Abstract:Secure instant group messaging applications such as WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, Matrix, and the Signal Application have become ubiquitous in today's internet, cumulatively serving billions of users. Unlike WhatsApp, for example, Matrix can be deployed in a federated manner, allowing users to choose which server manages their chats. To account for this difference in architecture, Matrix employs two novel cryptographic protocols: Olm, which secures pairwise communications, and Megolm, which relies on Olm and secures group communications. Olm and Megolm are similar to and share security goals with Signal and Sender Keys, which are widely deployed in practice to secure group communications. While Olm, Megolm, and Sender Keys have been manually analyzed in the computational model, no symbolic analysis nor mechanized proofs of correctness exist. Using mechanized proofs and computer-aided analysis is important for cryptographic protocols, as hand-written proofs and analysis are error-prone and often carry subtle mistakes. Using Verifpal, we construct formal models of Olm and Megolm, as well as their composition. We prove various properties of interest about Olm and Megolm, including authentication, confidentiality, forward secrecy, and post-compromise security. We also mechanize known limitations, previously discovered attacks, and trivial attacker wins from the specifications and previous literature. Finally, we model Sender Keys and the composition of Signal with Sender Keys in order to draw a comparison with Olm, Megolm, and their composition. From our analysis we conclude the composition of Olm and Megolm has comparable security to the composition of Signal and Sender Keys if Olm pre-keys are signed, and provably worse post-compromise security if Olm pre-keys are not signed.

The security analysis of the key exchange protocol based on the matrix power function defined over a family of non-commuting groups

A Linear Attack on a Key Exchange Protocol Using Extensions of Matrix Semigroups.

An Improvement of a Key Exchange Protocol Relying on Polynomial Maps

Cryptanalysis of a Key Exchange Protocol Based on a Congruence-Simple Semiring Action

Cryptoanalysis of a key exchange protocol based on a congruence-simple semiring action

Remarks on a Tropical Key Exchange System

Key Recovery on Several Matrix Public-Key Encryption Schemes.

Cryptanalysis of some Nonabelian Group-Based Key Exchange Protocols

Cryptanalysis of some protocols using matrices over group rings

Secure Key Exchange in Tropical Cryptography: Leveraging Efficiency with Advanced Block Matrix Protocols

Cryptanalysis of a Simple Three-party Key Exchange Protocol

The Matrix Reloaded: A Mechanized Formal Analysis of the Matrix Cryptographic Suite

On the Security of a Group Key Agreement Protocol and Its Improvement with Pairings

Computationally sound symbolic security reduction analysis of the group key exchange protocols using bilinear pairings

Security Research on an Information-Theoretically Secure Secret Key Agreement Using LDPC Matrices

A novel method for generating public keys involving matrix operations

Secure Multiparty Matrix Multiplication Based on Strassen-Winograd Algorithm

Analysis and Improvement of a Multi-Party Protocol for Finding the Eigenvalues of Matrices

Efficient Password-Based Authenticated Group Key Exchange Protocol

Security Analysis for a Mutually Partially Unbiased Bases–based Protocol

Matrix Power Function Based Block Cipher Operating in CBC Mode