Understanding barriers and facilitators to diet and physical activity modification in people with polycystic ovary syndrome: a mixed method systematic review
M. McGowan,R. Garad,G. Wadhwani,S. Torkel,V. Rao,A. Maunder,E. Osei-Safo,S. Cowan,L.J. Moran
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s0029665124000995
2024-05-09
Proceedings of The Nutrition Society
Abstract:Polycystic Ovary Syndrome PCOS is an endocrine disorder affecting 8 to 13% of reproductive aged women (1) . Dietary and physical activity changes are the first-line therapy to assist with symptom and weight management and to reduce the risk of reproductive, metabolic and psychological comorbidities (2) . However, women with PCOS have a higher weight, experience weight gain, and a higher prevalence of living in a larger body. Health care professionals (HCPs) play a crucial role in delivering diet and physical activity advice for people with PCOS. Thus, the aim of this systematic review is to understand the barriers, facilitators, experiences, and perceptions of engagement and compliance with diet and physical activity modifications in people with PCOS and in HCPs providing or referring people with PCOS to diet and physical activity modifications. A mixed-method systematic review was conducted with quantitative studies narratively synthesised and all studies thematically analysed. There were 68 eligible papers, including n = 59 (n = 5198) people with PCOS and n = 17 (n = 2,622) HCPs. Several themes were identified as impacting people with PCOS' ability to make diet and physical activity changes. HCP education on PCOS management through diet and physical activity was viewed by HCPs and people with PCOS to be inadequate, further impacting the quality of care and health outcomes. Dietary and physical activity advice delivered by a multidisciplinary team, including dietitians, was identified as a key component for change. Both people with PCOS and HCPs agreed that there was a need for individualised and PCOS-specific diet and physical activity advice. However, HCPs viewed that there was limited evidence supporting these recommendations and a lack of time to deliver this care. Weight stigma was identified as impacting both those in larger and smaller bodies with PCOS, reducing the quality of care and affecting self-perception and mental health. People with PCOS perceived that diet and physical activity are overly focused on weight loss and fertility, independent of their own personal motivations and goals. Systemic changes, including receiving diet and physical activity advice that meet the individual's needs, are necessary for leading to long-term sustainable changes and improvements in health outcomes. A multidisciplinary team approach and an overhaul of HCPs' perceptions and mentality of weight and weight-centric care for those with PCOS are essential in delivering effective diet and physical activity advice.
nutrition & dietetics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve
This paper aims to explore the barriers and facilitators faced by patients with Polycystic Ovary Syndrome (PCOS) when making dietary and physical activity changes. Specifically, the main research questions include:
1. **Experiences and Perceptions of PCOS Patients**: Understand the personal experiences, motivations, and goals of PCOS patients when making dietary and physical activity changes, as well as their views on these changes.
2. **The Role of Healthcare Professionals (HCPs)**: Evaluate the experiences, attitudes, and views of HCPs when providing or recommending dietary and physical activity advice, especially how they influence patient participation and compliance.
3. **Insufficiency of Existing Support**: Identify whether the current education and support for HCPs in PCOS management are sufficient, especially in terms of dietary and physical activity guidance.
4. **The Need for Personalized Advice**: Explore the needs and views of PCOS patients and HCPs regarding personalized and PCOS - specific dietary and physical activity advice.
5. **The Impact of Weight Bias**: Analyze how weight bias affects the quality of care, self - perception, and mental health of PCOS patients.
6. **The Necessity of Systemic Changes**: Discuss what systemic changes are required to achieve long - term sustainable health improvements, such as multidisciplinary team cooperation and changing the weight - centered care concept.
Through research in these aspects, the author hopes to provide more effective dietary and physical activity advice for PCOS patients and improve the care practices of healthcare professionals, thereby enhancing overall health outcomes.
### Key Findings
- **Insufficient HCP Education**: Both HCPs and PCOS patients believe that the current diet and physical activity education regarding PCOS management is inadequate, which affects the quality of care and health outcomes.
- **Importance of Multidisciplinary Teams**: Dietary and physical activity advice provided by multidisciplinary teams such as dietitians is considered the key to success.
- **Personalized Needs**: PCOS patients and HCPs unanimously agree that personalized, PCOS - specific diet and physical activity advice is required.
- **Time Constraints and Lack of Evidence**: HCPs consider that limited time and the lack of evidence to support personalized advice are the main challenges.
- **The Impact of Weight Bias**: Weight bias not only affects PCOS patients of large and small body sizes but also reduces the quality of care and affects self - perception and mental health.
- **Over - focus on Weight and Fertility**: PCOS patients believe that dietary and physical activity advice is overly focused on weight loss and fertility, ignoring their personal motivations and goals.
### Conclusion
To achieve long - term sustainable changes and health improvements, systemic reforms are required, including providing dietary and physical activity advice that meets individual needs, strengthening multidisciplinary team cooperation, and changing HCPs' views on weight and weight - centered care concepts.