance

Abstract:This paper develops a model of the Chinese economy using a DSGE framework that accommodates a banking sector and money. The model is used to shed light on the period of the Global Financial Crisis. It differs from other applications in the use of Indirect Inference to estimate and test the model. Officially mandated bank lending and government spending were used to supplement monetary policy to aggressively offset shocks to demand. This paper examines the efficacy of monetary policy in terms of the reduction in the frequency of severe economic slowdowns. We find that monetary policy can be used more vigorously to stabilise the economy, making direct banking controls and fiscal activism unnecessary. A nominal GDP targeting monetary policy is the most efficient, compared with a conventional Taylor Rule, a Friedman rule or a price level targeting rule. @& nbsp;2021 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
The Real Effects of Shadow Banking: Evidence from China

Xuan Tian,Guoqian Tu,Yichu Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3859068

IF: 5.4

2024-01-01

Management Science

Abstract:We provide firm-level evidence on the real effects of shadow banking in terms of technological innovation. Firm-to-firm entrusted loans, the largest part of the shadow banking sector in China, enhance the borrowers’ innovation output. The effects are more prominent when the borrowers are subject to severer financial constraints, information asymmetry, and takeover exposures. A plausible underlying channel is capital reallocations from less productive but easily financed lender firms to more innovative but financially less privileged borrower firms. Our paper suggests that shadow banking helps correct bank credit misallocations and thus, serves as a second-best market design in financing the real economy. This paper was accepted by Kay Giesecke, finance. Funding: X. Tian and Y. Wang acknowledge financial support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China [Grant 71825002] and the Beijing Outstanding Young Scientist Program [Grant BJJWZYJH012019100003014]. G. Tu acknowledges financial support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China [Grant 72010107001]. Supplemental Material: The online appendix and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.00953 .
Collateral Constraint and China's Credit Boom in the Global Financial Crisis: Loan-Level Anatomy

Wei Li,Yongqin Wang,Suhua Tian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4135437

2022-01-01

Abstract:Collateral is at the heart of modern financial system and plays an essential role in business and financial cycles. Leveraging detailed loan level data covering a major city in China, the paper is among the first to provide stylized facts on Chinese bank loan collateral structure. It shows that facing the tension between heightened uncertainty and government mandate of credit expansion during the global financial crisis (GFC), banks significantly raise collateral requirements while shortening loan maturity. Pre-existing relationship helps in obtaining bank loans in normal times but has less bite during the GFC. Further more, as firms prioritize real estate investment over intangibles to facilitate borrowing, this paper also finds reduced firm innovation among the affected firms. The anatomy of the collateral dynamics sheds light on how credit gets created and (mis) allocated during the GFC, and provides micro-level evidence for some recent salient macroeconomic facts on China.
Liquidity Shocks and 'borrow to Lend' Shadow Banking Activities

Zhibo Tan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3187132

2018-01-01

Abstract:Using quarterly financial statements data of listed firms during 2008-2016, this paper identifies the “borrow to lend” shadow banking activities of non-financial firms in China by examining the connection of key financial variables and investigates how liquidity shocks affect such activities. Empirical results demonstrate that “borrow to lend” activities have become more prevalent in recent years, especially for state-owned firms. Small private firms engage in the usual “borrow to invest” activities while the large state-owned firms and less profitable firms are more involved with “borrow to lend” activities. Liquidity shocks induce large private firms to take part in more “borrow to lend” activities, but they exert no additional impact on state-owned firms. The findings suggest that a broader focus is necessary to understand the multi-faceted aspects of shadow banking activities in China.
Collateral-based monetary policy and corporate employment: Evidence from medium-term lending facility in China

Xiaoling Liu,Yuhui Wu,Huan Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcorpfin.2022.102333

IF: 6.1

2022-12-01

Journal of Corporate Finance

Abstract:Collateral-based monetary policy tools in China aim to guide credit resources to the real economy by injecting base money into banks to support policy objectives, such as promoting employment. This study examines the effects of Medium-term Lending Facilities (MLF) on employment through the bank lending channel. The results of difference-in-differences estimation show that post-MLF implementation, employment growth and labor cost growth of firms with high MLF exposure increase by 8.04% and 5.74%, respectively. The channel test shows that commercial banks with high bond holdings significantly increase lending after MLF implementation, which subsequently increases employment for borrowers of these banks. This effect is more pronounced for firms with high dependence on external financing, strong financing constraints, no qualifications to issue bonds, high sales growth, and belonging to industries supported by industrial policies. MLF also improves the quality of employment, which in turn significantly increases the total factor productivity of firms. Finally, MLF also has a significant positive effect on local aggregate employment growth. Focusing on firm labor hiring decisions, which are crucial to real economic development and social stability, this study has important theoretical and practical implications for furthering our understanding of the effectiveness and feasibility of collateral-based monetary policy tools.

business, finance
Exploring the Nexus of Liquidity Regulation, Bank Risk-Taking, and Shadow Banking: A Comprehensive Analysis of Chinese Commercial Banks

Xing Chen,Yilei Wu,Yi Ding,Tongxin Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13132-024-02013-9

IF: 1.815

2024-05-01

Journal of the Knowledge Economy

Abstract:The banking industry plays a pivotal role in any economy, and its stability is paramount for societal and economic well-being. This research paper delves into the intricate relationship between liquidity regulation, bank risk-taking, and the shadow banking sector, focusing on Chinese commercial banks. With the introduction of the Net Stable Funding Ratio (NSFR) and its integration into the macroprudential regulatory framework, this study takes a novel approach to comprehensively analyze how adjustments in bank asset structures impact risk-taking behavior and the scale of shadow banking from a micro perspective. This paper's contributions are manifold. Firstly, it innovatively incorporates NSFR and Capital Adequacy Ratio into the DLM model, providing a unified theoretical framework to analyze liquidity management, risk-taking, and shadow banking. It uncovers the micro-level mechanisms driving commercial banks' liquidity behavior and their relationship with the shadow banking sector. Secondly, it goes beyond empirical verification and examines the logical relationship between liquidity regulation, bank risk-taking, and shadow banking. Thirdly, the paper introduces the " " indicator for NSFR, offering a differential approach to liquidity supervision and macroprudential regulation. Empirical analysis, spanning from 2012 to 2021 and covering 116 banks, supports the findings. The results suggest optimizing the internal structure of non-credit assets can significantly reduce bank risk-taking while improving NSFR for banks with " " greater than 0. Conversely, for banks with " " less than 0, adjusting the internal structure of credit assets can achieve similar objectives. These insights pave the way for more effective liquidity management practices and contribute to the dual goals of liquidity supervision and risk control. Policy recommendations include differentiated supervision based on " " values, encouraging banks to optimize their asset structures, and diversifying stable funding sources to enhance banking stability and safety. This research contributes to the ongoing discourse on enhancing financial stability and aligning with the goals of modern banking regulation.

economics
Systemic Risk Arising from Shadow Banking and Sustainable Development: A Study of Wealth Management Products in China

Hongjie Pan,Hong Fan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16104280

IF: 3.9

2024-05-20

Sustainability

Abstract:Shadow banking is a main way for the financial market to serve the real economy today, and this process is closely related to systemic risk. This study examines the impact of shadow banking associated with sustainable development in China's banking on systemic risk. We analyze the data obtained from a rich sample of 31 listed commercial banks in China and shadow banking represented by wealth management products (WMPs) by constructing a dynamic complex interbank network model. The results show that the risks and vulnerabilities generated by shadow banking spread out through the interbank network and cause systemic risk to increase. The effect operates through increasing the number of default banks, reducing banks' survival rate and profit, and forcing central bank bailout funds expansion. However, it has a positive impact in terms of augmenting liquidity and enhancing investment opportunities. Furthermore, the variability in the influence of different categories of shadow banking is assessed, emphasizing that short-term shadow banking exerts a more pronounced impact on systemic risk. In addition, the heterogeneity of the shadow banking effect on different types of commercial banks is explored, revealing that local and rural commercial banks experience a more conspicuous effect compared to state-owned and joint-stock banks. Our findings highlight that improving external supervision, promoting financial internal governance, and constraining credit linkages are vital for alleviating the increase in risks in shadow banking and maintaining the sustainable development of banking.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
The Shadow Banking System and Financial Crisis

Ya-bin DU,Hai-ning GU

2010-01-01

Abstract:The sudden emergence of the shadow banking in recent years has brought about a high degree of prosperity in the United States as well as the international financial market. But because of the highly leveraged operations,the endogenous fragility within the shadow banking system is no doubt one of the most important reasons that leads to the current most serious global financial crisis. The ebb and flow of the system provides a good inspiration for China’s further development in the financial sector. That is,efforts should be made to improve the basic assets quality,strengthen the avoidance of financial risks and supervision of financial institutions and activities.
Funny Money or Legitimate Finance? Shadow Banking and Policy Impacts in China

Sara Hsu,Xun Han

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/00027642211020060

2021-05-28

American Behavioral Scientist

Abstract:Government officials in China have taken different views regarding shadow banking. Some have seen the industry as overly risky, potentially undermining the formal financial system, while others have asserted that it is an increasingly important part of the financial system, filling a gap in finance provision to particular sectors and smaller firms. Do their views matter? Regulators have striven to crack down on the riskiest practices in shadow banking, but are the policies effective? In this article, we analyze the impact of government attitudes and actions on the shadow banking sector. Using a unique data set based on information collected from various sources in a difference-in-difference model, we find that shadow banking regulation plays a strong role in China’s financial sector, while contradictory government views (in the form of commentary in the People’s Daily) on shadow banking do not. This reveals that shadow banking is strongly affected by political authority when it is codified into regulation. Only some aspects of shadow banking can be legitimized through regulation, while the remainder of China’s financial system remains constrained due to state dominance over the financial sector. This underscores the “funny” nature of shadow banking’s money flows. This article is one of the first to study the effects of government views and regulations on the shadow banking system.

social sciences, interdisciplinary,psychology, clinical
Fiscal Stimulus, Deposit Competition, and the Rise of Shadow Banking: Evidence from China

Viral V. Acharya,Jun “QJ” Qian,Yang Su,Zhishu Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4694946

2024-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:The rise of shadow banking and attendant financial fragility in China can be traced to intensified deposit competition following the 2008–2009 global financial crisis (GFC). A large, state-owned bank’s deposits from cross-border money inflows fell significantly following the GFC, and it supported the government’s fiscal stimulus more aggressively than other large banks by issuing larger volumes of new loans. Small and medium-sized banks with more branch-level overlaps with this large bank relied more on shadow banking and issued more wealth management products (WMPs)—short-maturity, off-balance-sheet substitutes for deposits. Greater amounts of WMPs created rollover risks for the issuers, as reflected by higher yields on new WMPs, higher borrowing rates in the interbank market, and lower stock-market performance during liquidity stress. This paper was accepted by Victoria Ivashina, finance. Funding: This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China [Grants 71272024, 71972051, and 72071117]. Supplemental Material: The internet appendix and data files are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2023.04233 .
Shadow Banking, Stock Market Volatility, and Stock-Money Market Correlation: Evidence from China

Min Liu,Hong-Fei Liu,Chien-Chiang Lee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1540496x.2024.2425731

2024-11-16

Emerging Markets Finance and Trade

Abstract:The study on the relationship between shadow banking (SB) and stock market volatility is scarce. Based on sample data from January 2006 to May 2024, this paper dives deep to clarify whether and how China's SB brings uncertainties to China's stock market and the impact of SB on the stock-money market correlation. The novelty of this paper is that we connect low-frequency SB with high-frequency financial market information under the framework of mixed-frequency data analysis. Our findings indicate that the expansion of SB could directly enhance China's stock market volatility. There exists a persistent correlation between China's stock and money markets in the long run. Furthermore, the rapid development of SB also strengthens the stock-money market correlation in the long run. Since SB could reduce the controllability of China's monetary policy and increase China's money market uncertainties, we believe that China's money market may serve as an important channel for SB to spread risks to the stock market volatility by pushing the two markets to move more closely. We shed new light on the literature regarding the relationship between SB and stock market. This paper makes the first attempt to identify the role of SB in driving the dynamics of stock-money market correlation.

economics,international relations,business
Corporate Investment and Shadow Banking Channel of Monetary Policy

Bo Jiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3905367

2021-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:This paper studies the heterogeneous response of State-owned enterprises (SOEs) and nonState-owned enterprises (nonSOEs) to the monetary policy. I find that SOEs’ investment declines by 5% - 12% more than nonSOEs after a 100 basis point monetary tightening shock using recent data from China. I provide evidence that a shadow banking channel could explain the empirical results. I show that, via a rise of shadow banking relative to bank loans, a monetary tightening shock raises the credit spread of SOEs to nonSOEs, which further slows down the investment of SOEs compared to nonSOEs.

Collateral Monetary Policy, Regional Financial Development, and Nonfi nancial Firms' Shadow Banking Activities

The Study Between Shadow Banking and Financial Fragility in China: an Empirical Analysis Based on the Co-Integration Test and Error Correction Model

China's Financial System: Past, Present, and Future

Shadow banking and the bank lending channel of monetary policy in China

Shadow Banks and the Collateral Multiplier

The Collateral Channel of Monetary Policy: Evidence from China

'One system, two shadows': A local public Finance perspective on China's shadow banking system

A Comparative Study of Shadow Banking Activities of Non-Financial Firms in Transition Economies

Regulatory Arbitrage, Shadow Banking and Monetary Policy in China

Shadow Banks, Banking Policies and China’s Macroeconomic Fluctuations

The Real Effects of Shadow Banking: Evidence from China

Collateral Constraint and China's Credit Boom in the Global Financial Crisis: Loan-Level Anatomy

Liquidity Shocks and 'borrow to Lend' Shadow Banking Activities

Collateral-based monetary policy and corporate employment: Evidence from medium-term lending facility in China

Exploring the Nexus of Liquidity Regulation, Bank Risk-Taking, and Shadow Banking: A Comprehensive Analysis of Chinese Commercial Banks

Systemic Risk Arising from Shadow Banking and Sustainable Development: A Study of Wealth Management Products in China

The Shadow Banking System and Financial Crisis

Funny Money or Legitimate Finance? Shadow Banking and Policy Impacts in China

Fiscal Stimulus, Deposit Competition, and the Rise of Shadow Banking: Evidence from China

Shadow Banking, Stock Market Volatility, and Stock-Money Market Correlation: Evidence from China

Corporate Investment and Shadow Banking Channel of Monetary Policy