Different Applications Call for Different Antigen-Binding Moieties

Heleen Hanssens,Fien Meeus,Emma L. Gesquiere,Janik Puttemans,Yannick De Vlaeminck,Kim De Veirman,Karine Breckpot,Nick Devoogdt
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/ijms25115634
IF: 5.6
2024-05-23
International Journal of Molecular Sciences
Abstract:CAR-T cell therapy is at the forefront of next-generation multiple myeloma (MM) management, with two B-cell maturation antigen (BCMA)-targeted products recently approved. However, these products are incapable of breaking the infamous pattern of patient relapse. Two contributing factors are the use of BCMA as a target molecule and the artificial scFv format that is responsible for antigen recognition. Tackling both points of improvement in the present study, we used previously characterized VHHs that specifically target the idiotype of murine 5T33 MM cells. This idiotype represents one of the most promising yet challenging MM target antigens, as it is highly cancer- but also patient-specific. These VHHs were incorporated into VHH-based CAR modules, the format of which has advantages compared to scFv-based CARs. This allowed a side-by-side comparison of the influence of the targeting domain on T cell activation. Surprisingly, VHHs previously selected as lead compounds for targeted MM radiotherapy are not the best (CAR-) T cell activators. Moreover, the majority of the evaluated VHHs are incapable of inducing any T cell activation. As such, we highlight the importance of specific VHH selection, depending on its intended use, and thereby raise an important shortcoming of current common CAR development approaches.
biochemistry & molecular biology,chemistry, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper aims to address several key issues in the treatment of multiple myeloma (MM). Specifically: 1. **Antigen Selection Issue**: Although the two currently approved CAR-T cell therapies targeting B-cell maturation antigen (BCMA) have made significant progress in treating multiple myeloma, patients still experience relapses. One reason is the limitation of BCMA as a target, as BCMA is susceptible to γ-secretase-mediated shedding and antigen loss in some cases. 2. **CAR Structure Issue**: Existing CAR-T cell therapies primarily use artificially constructed single-chain variable fragments (scFv), which have issues with immunogenicity and stability. scFv may lead to anti-CAR immune responses and "tonic signaling" due to nonspecific membrane aggregation, resulting in premature T cell exhaustion. To address these issues, researchers used previously developed VHH antibodies targeting the mouse 5T33 MM cell epitope. These VHH antibodies have the following advantages: - High specificity and affinity. - No need for artificial formatting, as the natural monomeric form reduces immunogenicity. - Can be used for personalized treatment since each MM clone has its unique epitope (idiotype). By integrating these VHH antibodies into the CAR module, researchers compared the effects of different VHH antibodies on T cell activation. The results showed that although some VHH antibodies have high affinity, not all VHH antibodies can effectively activate T cells. Therefore, the study emphasizes the importance of selecting specific VHH antibodies and highlights the shortcomings in existing CAR development methods.