Undesirable woody establishment is driven by herbaceous cover phylogenetics and abiotic conditions

Rolando Trejo-Pérez,Pierre-Luc Chagnon,Béatrice Gervais-Bergeron,Patrick Boivin,Jacques Brisson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11258-024-01471-0
2024-11-07
Plant Ecology
Abstract:Revegetation with herbaceous covers is widely employed to inhibit tree encroachment in managed areas. However, most studies have focused on species selection for inclusion in herbaceous seed mixtures, neglecting the effect of local contingencies such as soil conditions and native vegetation emerging from the seed bank. Here, we tested the potential of sown herbaceous seed mixtures and local site conditions to reduce the abundance and establishment of three undesirable woody species. We sowed herbaceous seed mixtures containing 3, 5, or 8 species in a recently cleared right-of-way. Over two consecutive years, we allowed spontaneous vegetation establishment. We measured three facets of its diversity: taxonomic, functional, and phylogenetic. We also evaluated how woody encroachment was spatially structured and influenced by soil physicochemical properties. Our findings show that herbaceous seed mixtures were poorly established, hence they did not significantly impact overall seedling establishment. We also observed that no "silver bullet" mechanisms effectively inhibit the establishment of multiple woody species. The inhibition of woody species also involved multiple mechanisms, with phylogenetic diversity metrics being the dominant predictors of tree encroachment in the first year. However, the significance of abiotic mechanisms intensified in the second year. This temporal shift added complexity to identifying the most effective vegetation management strategies for inhibiting invasive and undesirable species. Our study illustrates how successful revegetation strategies for inhibiting tree species should account for herbaceous seed mixture effectiveness under ideal conditions and ecological versatility (i.e., the ability of these species to regenerate and thrive in various soil types and climatic conditions). Hence, effective prevention of woody species establishment on bare soil sites linked to infrastructure projects necessitates a multifaceted approach that integrates sown plant diversity and a comprehensive understanding of soil properties and resident vegetation diversity.
ecology,plant sciences,forestry
What problem does this paper attempt to address?