Abstract:Cooperation upholds life in organized societies, but its neurobiological mechanisms remain unresolved. Recent theoretical analyses have contrasted cooperation by its fast versus slower modes of decision making. This raises the question of the neural timescales involved in the integration of decision-related information, and of the participating neural circuits. Using time-resolved electroencephalography (EEG) methods, we characterized relevant neural signatures of feedback processing at the iterated prisoner’s dilemma (iPD), an economic task that addresses cooperation-based exchange between social agents. We then probed the ability of relevant EEG signals to indicate subsequent decision-making, and inspected game and behavioral conditions under which they do so - including timing. Participants played against an assumed co-player, and the neural activation at the game feedback stage was analyzed via event-related potential (ERP) and spectrotemporal analysis methods. As expected from value-based decision-making studies, ERPs were increased by cooperation, including the feedback-related negativity (FRN) and the P3. In addition, we report a late potential (LP) lateralized to left frontal regions, which was also modulated by cooperation. Slow-wave, delta-band activity associated to the LP component (termed ‘LP-delta’) was also found to be reduced for mutual versus one-sided cooperation feedback. We then addressed individually which of these feedback signals related to subsequent cooperation and when. Crucially, the FRN, P3 and LP-delta components were modulated by choice at the next round, although involvement of each component was contingent upon the current outcome type. Immediately after one-sided cooperation (‘sucker’s payoff’), differential signaling indicating future decision-making occurred at the relatively early FRN, decreasing in amplitude for player choices not to cooperate at the next round. For outcomes where the player did not cooperate at the co-player expense, P3 increases were associated with subsequent cooperation by the player. Following mutual cooperation rounds, and at a relatively late stage of feedback processing, modulations by forthcoming decision were found in the form of LP-delta desynchronizations that were prospective of further cooperation. We note that the decision to cooperate in the game can be based on predicting different aspects of the prospective interaction given the past realized outcome (e.g. whether ‘to sustain’ mutual cooperation or ‘to retaliate’ if it is one-sided). The results support information integration for cooperation decision-making at the iPD, beginning at different timescales and circuits, by such updating context. The specific case of verifying a partner’s cooperation entailed a shorter reciprocation response which was predictable by feedback signal changes at the immediately preceding trial. A neurally informed account of fast-mode dual-process mechanisms, and involvement of predictive coding principles in guiding cooperation with a partner at the iPD, are discussed. Highlights *FRN, P3 and late delta-band asymmetric frontal activity encode cooperation feedback *Decision to cooperate in iterated prisoner’s dilemma indicated by prior round signals *Speed of reciprocating partner’s cooperation correlates with single-trial activity

Belief updating during social interactions: neural dynamics and causal role of dorsomedial prefrontal cortex

The Dynamics of Belief Updating in Human Cooperation: Findings from Inter-Brain ERP Hyperscanning.

Human Frontal-Subcortical Circuit and Asymmetric Belief Updating

Decision-Making with Predictions of Others' Likely and Unlikely Choices in the Human Brain

Dissociable Neural Representations of Reinforcement and Belief Prediction Errors Underlie Strategic Learning

Neurocomputational mechanisms involved in adaptation to fluctuating intentions of others

Dynamic neural reconfiguration for distinct strategies during competitive social interactions

Modulation of Prefrontal Couplings by Prior Belief-Related Responses in Ventromedial Prefrontal Cortex

The Importance of the Lateral Prefrontal Cortex for Strategic Decision Making in the Prisoner’s Dilemma

Neural signals relating future cooperation from prisoner’s dilemma feedback are outcome-contingent

Event-related potentials in response to cheating and cooperation in a social dilemma game

Impact of Short Social Training on Prosocial Behaviors: An fMRI Study

Neural dynamics of two players when using nonverbal cues to gauge intentions to cooperate during the Prisoner's Dilemma Game

Neural Substrates of Updating the Prediction Through Prediction Error During Decision Making.

A calculus of probability or belief? Neural underpinnings of social decision-making in a card game

Trust or doubt? Neural resonance based on facial expressions in a deception game reflected by frontal EEG activities.

Neural mechanisms of cooperation and fairness in iterative prisoner's dilemma

Agency Modulates the Lateral and Medial Prefrontal Cortex Responses in Belief-Based Decision Making

The importance of working memory updating in the Prisoner’s dilemma

Effective cerebello-cerebral connectivity during implicit and explicit social belief sequence learning using dynamic causal modeling

Prior expectations about own abilities bias self-belief formation and hinder subsequent revision