Importing Clothing Made from Recycled Textile Materials? A Study of Retailers' Sourcing Strategies in Five European Countries

Leah Marsh,Sheng Lu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16020825

IF: 3.9

2024-01-19

Sustainability

Abstract:This study examined retailers' sourcing strategies for clothing made from recycled textile materials in the five largest European clothing retail markets (i.e., the UK, Italy, France, Germany, and Spain), given the increasing availability of such products. The multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) was conducted based on the detailed country of origin and product assortment information of thousands of such clothing items for sale in these five EU countries from January 2021 to May 2023. The results show that EU retailers sourced clothing using recycled textile materials diversely from over 40 developing and developed countries across Asia, America, Europe, and Africa. The geographic location of supplying countries statistically affects the detailed assortment of recycled clothing that EU retailers import. However, apart from assortment diversity, no statistical evidence indicates that developing countries had advantages over developed ones regarding product sophistication, replenishment frequency, and pricing in the five EU markets. The study's findings offer new insights into the business aspects of recycled clothing and reveal promising global sourcing opportunities for such products. The results also imply a potentially significant shift in global apparel trade patterns as retailers embrace fashion circularity and expand sourcing clothing made from recycled textile materials.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the procurement strategies of the five largest clothing retail markets in Europe (the United Kingdom, Italy, France, Germany, and Spain) for clothing made from recycled textile materials.

Specifically, the study examines how these retailers source clothing made from recycled textile materials from over 40 developed and developing countries worldwide, based on detailed country of origin and product mix information for thousands of such clothing products sold in these markets from January 2021 to May 2023, using the Multivariate Analysis of Variance (MANOVA) method.

The study results indicate:

1. **Diversified Procurement Sources**: EU retailers sourced clothing made from recycled textile materials from over 40 countries across Asia, the Americas, Europe, and Africa, demonstrating a highly diversified procurement pattern.

2. **Impact of Geographic Location on Product Mix**: The geographic location of the supplier countries statistically influenced the specific mix of recycled clothing imported by EU retailers. However, apart from diversity, there was no evidence that developing countries had a significant advantage over developed countries in terms of product complexity, replenishment frequency, and pricing.

3. **Near-Sourcing**: Near-sourcing played an important role in the procurement strategies of EU retailers, especially for clothing targeting the high-end or luxury markets. Many EU countries were involved in the production of such clothing, and these products were often aimed at higher-end markets.

In summary, this study fills a research gap regarding the procurement strategies of EU retailers for clothing made from recycled textile materials and provides important new knowledge about the supply chain of such clothing. Additionally, the study results offer valuable references for fashion companies interested in expanding the sales of recycled clothing in the competitive EU retail market and help policymakers formulate appropriate policies to support EU businesses in procuring more recycled clothing and promoting circular fashion business models.