Abstract:Question Do current donation metrics adequately represent organ procurement organization (OPO) performance?Findings In this national study of 75 769 organ donors, OPO performance varied significantly over time and across donation metrics, which were not entirely described by population demographics. The performance of OPOs was positively associated with use of donors who were ineligible, which varied significantly among OPOs and demographic subgroups.Meaning Use of donors who are ineligible should be considered within OPO performance metrics to provide a more accurate assessment of performance, and this represents a target metric for improving organ availability.Importance Organ transplant is a life-saving procedure for patients with end-stage organ failure. In the US, organ procurement organizations (OPOs) are responsible for the evaluation and procurement of organs from donors who have died; however, there is controversy regarding what measures should be used to evaluate their performance.Objective To evaluate OPO performance metrics using combined mortality and donation data and quantify the associations of population demographics with donation metrics.Design, Setting, and Participants This national cohort study includes data from the US organ transplantation system from January 2008 through December 2017. All individuals who died within the US, as reported by the National Death index, were included.Exposures Death, organ donation, and donation eligibility.Main Outcomes and Measures Evaluation of the variation in donation metrics and the use of ineligible donors by OPO and demographic subgroup.Results This study included 17 501 742 deaths and 75 769 deceased organ donors (45 040 men [59.4%]; 51 908 White individuals [68.5%]). Of these donors, 15 857 (20.9%) were not eligible, as defined by the OPOs. The median donation metrics by OPO were 0.004 (range, 0.002-0.012) donors per death, 0.89 (range, 0.68-1.30) donors per eligible death, and 0.72 (range, 0.57-0.86) eligible donors per eligible death. The OPOs in the upper quartile of the overall eligible donors per eligible death metric were in the upper quartile of annual rankings on 90 of 140 occasions (64.3%). There was little overlap in top-performing OPOs between metrics; an OPO in the upper quartile for 1 metric was also in the upper quartile for the other metrics on 37 of 570 occasions (6.5% of the time). The median donor eligibility rate, defined as the number of eligible donors per donor, was 0.79 (range, 0.61-0.95) across OPOs. Age (eg, 65 to 84 years, coefficient, −0.55 [SE, 0.03]; P < .001; vs those aged 18 to 34 years), sex (male individuals, −0.09 [SE, 0.02]; P < .001; vs female individuals), race (eg, Black individuals, 0.35 [SE, 0.02]; P < .001; vs White individuals), cause of death (eg, central nervous system tumor, 0.48 [SE, 0.08]; P < .001; vs anoxia), year (eg, 2016-2017: −0.10 [SE, 0.03]; P < .001; vs 2008-2009), and OPO were associated with the use of ineligible donors; OPO was a significant factor associated with performance in all metrics (χ256, 500.5; P < .001; coefficient range across individual OPOs, −0.15 [SE, 0.09] to 0.75 [SE, 0.09]), even after accounting for population differences. Female and non-White individuals were significantly less likely to be used as ineligible donors.Conclusions and Relevance We demonstrate significant variability in OPO performance rankings, depending on which donation metric is used. There were significant differences in OPO performance, even after accounting for differences in potential donor populations. Our data suggest significant variation in use of ineligible donors among OPOs, a source for increased donors. The performance of OPOs should be evaluated using a range of donation metrics.

Impact of Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Final Rule on Organ Procurement Organization Metrics and Procedural Trends in the Procurement of Pancreata for Research

OPO performance improvement and increasing organ transplantation: Metrics are necessary but not sufficient

Assessment of National Organ Donation Rates and Organ Procurement Organization Metrics

Potential Implications of Recent and Proposed Changes in the Regulatory Oversight of Solid Organ Transplantation in the United States

Adjusting for race in metrics of organ procurement organization performance

Evaluating the Impact of Performance Improvement Initiatives on Transplant Center Reporting Compliance and Patient Follow-Up After Living Kidney Donation

The 20-year paradigm shift toward organ recovery centers: 2500 donors at Mid-America Transplant and broader adoption across the United States

Organ Procurement Organization Compliance with 21 CFR 1271: A Challenge for Allogeneic Pancreatic Islet Cell Transplantation Programs

The OPTN Expeditious Task Force: Improved Organ Utilization and Efficiency to Drive Transformational Growth in Solid Organ Transplant in the United States

Characteristics and Practices of High-Performing Centers in Organ Donor Identification and Referral: A Qualitative Study

COVID‐19 in organ donors: An organ procurement organization perspective

Pediatric donor heart utilization variability among organ procurement organizations

Market Factors, Not Quality, Influence Reimbursement for Pancreaticoduodenectomy in an Era of Price Transparency

In-house coordinator programs improve conversion rates for organ donation

Potential donor characteristics and decisions made by organ procurement organization staff: Results of a discrete choice experiment

The US Organ Transplantation System: HRSA's Modernization Initiative

Reinforcing Global Oversight of Organ Transplantation: Activity and Outcome Monitoring Through the Development of Registries

Current status: meeting the regulatory goals of your liver transplant program

Organ Utilization Rates from Non-Ideal Donors for Solid Organ Transplant in the United States

The Effect of State Policies on Organ Donation and Transplantation in the United States

Ethical and Policy Issues Arising in Crowdfunding for Solid Organ Transplantation: A Content Analysis of Newspaper Coverage of Recipient and Donor Fundraising Campaigns