Unveiling urban ecological integrity: spatially explicit assessment in contrasting environments

Richard Lemoine-Rodríguez,Michelle García-Arroyo,Miguel A. Gómez-Martínez,Meri Back,Tonje Lindeman,Ian MacGregor-Fors
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11252-024-01517-1
IF: 2.686
2024-02-13
Urban Ecosystems
Abstract:Although much attention has been paid to improve the representation of the urban spatial complexity, most efforts have been limited to the inclusion of green cover data to describe the biological component of cities, leaving the measurement of crucial urban ecological properties out of the picture. To tackle this, the Urban Ecosystem Integrity Index (UEII) was recently proposed to spatially represent the interplay between the intensity of urbanization and the biological components of cities, including urban biodiversity. The UEII has shown to be effective in measuring the ecosystem integrity of a Neotropical city; however its generalized applicability remains to be tested. Thus, here we tested the suitability of the UEII when applied in a boreal city and also evaluated if it adds more valuable information than the NDVI (also contrasting it with a UEII previously published for a tropical city), which is often suggested as a proxy of urban greenness and therefore the ecology of cities. We calculated the UEII by considering land surface temperature, built-up cover, and native plants and bird species richness of the city of Lahti, Finland (Palearctic; boreal). The UEII showed to be robust, comparable, and effective in capturing the intra and inter-urban spatial heterogeneity of both cities. Moreover, although the UEII and NDVI values correlated, the variance in such correlation showed the detail that the UEII brings to the quantificaiton of the ecological integrity of the cities, representing a more integral indicator. Thus, our findings indicate that the UEII is a valuable tool to inform on areas requiring ecological enhancement, as well as identifying those that are thriving, in cities ranging from tropical and highly biodiverse to boreal and with considerable less biodiversity.
biodiversity conservation,ecology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main aim of this paper is to address the following issues: 1. **Assessing Urban Ecological Integrity**: Proposing and testing a new method called the "Urban Ecosystem Integrity Index" (UEII) to quantify the ecological integrity of cities. This method considers the interaction between urbanization intensity (such as land surface temperature and building coverage) and biodiversity (such as the richness of local plant and bird species). 2. **Comparing Applicability in Different Environments**: Testing the effectiveness and generality of the UEII in two distinctly different ecological environments—a tropical city (Xalapa, Mexico) and a northern city (Lahti, Finland). Through this comparison, researchers can evaluate whether the index can provide valuable information in urban environments with different biodiversity. 3. **Comparison with the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI)**: Comparing the UEII with the commonly used Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) to determine if the UEII can provide more detailed and comprehensive information about urban ecological conditions. The study shows that the UEII not only effectively captures the spatial heterogeneity of ecological integrity within cities but also provides richer information than the NDVI, especially in distinguishing the ecological value of different types of green spaces. In summary, the core objective of this study is to develop a new tool to more accurately measure and understand the health of urban ecosystems in different environmental contexts and to validate the effectiveness and practicality of this tool.