Superfluidity and Superconductivity in Neutron Stars

Nicolas Chamel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/universe10030104

IF: 2.8128

2024-02-22

Universe

Abstract:By compressing matter to densities up to several times the density of atomic nuclei, the catastrophic gravitational collapse of the core of stars with a mass M≳8M⊙ during supernova explosions and the neutron star left behind (see, e [...]

astronomy & astrophysics,physics, particles & fields

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Gamma-ray and X-ray luminosities from spin-powered pulsars in the full polar cap cascade model

Bing Zhang,Alice K. Harding

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.1303217

1999-11-03

Abstract:We modify the conventional curvature radiation (inverse Compton scattering) + synchrotron radiation polar cap cascade model by including the inverse Compton scattering of the higher generation pairs. Within the framework of the space-charge-limited-flow acceleration model with frame-dragging proposed by Harding & Muslimov (1998), such a full polar cap cascade scenario can well reproduce the $L_\gamma \propto (L_{\rm sd})^{1/2}$ and the $L_x \sim 10^{-3} L_{\rm sd}$ dependences observed from the known spin-powered pulsars. According to this model, the ``pulsed'' soft ROSAT-band X-rays from most of the millisecond pulsars might be of thermal origin, if there are no strong multipole magnetic components near their surfaces.

Astrophysics
Gapless superfluidity in neutron stars: Thermal properties

Valentin Allard,Nicolas Chamel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.108.015801

2024-03-12

Abstract:The interior of mature neutron stars is expected to contain superfluid neutrons and superconducting protons. The influence of temperature and currents on superfluid properties is studied within the self-consistent time-dependent nuclear energy-density functional theory. We find that this theory predicts the existence of a regime in which nucleons are superfluid (the order parameter remains finite) even though the energy spectrum of quasiparticle excitations exhibits no gap. We show that the disappearance of the gap leads to a specific heat that is not exponentially suppressed at low temperatures as in the BCS regime but can be comparable to that in the normal phase. Introducing some dimensionless effective superfluid velocity, we show that the behavior of the specific heat is essentially universal and we derive general approximate analytical formulas for applications to neutron-star cooling simulations.

Nuclear Theory,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena
Fluxtube Dynamics in Neutron Star Cores

Vanessa Graber

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/asna.201713441

2017-09-07

Abstract:Although the detailed structure of neutron stars remains unknown, their equilibrium temperatures lie well below the Fermi temperature of dense nuclear matter, suggesting that the nucleons in the stars' core form Cooper pairs and exhibit macroscopic quantum behavior. The presence of such condensates impacts on the neutron stars' large scale properties. Specifically, superconducting protons in the outer core (expected to show type-II properties) alter the stars' magnetism as the magnetic field is no longer locked to the charged plasma but instead confined to fluxtubes. The motion of these structures governs the dynamics of the core magnetic field. To examine if field evolution could be driven on observable timescales, several mechanisms affecting the fluxtube distribution are addressed and characteristic timescales for realistic equations of state estimated. The results suggest that the corresponding timescales are not constant but vary for different densities inside the star, generally being shortest close to the crust-core interface.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,Solar and Stellar Astrophysics
Fermionic Superfluidity: From Cold Atoms to Neutron Stars

Annette Lopez,Patrick Kelly,Kaelyn Dauer,Ettore Vitali

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2012.04149

2020-12-08

Abstract:From flow without dissipation of energy to the formation of vortices when placed within a rotating container, the superfluid state of matter has proven to be a very interesting physical phenomenon. Here we present the key mechanisms behind superfluidity in fermionic systems and apply our understanding to an exotic system found deep within the universe -- the superfluid found deep within a neutron star. A defining trait of a superfluid is the pairing gap, which the cooling curves of neutron stars depend on. The extreme conditions surrounding a neutron star prevent us from directly probing the superfluid's properties, however, we can experimentally realize conditions resembling the interior through the use of cold atoms prepared in a laboratory and simulated on a computer. Experimentalists are becoming increasingly adept at realizing cold atomic systems in the lab that mimic the behavior of neutron stars and superconductors. In their turn, computational physicists are leveraging the power of supercomputers to simulate interacting atomic systems with unprecedented accuracy. This paper is intended to provide a pedagogical introduction to the underlying concepts and the possibility of using cold atoms as a tool that can help us make significant strides towards understanding exotic physical systems.

Quantum Gases
Location and symmetry of superconductivity in neutron stars

Dmitry Kobyakov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.31725/0552-5829-2023-171-174

2023-10-27

Abstract:Earlier, it was a standard assumption that the entire core of neutron stars is superconducting. However, the matter contents in the inner core has been unknown even qualitatively, because the density of matter in that region is expected to be higher than the nuclear saturation density 0.16 $\mathrm{fm}^{-3}$. As a consequence, no reliable model exists that would describe the neutron star matter in the inner core of neutron stars. Thus, a possibility of presence of normal, nonsuperconducting, plasma in the inner core cannot be excluded as of today. This point is supported by the numerical calculations performed in [1]. The calculations are based on the equation of state and the proton Cooper pairing gap energy derived from the chiral effective field theory. The numerical results show that the superconducting gap goes to zero beyond the depth about 1 km below the crust-core boundary. Given that the stellar radius is of the order of 12 km, therefore the superconducting proton matter is expected to exist only in a thin layer at the tip of the outer core. Recently it has been realized that the symmetry of superconductor is anisotropic in the lasagna region of the pasta phases located at the bottom of the crust. However the question of whether this symmetry is continuous or discreet was unsolved. The numerical calculations performed in [1] have shown that the tunneling rate between the adjacent slabs in the entire range of the corresponding densities is negligibly small. Thus, a discreet model is necessary for the description of the lasagna region. Uncertainties and future directions of the research are discussed.

Nuclear Theory,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena
Magnetic Field Evolution in Superconducting Neutron Stars

Vanessa Graber,Nils Andersson,Kostas Glampedakis,Samuel K. Lander

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stv1648

2015-05-01

Abstract:The presence of superconducting and superfluid components in the core of mature neutron stars calls for the rethinking of a number of key magnetohydrodynamical notions like resistivity, the induction equation, magnetic energy and flux-freezing. Using a multi-fluid magnetohydrodynamics formalism, we investigate how the magnetic field evolution is modified when neutron star matter is composed of superfluid neutrons, type-II superconducting protons and relativistic electrons. As an application of this framework, we derive an induction equation where the resistive coupling originates from the mutual friction between the electrons and the vortex/fluxtube arrays of the neutron and proton condensates. The resulting induction equation allows the identification of two timescales that are significantly different from those of standard magnetohydrodynamics. The astrophysical implications of these results are briefly discussed.

Solar and Stellar Astrophysics
Neutron Stars and the High Density Equation of State

T. Klaehn,C. D. Roberts,D. B. Blaschke,F. Sandin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.3146212

2009-01-01

Abstract:One of the key ingredients to understand the properties of neutrons stars1 (NS) is the equation of state at finite densities far beyond nuclear saturation. Investigating the phase structure of quark matter that might be realized in the core of NS inspires theory and observation. We discuss recent results of our work to point out our view on challenges and possibilities in this evolving field by means of a few examples.
Coupling between superfluid neutrons and superfluid protons in the elementary excitations of neutron star matter

M. Baldo,C. Ducoin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.99.025801

2019-01-22

Abstract:Several phenomena occurring in neutron stars are affected by the elementary excitations that characterize the stellar matter. In particular, low-energy excitations can play a major role in the emission and propagation of neutrinos, neutron star cooling and transport processes. In this paper, we consider the elementary modes in the star region where both proton and neutron components are superfluid. We study the overall spectral functions of protons, neutrons and electrons on the basis of the Coulomb and nuclear interactions. This study is performed in the framework of the Random Phase Approximation, generalized to superfluid systems. The formalism we use ensures that the Generalized Ward's Identities are satisfied. We focus on the coupling between neutrons and protons. On one hand this coupling results in collective modes that involve simultaneously neutrons and protons, on the other hand it produces a damping of the excitations. Both effects are especially visible in the spectral functions of the different components of the matter. At high density while the neutrons and protons tend to develop independent excitations, as indicated by the spectral functions, the neutron-proton coupling still produces a strong damping of the modes.

Nuclear Theory
Superfluidity in Disordered Neutron Stars Crusts

J. A. Sauls,N. Chamel,M. A. Alpar

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2001.09959

2020-01-28

Abstract:Nonequilibrium conditions imposed by neutrino cooling through the liquid-solid transition lead to disorder in the solid crust of neutron stars. Disorder reduces the superfluid fraction, $\rho_s/\rho$, at densities above that of neutron drip, $\rho_d \approx 4\times 10^{11}\,g/cm^3$. For an amorphous solid crust the suppression of $\rho_s$ is small, except in the highest density regions of the crust. In contrast to the strong reduction in neutron conduction predicted for coherent Bragg scattering in a crystalline crust, the disordered solid crust supports sufficient neutron superfluid density to account for pulsar glitches.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,Superconductivity,Nuclear Theory
Superfluid vortices in neutron stars

O. Elgaroy,F. V. De Blasio

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361%3A20010160

2001-02-21

Abstract:A microscopic, quantum mechanical model for neutron vortices in the crust of a neutron star is presented. After a brief introduction to the Bogoliubov- de Gennes equations, which form the basis for our calculations, we present results for density distributions, vortex core sizes and vortex energies, both for an isolated neutron vortex and for the case when the vortex core overlaps with a cylindrical nucleus. Earlier results on the vortex core size are confirmed, indicating a much less dramatic variation of the vortex core size with density than predicted by the BCS formula.

Astrophysics,Superconductivity,Nuclear Theory
Superfluid quantum criticality and the thermal evolution of neutron stars

Hao-Fu Zhu,Guo-Zhu Liu,Jing-Rong Wang,Xufen Wu

2024-08-08

Abstract:The neutron star starts to cool down shortly after its birth by emitting neutrinos. When it is cold enough, the Cooper pairs of neutrons are formed, which triggers a superfluid transition. Previous works on neutron superfluidity are focused on the finite-temperature transition. Little attention is paid to the potentially important quantum critical phenomena associated with superfluidity. Here, we provide the first theoretical analysis of superfluid quantum criticality, concentrating on its impact on neutron star cooling. Extensive calculations found that superfluidity occurs within a finite range of nuclear density $\rho$. The density serves as a non-thermal parameter for superfluid quantum phase transition. In a broad quantum critical region, there is a strong coupling between the gapless neutrons and the quantum critical fluctuations of superfluid order parameter. We handle this coupling by using perturbation theory and renormalization group method, and show that it leads to non-Fermi liquid behavior, which yields a logarithmic $T\ln(1/T)$ correction to the Fermi-liquid specific heat $c_{n}\propto T$ and also markedly alters the neutrino emissivity. Quantum critical phenomena emerge at a time much earlier than the onset of superfluidity and persist throughout almost the entire life of a neutron star. At a low $T$, such phenomena coexist with superfluidity in the neutron star interior, yet occupying different layers. We include superfluid quantum criticality into the theoretical description of neutron star cooling and find that it obviously prolongs the thermal relaxation time. By varying the strength of superfluid fluctuations and other quantities, we obtain an excellent fit to the observed cooling data of a variety of neutron stars. Our results indicate the existence of an intriguing correlation between superfluid quantum criticality and the thermal evolution of neutron stars.

Nuclear Theory,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,Strongly Correlated Electrons,Superconductivity
Role of isospin physics in supernova matter and neutron stars

Bharat K. Sharma,Subrata Pal

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.82.055802

2010-10-28

Abstract:We investigate the liquid-gas phase transition of hot protoneutron stars shortly after their birth following supernova explosion and the composition and structure of hyperon-rich (proto)neutron stars within a relativistic mean-field model where the nuclear symmetry energy has been constrained from the measured neutron skin thickness of finite nuclei. Light clusters are abundantly formed with increasing temperature well inside the neutrino-sphere for an uniform supernova matter. Liquid-gas phase transition is found to suppress the cluster yield within the coexistence phase as well as decrease considerably the neutron-proton asymmetry over a wide density range. We find symmetry energy has a modest effect on the boundaries and the critical temperature for the liquid-gas phase transition, and the composition depends more sensitively on the number of trapped neutrinos and temperature of the protoneutron star. The influence of hyperons in the dense interior of stars makes the overall equation of state soft. However, neutrino trapping distinctly delays the appearance of hyperons due to abundance of electrons. We also find that a softer symmetry energy further makes the onset of hyperon less favorable. The resulting structures of the (proto)neutron stars with hyperons and with liquid-gas phase transition are discussed.

Nuclear Theory
Bulk viscosity in superfluid neutron star cores. III. Effects of $Σ^-$ hyperons

P. Haensel,K.P. Levenfish,D.G. Yakovlev

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361%3A20011532

2001-11-15

Abstract:Bulk viscosity of neutron star cores containing hyperons is studied taking into account non-equilibrium weak process $n+n \rightleftharpoons p+\Sigma^-$. Rapid growth of the bulk viscosity within the neutron star core associated with switching on new reactions (modified Urca process, direct Urca process, hyperon reactions) is analyzed. The suppression of the bulk viscosity by superfluidity of baryons is considered and found out to be very important.

Astrophysics
Gapless neutron superfluidity in the crust of the accreting neutron stars KS 1731−260 and MXB 1659−29

Valentin Allard,Nicolas Chamel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epja/s10050-024-01329-z

2024-05-31

The European Physical Journal A

Abstract:The interpretation of the thermal evolution of the transiently accreting neutron stars MXB 1659−29 and KS 1731−260 after an outburst is challenging, both within the traditional deep-crustal heating paradigm and the thermodynamically consistent approach of Gusakov and Chugunov that accounts for neutron diffusion throughout the crust. All these studies assume that the neutron superfluid in the crust is at rest. However, we have recently shown that a finite superflow could exist and could lead to a new gapless superfluid phase if quantized vortices are pinned. We have revisited the cooling of MXB 1659−29 and KS 1731−260 and we have found that gapless superfluidity could naturally explain their late time cooling. We pursue here our investigation by performing new simulations of the thermal relaxation of the crust of MXB 1659−29 and KS 1731−260 within a Markov Chain Monte Carlo method accounting for neutron diffusion and allowing for gapless superfluidity. We have varied the global structure of the neutron star, the composition of the heat-blanketing envelope, and the mass accretion rate. In all cases, observations are best fitted by models with gapless superfluidity. Finally, we make predictions that could be tested by future observations.

physics, particles & fields, nuclear
Imposing multi-physics constraints at different densities on the Neutron Star Equation of State

Suprovo Ghosh,Debarati Chatterjee,Jürgen Schaffner-Bielich

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1140/epja/s10050-022-00679-w

2023-12-17

Abstract:Neutron star matter spans a wide range of densities, from that of nuclei at the surface to exceeding several times normal nuclear matter density in the core. While terrestrial experiments, such as nuclear or heavy-ion collision experiments, provide clues about the behaviour of dense nuclear matter, one must resort to theoretical models of neutron star matter to extrapolate to higher density and finite neutron/proton asymmetry relevant for neutron stars. In this work, we explore the parameter space within the framework of the Relativistic Mean Field model allowed by present uncertainties compatible with state-of-the-art experimental data. We apply a cut-off filter scheme to constrain the parameter space using multi-physics constraints at different density regimes: chiral effective field theory, nuclear and heavy-ion collision data as well as multi-messenger astrophysical observations of neutron stars. Using the results of the study, we investigate possible correlations between nuclear and astrophysical observables.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,Nuclear Theory
Superfluid Spin-up: Three-dimensional Simulations of Post-glitch Dynamics in Neutron Star Cores

J. R. Fuentes,Vanessa Graber

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ad77d5

IF: 5.521

2024-10-20

The Astrophysical Journal

Abstract:Neutron stars show a steady decrease in their rotational frequency, occasionally interrupted by sudden spin-up events called glitches. The dynamics of a neutron star after a glitch involve the transfer of angular momentum from the crust (where the glitch is presumed to originate) to the liquid core, causing the core to spin up. The crust–core coupling, which determines how quickly this spin-up proceeds, can be achieved through various physical processes, including Ekman pumping, superfluid vortex-mediated mutual friction, and magnetic fields. Although the complex nature of these mechanisms has made it difficult to study their combined effects, analytical estimations for individual processes reveal that spin-up timescales vary according to the relative strength of Coriolis, viscous, and mutual friction forces, as well as the magnetic field. However, experimental and numerical validations of those analytical predictions are limited. In this paper, we focus on viscous effects and mutual friction. We conduct nonlinear hydrodynamical simulations of the spin-up problem in a two-component fluid by solving the incompressible Hall–Vinen–Bekarevich–Khalatnikov equations in the full sphere (i.e., including r = 0) for the first time. We find that the viscous (normal) component accelerates due to Ekman pumping, although the mutual friction coupling to the superfluid component alters the spin-up dynamics compared to the single-fluid scenario. Close to the sphere's surface, the response of the superfluid is accurately described by the mutual friction timescale irrespective of its coupling strength with the normal component. However, as we move deeper into the sphere, the superfluid accelerates on different timescales due to the slow viscous spin-up of the internal normal fluid layers. We discuss potential implications for neutron stars, and requirements for future work to build more realistic models.

astronomy & astrophysics
The equation of state of hot, dense matter and neutron stars

James M. Lattimer,Madappa Prakash

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physrep.2015.12.005

IF: 30.51

2016-03-01

Physics Reports

Abstract:Recent developments in the theory of pure neutron matter and experiments concerning the symmetry energy of nuclear matter, coupled with recent measurements of high-mass neutron stars, now allow for relatively tight constraints on the equation of state of dense matter. We review how these constraints are formulated and describe the implications they have for neutron stars and core-collapse supernovae. We also examine thermal properties of dense matter, which are important for supernovae and neutron star mergers, but which cannot be nearly as well constrained at this time by experiment. In addition, we consider the role of the equation of state in medium-energy heavy-ion collisions.
Unified description of superconductivity in neutron stars

Dmitry Kobyakov

2023-08-18

Abstract:In this paper, I study the location and symmetry of superconducting protons. Solving the Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff (TOV) equations based on the unified Barcelona-Catania-Paris-Madrid equation of state (BCPM EoS) and on the pairing gap calculations by Lim and Holt [1], I find that roughly 500 meters of the liquid core (with isotropic and continuous symmetry) and roughly 100-150 meters of the core-crust interface (with anisotropic symmetry) are superconducting, while the rest of the star is normal. To specify whether the superconducting symmetry is discreet in the pasta phase, I study the coexistence of the saturated nuclear and the pure neutron matter using EoS based on the chiral effective field theory (ChEFT). I find that the maximum pressure at coexistence is $P_{*}\simeq0.5\;{\rm MeV\,fm^{-3}}$. To verify the precision of the coexistence calculations I evaluate the surface and the Coulomb corrections using the compressible liquid drop model. I calculate the proton tunneling rate in the perfectly ordered slab region of the pasta phase and conclude that for the chosen EoS, the proton supercurrent tunneling between the adjacent slabs is negligible and the slab region should be described as a discreet symmetry system of quasi two-dimensional layers.

Nuclear Theory,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,Superconductivity
Superbursts from Strange Stars

Dany Page,Andrew Cumming

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/499520

IF: 5.521

2005-12-08

The Astrophysical Journal

Abstract:Recent models of carbon ignition on accreting neutron stars predict superburst ignition depths that are an order of magnitude larger than those observed. We explore a possible solution to this problem, that the compact stars in low-mass X-ray binaries that have shown superbursts are in fact strange stars with a crust of normal matter. We calculate the properties of superbursts on strange stars and the resulting constraints on the properties of strange quark matter. We show that the observed ignition conditions exclude fast neutrino emission in the quark core, for example, by the direct Urca process, which implies that strange quark matter at stellar densities should be in a color superconducting state. For slow neutrino emission in the quark matter core, we find that reproducing superburst properties requires a definite relation between three poorly constrained properties of strange quark matter: its thermal conductivity (K), its slow neutrino emissivity (ϵν ≃ QνT), and the energy released by converting a nucleon into strange quark matter (QSQM).

astronomy & astrophysics
Properties of Dense Matter in a Supernova Core in the Relativistic Mean-Field Theory

ZG Dai,KS Cheng

1998-01-01

Astronomy and Astrophysics

Abstract:We have used the Zimanyi & Moszkowski model in the relativistic mean-field theory to study the properties of asymmetric nuclear matter and the equation of state (EOS) for supernova matter. We find that even though muons are included in the chemical composition of neutron-star matter, this model still results in a small proton concentration so that only the modified Urea process occurs as a main neutrino reaction in neutron stars. This conclusion is opposite to that of the previous studies in the relativistic mean-field theory. The incompressibility of symmetric nuclear matter is consistent with both the experimental values extracted from the nuclear physics and the constraints placed on the EOS by observations of neutron star masses. If the EOS for supernova matter is described by this model, the prompt mechanism for Type II supervovae cannot work, but the EOS is likely to be favourable to the delayed explosion mechanism.

Superfluidity and Superconductivity in Neutron Stars

Gamma-ray and X-ray luminosities from spin-powered pulsars in the full polar cap cascade model

Gapless superfluidity in neutron stars: Thermal properties

Fluxtube Dynamics in Neutron Star Cores

Fermionic Superfluidity: From Cold Atoms to Neutron Stars

Location and symmetry of superconductivity in neutron stars

Magnetic Field Evolution in Superconducting Neutron Stars

Neutron Stars and the High Density Equation of State

Coupling between superfluid neutrons and superfluid protons in the elementary excitations of neutron star matter

Superfluidity in Disordered Neutron Stars Crusts

Superfluid vortices in neutron stars

Superfluid quantum criticality and the thermal evolution of neutron stars

Role of isospin physics in supernova matter and neutron stars

Bulk viscosity in superfluid neutron star cores. III. Effects of $Σ^-$ hyperons

Gapless neutron superfluidity in the crust of the accreting neutron stars KS 1731−260 and MXB 1659−29

Imposing multi-physics constraints at different densities on the Neutron Star Equation of State

Superfluid Spin-up: Three-dimensional Simulations of Post-glitch Dynamics in Neutron Star Cores

The equation of state of hot, dense matter and neutron stars

Unified description of superconductivity in neutron stars

Superbursts from Strange Stars

Properties of Dense Matter in a Supernova Core in the Relativistic Mean-Field Theory