Abstract:Growing access to different sources of airborne LiDAR, including data acquired from airplanes, helicopters and unoccupied aerial vehicles (UAVs), is transforming our ability to capture the 3D structure of forests at scale. However, considerable uncertainty remains as to how comparable structural metrics derived from these various platforms are to each other. Using LiDAR data acquired concurrently from airplanes and UAVs across 115 sites in an open‐canopy woodland ecosystem in Australia, we tested the robustness of 32 commonly used canopy structural metrics. We show that many widely used canopy structural metrics show poor agreement between these two platforms, but were also able to identify a subset of metrics that provide a robust and ecologically intuitive way of characterizing the structure of open‐canopy forests worldwide. LiDAR data acquired from airplanes and helicopters – known as airborne laser scanning (ALS) – are widely regarded as the gold standard for characterizing the 3D structure of forests at scale. But in the last decade, advances in unoccupied aerial vehicle (UAV) technologies have led to a rapid rise in the use of UAV laser scanning (ULS) for mapping forest structure. As both ALS and ULS data become increasingly available, they are being used to derive an ever‐growing number of metrics designed to measure different facets of canopy structure. However, which metrics can be robustly retrieved from both ALS and ULS platforms remains unclear. To address this question, we acquired coincident, high‐density ALS and ULS scans covering 115 plots (4‐ha in size) in an open‐canopy temperate ecosystem in Western Australia. Using this unique dataset, we quantified 32 canopy structural metrics related to canopy height, openness and heterogeneity, including metrics calculated directly from the point clouds and ones measured from derived canopy height models (CHM). Overall, we found that ALS and ULS‐derived metrics were strongly correlated (r2 = 0.90). However, this high degree of correlation masked considerable systematic differences between platforms. Specifically, point cloud metrics were less strongly (r2 = 0.87) correlated and had higher bias (10.7%) compared to CHM‐derived ones (r2 = 0.98; bias = 2.5%). Similarly, metrics of canopy openness and heterogeneity were less strongly correlated (r2 = 0.84 and 0.87) and exhibited greater bias (14.4 and 7.9%) than ones relating to canopy height (r2 = 0.96; bias = 3.8%). Our results indicate that only a small subset of the 32 metrics we tested were directly comparable between ALS and ULS platforms. Consequently, future efforts to combine laser scanning data across platforms and instruments should think carefully about which metrics are most appropriate, especially when working with point cloud data.

Evaluating the reliability of bi-temporal canopy height model generated from airborne laser scanning for monitoring forest growth in boreal forest region

An adaptive directional model for estimating vegetation canopy height using space-borne photon counting laser altimetry data

Analysis of the Spatial Differences in Canopy Height Models from UAV LiDAR and Photogrammetry

Comparison of Canopy Height Metrics from Airborne Laser Scanner and Aerial/Satellite Stereo Imagery to Assess the Growing Stock of Hemiboreal Forests

Tree Height Growth Measurement with Single-Scan Airborne, Static Terrestrial and Mobile Laser Scanning

Assessment of approaches for monitoring forest structure dynamics using bi-temporal digital aerial photogrammetry point clouds

Estimation of canopy height based on multi-source remote sensing data using forest structure aided sample selection

A comparative analysis of modeling approaches and canopy height-based data sources for mapping forest growing stock volume in a northern subtropical ecosystem of China

Using canopy height model derived from UAV imagery as an auxiliary for spectral data to estimate the canopy cover of mixed broadleaf forests

Robust retrieval of forest canopy structural attributes using multi‐platform airborne LiDAR

Estimating Forest Canopy Height based on GEDI Lidar Data and Multi-source Remote Sensing Images

UAV leaf-on, leaf-off and ALS-aided tree height: A case study on the trees in the vicinity of roads

Forest canopy height modelling based on photogrammetric data and machine learning methods

Regionalization of an Existing Global Forest Canopy Height Model for Forests of the Southern United States

Integrating UAV-SfM and Airborne Lidar Point Cloud Data to Plantation Forest Feature Extraction

Analyzing the Saturation of Growing Stem Volume Based on ZY-3 Stereo and Multispectral Images in Planted Coniferous Forest

Improving Measurement of Forest Structural Parameters by Co-Registering of High Resolution Aerial Imagery and Low Density LiDAR Data

Feasibility of Bi-Temporal Airborne Laser Scanning Data in Detecting Species-Specific Individual Tree Crown Growth of Boreal Forests

Forest Canopy Height Mapping by Synergizing ICESat-2, Sentinel-1, Sentinel-2 and Topographic Information Based on Machine Learning Methods

Regional Sampling of Forest Canopy Covers Using UAV Visible Stereoscopic Imagery for Assessment of Satellite-Based Products in Northeast China

Integrating multi-source remote sensing data for mapping boreal forest canopy height and species in interior Alaska in support of radar modeling