The long-run effects of recessions on fertility

Zimmer, David M.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11150-024-09713-w
2024-06-12
Review of Economics of the Household
Abstract:Using large repeated cross-sections and a cohort-based econometric approach, this paper produces evidence that women who finish their formal education during periods of high unemployment have significantly, and persistently, lower fertility compared to women who graduate during more favorable economic conditions. In terms of magnitude, a woman who graduates into a market with a 3 percentage point higher unemployment rate experiences an approximate 14% reduction in birth probabilities about a half-decade later. The long-recognized negative effects of unemployment on marriage explain, at most, 30% of that reduction in fertility. Rather, graduating into high unemployment appears to exert its own influence on fertility, separate from its effect on marriage.
economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the long - term impact of economic recession on female fertility rates. Specifically, through a large amount of repeated cross - sectional data and cohort - based econometric methods, the author studied whether the fertility rate of women who completed formal education during periods of high unemployment is significantly and persistently lower compared to those who graduated during better economic conditions. The study found that if a woman faces a 3 - percentage - point higher unemployment rate upon graduation, then approximately half a decade later, her probability of giving birth will decrease by about 14%. In addition, the study also explored the impact of high unemployment on marriage and to what extent this impact explains the decline in fertility rates. ### Main problems 1. **Long - term impact of economic recession on fertility rates**: - The author studied whether the fertility rate of women who completed formal education during periods of high unemployment would be significantly and persistently lower than those who graduated during better economic conditions. - The study found that the negative impact of high unemployment on fertility rates is significant and persistent, and this impact still exists even after considering the marriage factor. 2. **Impact of high unemployment on marriage**: - The author further explored the impact of high unemployment on marriage and analyzed to what extent this impact explains the decline in fertility rates. - The study found that although high unemployment does reduce the probability of women getting married, this factor can only explain about 30% of the decline in fertility rates, and the remaining 70% of the decline in fertility rates is directly caused by high unemployment. ### Key findings - **Long - term impact on fertility rates**: - The negative impact of high unemployment on fertility rates is significant and persistent, and this impact still exists even after considering the marriage factor. - If a woman faces a 3 - percentage - point higher unemployment rate upon graduation, then approximately half a decade later, her probability of giving birth will decrease by about 14%. - **Impact on marriage**: - High unemployment not only directly affects fertility rates but also indirectly affects fertility rates by reducing the probability of women getting married. - However, the direct impact of high unemployment on fertility rates is greater, accounting for about 70% of the total impact. ### Significance - **Policy recommendations**: - This study is of great significance to policy - makers. If they hope to increase the fertility rate, simply implementing policies to promote marriage may have limited effects. - More effective measures may be to directly reduce the cost of childbearing, such as providing favorable tax treatment or subsidizing childcare services. ### Methods - **Data sources**: - Use data from the American Community Survey (ACS), covering annual data from 2000 to 2019. - The sample includes women aged 16 to 45, who have completed at least 9th grade education and were born in the 50 states of the United States or the District of Columbia. - **Econometric model**: - Adopt the "scarring model" and analyze the long - term impact of high unemployment on fertility rates through linear regression. - The model includes fixed effects to control the influence of factors such as year, graduation year, and education level. ### Conclusions - Economic recession has a significant and persistent negative impact on women's fertility rates, and this impact is not only indirectly achieved by reducing the probability of getting married but also directly affects the decision - making of childbearing. - Policy - makers should consider measures to directly reduce the cost of childbearing in order to effectively increase the fertility rate.