Abstract:Solution robustness focuses on structural similarities between the nominal solution and the scenario solutions. Most other robust optimization approaches focus on the quality robustness and only evaluate the relevance of their solutions through the objective function value. However, it can be more important to optimize the solution robustness and, once the uncertainty is revealed, find an alternative scenario solution $x^s$ which is as similar as possible to the nominal solution $x^{nom}$. This for example occurs when the robust solution is implemented on a regular basis or when the uncertainty is revealed late. We call this distance between $x^{nom}$ and $x^s$ the solution cost. We consider the proactive problem which minimizes the average solution cost over a discrete set of scenarios while ensuring the optimality of the nominal objective of $x^{nom}$. We show for two different solution distances $d_{val}$ and $d_{struct}$ that the proactive problem is NP-hard for both the integer min-cost flow problem with uncertain arc demands and for the integer max-flow problem with uncertain arc capacities. For these two problems, we prove that once the uncertainty is revealed, even identifying a reactive solution $x^r$ with a minimal distance to a given solution $x^{nom}$ is NP-hard for $d_{struct}$, and that it is polynomial for $d_{val}$. We highlight the benefits of solution robustness in a case study on a railroad planning problem. First, we compare our proactive approach to the anchored and the $k$-distance approaches. Then, we show the efficiency of the proactive solution over reactive solutions. Finally, we illustrate the solution cost reduction when relaxing the optimality constraint on the nominal objective of the proactive solution $x^{nom}$.

Robust reverse 1-center problems on trees with interval costs

Inverse Vertex/Absolute Quickest 1-Center Location Problem on a Tree Under Weighted Norm

Unified approach to the inverse median location problem under the sum and the max objectives applying ordered median function

The sum of root-leaf distance interdiction problem with cardinality constraint by upgrading edges on trees

The Inverse $p$-maxian Problem on Trees with Variable Edge Lengths

The balanced 2-median and 2-maxian problems on a tree

Matroid and Knapsack Center Problems

Inverse Minimum Spanning Tree Problem and Reverse Shortest-Path Problem with Discrete Values*

The 1-Center and 1-Highway problem

Some inverse optimization problems under the Hamming distance

Downgrading to Minimize Connectivity

Constrained Inverse Minimum Spanning Tree Problems under the Bottleneck-Type Hamming Distance

Recoverable Robust Shortest Path Problem Under Interval Budgeted Uncertainty Representations

Precedence-Constrained Arborescences

A solution robustness approach applied to network optimization problems

Target-oriented Robust Location-Transportation Problem with Service-Level Measure

The Two-Center Problem of Uncertain Points on Trees

Robust Counterpart Models for Fresh Agricultural Product Routing Planning Considering Carbon Emissions and Uncertainty

Robust facility location in reverse logistics

Large-scale robustness-oriented efficient edge addition through traversal tree-based weak edge identification

A Lagrangian Decomposition Algorithm for Robust Green Transportation Location Problem