Abstract:Civil religion as formulated in Robert Bellah's seminal 1967 article, recalling Rousseau's Social Contract, has recently been proposed to build shared values and bridge deep partisan divides. A competing approach to shared values, based on public reason, relies on overlapping consensus in the works of John Rawls. In this paper, we present an in-between strategy that recognizes the insuperable empirical and normative problems of civil religion while using university civic engagement programs to bring about a public square in which religious reasons are found alongside neutral ones, ultimately for the sake of public justification. Having documented recent polarization trends, we consider the last major attempt to defend civil religion from the perspective of democratic solidarity, Phil Gorski's American Covenant, but believe it falls short: based on sociological work and Augustinian insights, we show the risk of domination that Gorski's strategy still entails, not least because of the definitional indeterminacy of civil religion and its overlap with religious nationalism. Paradoxically, a late Rawlsian approach that allows for the initial use of religious reasons, with a generosity proviso of necessary translation into public reason at some point, can lead to a public square with more religious arguments than one theorized explicitly from the perspective of civil religion. This is especially important because, given the discussed polarization trends, universities have taken on an increasingly important civic engagement role even as some still rely on a civil religion approach. We insist on public justification in university civic engagement, and for the sake of doing so take as a starting point Ben Berger's work in favoring civil engagement, which we define as combining moral, political, and social rather than exclusively political commitments. In proposing a novel university shared values mechanism, intended to expose learners to a maximum diversity of opinions and lived experiences, we offer a fresh approach to building trust in cohorts that increases the likelihood of true dialogue across difference.

The New Outspoken Atheism and Education

Politics by Other Means: Civic Education in a Time of Controversy

Science, Religion and the Teaching of Evolution

Building Bridges Across Faith Lines: Responsible Christian Education in a Post-Christian Society

Encountering the Religious Other at a Public University: Student Development Through Reflection and Discussion

Education, Religion, and a Sustainable Planet

The Bible, ODeL (Open and Distance Education and Learning) and Spirituality: Possibilities in a Post-secular Time

Between Public Justification and Civil Religion: Shared Values in a Divided Time

Inclusive-Dialogic Religious Education: A Model for Cultivating Multi-Religious Character in Early Childhood Education (ECE)

Adding and Dividing by Religion: The Not-So-Hidden Curriculum of Mission-Public Schools in Ghana

Activism, Religious Studies, and Embodied Teaching in an Era of Rapid Climate Changes

The Quest to Cultivate Tolerance Through Education

The New Politics of Religious Education in the United States and Germany

Teaching in an Era of Political Divisiveness: An Exploration of Strategies for Discussing Controversial Issues

Teaching evolution (and all of biology) more effectively: Strategies for engagement, critical reasoning, and confronting misconceptions

#WhoNeedsDiverseBooks?: Preservice Teachers and Religious Neutrality with Children’s Literature

The development of beliefs and values in early adolescence: a case study through religious education pedagogy

The Potential of Catholic Schools: Public Virtues through Private Voucher

Issues in Religious Education

Re-defining ‘learning about religion’ and ‘learning from religion’: a study of policy change

Philosophy of education in a new key: publicness, social justice, and education; a South-North conversation