Abstract:In the beginning it was simple: we injected a protein antigen and studied the immune responses against the purified protein. This elegant toolbox uncovered thousands of mechanisms via which immune cells are activated. However, when we consider immune responses against real infectious threats, this elegant simplification misses half of the story: the infectious agents are typically evolving orders-of-magnitude faster than we are. Nowhere is this more pronounced than in the mammalian large intestine. A bacterium representing only 0.1% of the human gut microbiota will have a population size of 109 clones, each actively replicating. Moreover, the evolutionary pressure from other microbes is at least as profound as direct effects of the immune system. Therefore, to really understand intestinal immune mechanisms, we need to understand both the host response and how rapid microbial evolution alters the apparent outcome of the response. In this review we use the examples of intestinal inflammation and secretory immunoglobulin A (SIgA) to highlight what is already known (Fig. 1). Further, we will explore how these interactions can inform immunotherapy and prophylaxis. This has major implications for how we design effective mucosal vaccines against increasingly drug-resistant bacterial pathogens Fig. 1 THE IMMUNE RESPONSE SHAPES THE FITNESS LANDSCAPE IN THE GASTRO-INTESTINAL TRACT.: The red arrows depict possible evolutionary paths of a novel colonizer along adaptive peaks in the intestinal fitness landscapes that change with the status of the host immune system. The flat surfaces represent the non-null fitness baselines (values x or y) at which a bacterium can establish at minimum carrying capacity. a In the healthy gut, metabolic competence, resistance to aggressions by competitors and predators, swift adaptation to rapid fluctuations as well as surviving acidic pH and the flow of the intestinal content, represent potent selective pressures and as many opportunities for bacteria to increase fitness by phenotypic or genetic variations. b When pathogens trigger acute inflammation, bacteria must adapt to iron starvation, killing by immune cells and antimicrobial peptides, and oxidative stress, while new metabolic opportunities emerge. c When high-affinity SIgA are produced against a bacterium, e.g., after oral vaccination, escape of SIgA by altering or losing surface epitopes becomes crucial for maximum fitness. However, escaping polyvalent SIgA responses after vaccination with "evolutionary trap" vaccines leads to evolutionary trade-offs: A fitness maximum is reached in the vaccinated host gut that represents a major disadvantage for transmission into naïve hosts (fitness diminished below x) (d).

Pathogen evolution: Protective microbes act as a double-edged sword

Incomplete immunity in a natural animal-microbiota interaction selects for higher pathogen virulence

Experimental evolution of a pathogen confronted with innate immune memory increases variation in virulence

Links between Innate and Adaptive Immunity Can Favor Evolutionary Persistence of Immunopathology

When experimental selection for virulence leads to loss of virulence

How infection-triggered pathobionts influence virulence evolution

When the microbiome shapes the host: immune evolution implications for infectious disease

Eco-evolutionary control of pathogens

Within-host competition sparks pathogen molecular evolution and perpetual microbiota dysbiosis

Darwin review: the evolution of virulence in human pathogens

Experimental evolution of insect immune memory versus pathogen resistance

Making a pathogen? Evaluating the impact of protist predation on the evolution of virulence in

PATHOGEN GROWTH AND VIRULENCE DYNAMICS DRIVE THE HOST EVOLUTION AGAINST COINFECTIONS

Prior exposure to pathogens augments host heterogeneity in susceptibility and has key epidemiological consequences

Building pyramids against the evolutionary emergence of pathogens

The evolution of regulated cell death pathways in animals and their evasion by pathogens

Multispecies interactions and the community context of the evolution of virulence

A speed limit on serial strain replacement from original antigenic sin

Defensins Versus Pathogens: an Unfolding Story

Host–pathogen coevolution promotes the evolution of general, broad-spectrum resistance and reduces foreign pathogen spillover risk

Resistance is futile? Mucosal immune mechanisms in the context of microbial ecology and evolution