Similarities and differences among selected gemmological varieties of chalcedony: chemistry, mineralogy and microstructure

Sara Monico,Marco Cantaluppi,Valeria Diella,G. Diego Gatta,Ilaria Adamo,Patrizia Fumagalli,Nicoletta Marinoni
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1180/mgm.2023.92
2024-02-16
Mineralogical Magazine
Abstract:Abstract This study describes a new variety of chalcedony with a unique inhomogeneous bluish green hue, named aquaprase. It was discovered in Africa and is considered to be a valuable addition to the gem trade. A multi-methodological approach was used to examine its chemistry, mineralogy and microstructure, which were then compared to those of chrysoprase and agate, two of the most popular varieties of chalcedony. Optical microscopy revealed a complex microstructural heterogeneity in the different colour intensity areas/bands of aquaprase and agate, whereas chrysoprase exhibited a more homogeneous coexistence of micro- and cryptocrystalline quartz. High-resolution synchrotron XRD was essential for highlighting the complex assemblage of various types of α-quartz in aquaprase and agate (which differ in terms of crystal size and/or cell parameters). Micro-Raman spectroscopy revealed α-quartz and moganite in all three varieties of chalcedony and the presence of the nickel-bearing layered silicate mineral, willemseite, in chrysoprase, which is responsible for its green colouration. The chemical analysis displayed a homogeneous composition of agate, as well as high levels of nickel content in the chrysoprase variety. Aquaprase showed significant amounts (ppm by weight) of trace elements (Al, Mg, Na, K, Ca, Ti, U and Fe) characteristic of its formation environment, as well as high values of Cr, which are thought to be the cause of its bluish green colouration.
mineralogy
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is the comparative analysis of a newly discovered variety of chalcedony—Aquaprase—with two known varieties of chalcedony—Chrysoprase and Agate—through multi-method research in chemistry, mineralogy, and microstructure. Specifically, the paper aims to: 1. **Describe the characteristics of the new variety Aquaprase**: Aquaprase is a new variety of chalcedony with a unique uneven blue-green hue, first discovered in Africa, and is considered to have significant value in the gemstone trade. 2. **Compare the chemical composition of different chalcedony varieties**: Through chemical analysis, explore the similarities and differences in elemental composition among Aquaprase, Chrysoprase, and Agate. 3. **Analyze mineralogical characteristics**: Using techniques such as high-resolution synchrotron X-ray diffraction (HR-SXRD) and micro-Raman spectroscopy, study in detail the mineral phases and their distribution in the three varieties of chalcedony. 4. **Study the microstructure**: Observe the microstructure of different color regions through an optical microscope to reveal their complexity. 5. **Explore the formation environment**: Through trace element analysis, investigate the formation environment of Aquaprase and its differences from other chalcedony varieties. Overall, the paper aims to comprehensively understand the properties of Aquaprase and compare it with known varieties of chalcedony, in order to provide scientific evidence for gemological research and market applications.