Inter‐reporter differences in symptom burdens in Japanese children with cancer

Tomomi Hayase,Makiko Naka Mieno,Naoko Mori,Yuki Yuza,Hirozumi Sano,Shinya Osone,Daiichiro Hasegawa,Miho Ashiarai,Keitaro Fukushima

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/ped.15729

2024-02-28

Pediatrics International

Abstract:Background Recent studies about inter‐reporter differences and patient‐reported outcomes (PROs) in childhood cancer from Western countries showed that caregiver proxy reports tend to overestimate symptom burdens in comparison with children's self‐reports. However, the results from Western countries may not be generalizable to Asian countries. Methods This paper is a secondary analysis of a validation study of the Japanese pediatric version of the Memorial Symptom Assessment Scale including 88 dyads of children aged 7–12 years and 74 dyads of children aged 13–18 years and their caregivers. The study assessed the inter‐reporter differences of eight and 31 symptom burdens calculated as symptom scores in children aged 7–12 years and 13–18 years, respectively, and the association between inter‐reporter differences and the characteristics of children and caregivers. Results The majority of children and caregivers scored equally at the dyadic level for almost all symptoms. However, 37.5% of symptoms in children aged 7–12 years and 10.0% of symptoms in children aged 13–18 years showed significant inter‐reporter differences, suggesting a general tendency of caregivers to underestimate their children's symptom burden. The caregiver's age was the characteristic most frequently associated with magnitude of inter‐reporter differences. Conclusions Caregiver proxy reports may be a reliable source of PROs in Japanese children with cancer, as self‐reported and caregiver proxy‐reported symptom burdens were generally concordant. However, as some significant inter‐reporter differences were observed, an effort should be made within the medical community to evaluate the parent–child relationship to minimize inter‐reporter differences and achieve better symptom management.

pediatrics