Vincent P. Diego,Eron G. Manusov,Marcio Almeida,Sandra Laston,David Ortiz,John Blangero,Sarah Williams-Blangero
Abstract:Statistical genetic models of genotype-by-environment (G×E) interaction can be divided into two general classes, one on G×E interaction in response to dichotomous environments (e.g., sex, disease-affection status, or presence/absence of an exposure) and the other in response to continuous environments (e.g., physical activity, nutritional measurements, or continuous socioeconomic measures). Here we develop a novel model to jointly account for dichotomous and continuous environments. We develop the model in terms of a joint genotype-by-sex (for the dichotomous environment) and genotype-by-social determinants of health (SDoH; for the continuous environment). Using this model, we show how a depression variable, as measured by the Beck Depression Inventory-II survey instrument, is not only underlain by genetic effects (as has been reported elsewhere) but is also significantly determined by joint G×Sex and G×SDoH interaction effects. This model has numerous applications leading to potentially transformative research on the genetic and environmental determinants underlying complex diseases.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve
The paper aims to solve the problem of genotype - environment interaction (Genotype - by - Environment, G×E) modeling in statistical genetics. Specifically, the paper attempts to develop a new model that can simultaneously consider the effects of binary environments (such as gender) and continuous environments (such as social determinants of health, SDoH) on phenotypes. Through this joint model, the authors hope to reveal the complex interactions between genotypes and the environment, especially how these interactions affect the occurrence and development of complex diseases such as depression.
### Main research background
1. **Genotype - environment interaction**
- Existing genotype - environment interaction models can be divided into two categories: one is for binary environments (such as gender, disease status, exposed or not), and the other is for continuous environments (such as physical activity level, nutritional measurement, socioeconomic status).
- Binary environment models are usually applied to gender (male / female), disease status (affected / not affected) or environmental exposure (such as smoking / non - smoking, low - cholesterol diet / high - fat diet).
- Continuous environment models are applied to continuous age variables, physical activity levels, socioeconomic status variables, etc.
2. **Social determinants of health (SDoH)**
- Since the research started by Michael Marmot et al. in the 1970s, SDoH has become increasingly important in medical research, especially in exploring the causal mechanisms behind diseases.
- SDoH has also been widely used in mental health research, especially in the study of depression. Physiological studies have shown that stress (especially stress related to SDoH) is mainly associated with depression through the hypothalamic - pituitary - adrenal axis (HPA axis).
3. **Gender - specific effects**
- Existing evidence shows that gender has a significant impact on the genetic effects of depression. Therefore, gender and SDoH may jointly affect the phenotype of depression.
### Research objectives
1. **Develop a joint model**
- Develop a new statistical genetic model that can simultaneously consider the effects of binary environments (such as gender) and continuous environments (such as SDoH) on phenotypes.
- Through this model, researchers hope to reveal the complex interactions between genotypes and the environment, especially how these interactions affect the occurrence and development of depression.
2. **Application examples**
- Use the Beck Depression Inventory - II (BDI - II) to assess the severity of depressive symptoms, combined with the measurement of social determinants of health (SDoH), to explore how gender and SDoH jointly affect the phenotype of depression.
### Method overview
1. **Polygenic model**
- Establish a basic polygenic model to estimate the heritability of phenotypes and serve as the basis for more complex models.
- The model assumes that the phenotype vector \( y \) follows a multivariate normal distribution, and the expression is:
\[
y = X\beta + g + e
\]
where \( X \) is the covariate matrix, \( \beta \) is the intercept parameter and the vector of regression coefficients, and \( g \) and \( e \) are the unobserved random genetic effects and environmental effects, respectively.
2. **Genotype - environment interaction model**
- For binary environments, use the genotype - gender model (G×Sex), and decompose the total phenotype covariance into the within - female polygenic model, the within - male polygenic model, and the cross - gender additive genetic covariance.
- For continuous environments, use the genotype - social determinants of health model (G×SDoH), and model the genotype - environment interaction through variance and correlation functions.
3. **Joint genotype - environment interaction model**
- Construct a joint model that simultaneously considers the effects of binary environments (gender) and continuous environments (SDoH).
- This model contains five equations, which respectively describe the within - female variance and covariance, the within - male variance and covariance, and the cross - gender covariance function.
### Result overview
1. **Performance of individual models**
- Both the G×Sex model and the G×SDoH model are significantly better than the polygenic model, indicating the existence of significant genotype - environment