Abstract:This study analyzes statistically and empirically whether the emergence of health issues around the world is able to lead to notable change in military security. With the emergence of the concept of human security and rapid increase of health threat around the world after the Post-Cold War, There has been a number of arguments that the significance of military security based on the realist theory would be devalued by the proliferating health security agenda. In particular, there is a traditional perspective within the government expenditure named “guns and butter” theory, a trade-off relationship between defense and welfare, which refers that an increase of spending in an area inevitably leads to a decrease in another area with limited tax revenue. In this context, this study estimates the effect of changes in the proportion of health expenditure on the proportion of defense expenditure by conducting regression analysis for all countries from 2000 to 2019, utilizing the PCSE model. As a result, it was found that a trade-off appeared in countries with low economic development level and military manpower, while there is a positive correlation between both spending in case of having high values. Based on this result, the study conducted an empirical review of six countries of the Asia-Pacific region to determine whether the moderating effect is significant at the individual country level. In this analysis, it turned out that the income level and the number of active military manpower indicates a significant moderating effect. In this regard, the research implies that the level of economic development and the military manpower structure are the factors that would change the relationship between the both expenditures. Throughout the analysis, It suggests that there is compatibility between health and military security concepts as well as that changes in military or economic factors exceed non-traditional security issues in the compilation of a military budget. Ultimately, this study implies it is impossible to grasp the mutual competitiveness in the “gun and butter” debate and it is revealed that the gun overwhelms the butter. Additionally, This accentuates that the suitability of realism is still valid in spite of the emergence of the new security concept.

Defense Expenditure and National Well-Being: Evidence from the G7 Countries

Defence spending and real growth in an asymmetric environment: Accessing evidence from a developing economy

Is defence expenditure a guarantee of human development? A panel data approach in the group of twenty

Military spending and economic growth: a panel data investigation

Does military expenditure crowd out health-care spending? Cross-country empirics

Military Expenditures and Economic Growth: Evidence from NATO and Non-NATO Alliances

An Analysis on Factors Affecting Trade-off between Defense and Health Expenditure with Emerging Securitization of Health Threat : Focusing on Six Countries’ in the Asia-Pacific Region

Impact of Defence Expenditure on Total Factor Productivity: New Insights from Panel Bootstrap Granger Causality

Defence Spending and Income Inequality. An Asymmetric Empirical Evidence from a Decomposition Analysis of Defence Spending in the Case of Greece

Military Expenditure Trends for 1960–2014 and What They Reveal

Geopolitical risk and military expenditures: Evidence from the US economy

The relationship between tax revenue, government expenditure, and economic growth in G7 countries: new evidence from time and frequency domain approaches

How military spending, economic growth, and renewable energy impacts ecological footprints in Next Eleven nations

Modelling the Dynamic Linkages Between Eco-Innovation, Urbanization, Economic Growth and Ecological Footprints for G7 Countries: Does Financial Globalization Matter?

Preventing Plunder: Military Technology, Capital Accumulation, and Economic Growth

Can sustainable resource management overcome geopolitical risk?

Macroeconomic Frameworks: Reconciling Evidence and Model Predictions from Demand Shocks

RELATION BETWEEN DEFENSE BUDGET, PURCHASING POWER PARITY, FOREIGN EXCHANGE, AND EXTERNAL DEBT WITH MILITARY STRENGTH: EVIDENCE FROM ASEAN COUNTRIES

Economic, Social, and Political Determinants of Environmental Sustainability: Panel Data Evidence from NEXT Eleven Economies

How education expenditures, natural resources, and GDP interact with load capacity factor in the presence of trade diversity index under COVID-19 perception: Evidence from G-7 nations

Defence Partnerships and Economic Dynamics: An Analysis in PESCO Countries