Abstract:Land consolidation serves as a vital instrument for rural development worldwide. Various governance structures of land consolidation and their performance have been examined against diverse backgrounds; however, how institutional change affects different governance structures of land consolidation remains to be studied. A synthetic framework linking the institutional environment, governance structures and incentives of actors is proposed to examine the suitability and sustainability of different governance structures under changes in the institutional environment through the lens of land reallocation in land consolidation. The paper applies an embedded comparative case study using cases from China because the promotion of land consolidation in China is in parallel with rural land rights reform. The results have shown that both government-dominated land reallocation and self-organized land reallocation were suitable and individual exchanges was not suitable to solve the problem of large-scale fragmentation in China, while institutional environmental change characterized by the unimproved land consolidation legal framework and the enhanced private land right legal framework has undermined the suitability of government-dominated land reallocation. We conclude that whether initiation, land redistribution and conflict resolution match with the situation and align with each other determines the suitability of governance structures; Changing institutional environment may lead to mode fixing or mode shifting of governance structures in the long run, which depends on the incentives of actors. The government-dominated land reallocation is not sustainable because the behavior of the decision-makers in the mode, who are local government-officials, has a nature of upward accountability. The institutional environmental change has discouraged local government officials from conducting land reallocation. Based on this conclusion, we propose that land consolidation legal framework in China should be enhanced along with rural land rights reform, and in other developing countries that are undergoing similar reform, connections between related institutions should be carefully balanced rather than simply enhancing tenure security.

Unpacking market-oriented land governance and its performance differences: Empirical evidence from urban land redevelopment in contemporary China

The Suitability and Sustainability of Governance Structures in Land Consolidation under Institutional Change: A Comparative Case Study

The Micro Administrative Mechanism of Land Reallocation in Land Consolidation: A Perspective from Collective Action

Assessing Performance and Disparities in China’s Land Finance Transition: Insights from Neo-Liberalism and Neo-Marxism

Efficiency and Distribution of Rural Construction Land Marketization in Contemporary China

Public and Self-Organized Land Readjustment in Rural China − A Comparison

Rural Renewal of China in the Context of Rural-Urban Integration: Governance Fit and Performance Differences

Local Government Competition and Centralised Urban Growth Management Policy Implementation: Evidence from China

A Study on Promoting the Intensive Use of Industrial Land in China Through Governance: A Game Theoretical Approach

Land Use Policy for Urbanization in China

Market-oriented reform and land use efficiency: Evidence from a regression discontinuity design

New geography of land commodification in Chinese cities: Uneven landscape of urban land development under market reforms and globalization

The Boundary between the Function of the Market and That of the Government:Choosing the Governance Structure of the Non-agricultural Use of Farmland

Land Management Strategy of Local Government, Competition Mechanism and China’s Urban Hierarchy from the Spatial Perspective:An Empirical Analysis based on the 186 Cities in China

Land Policy Making in a Complex System: the Innovation and Diffusion Logic of China's Retained Land Policy Reform

Liberalizing Rural-to-urban Construction Land Transfers in China: Distribution Effects

Evolution of transitional institutions for urban land redevelopment in China—Case in Guangzhou

Land finance dependence and urban land marketization in China: The perspective of strategic choice of local governments on land transfer

Institutional Diversity or Isomorphism? Research on the Evolution of Collective-Owned Construction Land Marketization Reform since the 1990s—The Case of Shunde and Wujiang, China

Urban land marketization in China: Central policy, local initiative, and market mechanism

Land Property Rights, Spatial Form, and Land Performance: A Framework of Policy Performance Evaluation on Collective-Owned Construction Land and Evidence from Rural China