The immediate integration of semantic selectional restrictions of Chinese social hierarchical verbs with extralinguistic social hierarchical information in comprehension

Yajiao Shi,Tongquan Zhou,Simin Zhao,Zhenghui Sun,Zude Zhu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/langcog.2024.11
2024-03-20
Language and Cognition
Abstract:Social hierarchical information impacts language comprehension. Nevertheless, the specific process underlying the integration of linguistic and extralinguistic sources of social hierarchical information has not been identified. For example, the Chinese social hierarchical verb 赡养, /shan4yang3/, 'support: provide for the needs and comfort of one's elders', only allows its Agent to have a lower social status than the Patient. Using eye-tracking, we examined the precise time course of the integration of these semantic selectional restrictions of Chinese social hierarchical verbs and extralinguistic social hierarchical information during natural reading. A 2 (Verb Type: hierarchical vs. non-hierarchical) × 2 (Social Hierarchy Sequence: match vs. mismatch) design was constructed to investigate the effect of the interaction on early and late eye-tracking measures. Thirty-two participants (15 males; age range: 18–24 years) read sentences and judged the plausibility of each sentence. The results showed that violations of semantic selectional restrictions of Chinese social hierarchical verbs induced shorter first fixation duration but longer regression path duration and longer total reading time on sentence-final nouns (NP2). These differences were absent under non-hierarchical conditions. The results suggest that a mismatch between linguistic and extralinguistic social hierarchical information is immediately detected and processed.
psychology, experimental,linguistics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to explore the semantic selection restrictions of Chinese social hierarchy verbs and the real-time integration mechanism of social hierarchy information from foreign languages during sentence comprehension. Specifically, the study focuses on certain unique verbs in Chinese (such as "赡养," meaning "to support elders"), which have strict semantic requirements regarding the social hierarchy relationship between the agent and the patient. For example, the verb "赡养" requires that the social status of the agent is lower than that of the patient. The paper examines how readers process the semantic selection restrictions of such verbs and the consistency or inconsistency between the implied social hierarchy information of nouns in sentences during natural reading through eye-tracking experiments. The experimental design includes two types of verbs: social hierarchy verbs and social hierarchy irrelevant verbs, as well as two hierarchy sequences: matching sequences and mismatching sequences. The study focuses on how readers handle the inconsistency when the semantic selection restrictions of the verb conflict with the implied social hierarchy information of the nouns. The main findings indicate that when processing social hierarchy verbs with mismatched social hierarchy information, readers have shorter first fixation times on the sentence-final noun but longer regression path times and total reading times. In contrast, such differences were not observed when processing social hierarchy irrelevant verbs. This suggests that when there is an inconsistency between the intra-linguistic (semantic selection restrictions of the verb) and social hierarchy information, readers immediately detect this inconsistency, which subsequently affects the sentence comprehension process. This result supports the one-step model, which posits that all relevant information is immediately used to determine the meaning of the sentence. In summary, this paper addresses the specific process of how social hierarchy information influences language comprehension, particularly for Chinese. It reveals how the semantic selection restrictions of social hierarchy verbs and social hierarchy information from foreign languages are integrated under natural reading conditions.