Exploring the spatial-temporal variations and policy-based driving force behind groundwater contamination and remediation research in past decades

Bo Li,Yaling Lu,Jiao Li,Hongqiang Jiang,Yuan Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-020-11382-y
IF: 5.8
2020-11-11
Environmental Science and Pollution Research
Abstract:Groundwater has been recognized as one of the most critical and vulnerable natural sources which is utilized in potable water supply, agricultural irrigation, and industrial manufacture worldwide. In past decades, groundwater issues have drawn more and more attention and enable groundwater contamination and remediation research achieve dramatic development. This study depicted the spatial-temporal evolution of groundwater contamination and remediation research by evaluating related literatures published from 1989 to 2017 based on databases of Science Citation Index, Social Science Citation Index, Conference Proceedings Citation Index-Sci, and Conference Proceedings Citation Index-Social Science and Humanities with Bibliometric Analysis and explored the policy-based driving force with laws and regulations collected from United States Code (U.S. Code) system and Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) system behind those variations. The results demonstrated a rapid growth of groundwater contamination and remediation–related publications, and the USA identified as the leading country in terms of contributing the largest number of articles and possessing the greatest influence. From the temporal view, scholars from different countries have made in-depth studies in the fields of groundwater, pollutants and groundwater quality, remediation materials, and remediation approaches. The spatial analysis demonstrated America and Asia are the two continents that have published the most articles. In the past decades, the evolutionary progress of groundwater research is demonstrated that the hot spots are developed from groundwater contamination and remediation to more specific researches. Simultaneously, laws and regulations about groundwater are developed as well and to some extent, those laws and regulations boost the development of groundwater contamination and remediation research publications. These findings, as important references, could be utilized to depict the evolutionary progress of groundwater contamination and remediation research and explore the directions and trends of this specific research field in the future.
environmental sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: **By analyzing the spatio - temporal changes in groundwater pollution and remediation research and their policy - driving factors from 1989 to 2017, reveal the research hotspots, development trends in the field of groundwater pollution and remediation, and the promoting role of relevant policies on the research**. The following are the main problems involved in the paper and the solutions: --- ### **1. Research Background and Objectives** - Groundwater, as an important source of drinking water for approximately 31.5% of the global population, is facing the dual threats of depletion and pollution. - In recent decades, groundwater pollution and remediation research has developed rapidly, but there is a lack of systematic analysis of its spatio - temporal evolution and policy - driving factors. - This paper aims to: - Describe the spatio - temporal evolution characteristics of groundwater pollution and remediation research; - Explore the promoting role of laws and regulations in this field; - Summarize research hotspots and development trends, and provide references for future research directions. --- ### **2. Main Problems Solved** #### **(1) Data Analysis: Spatio - temporal Distribution of Groundwater Pollution and Remediation Research** - **Problem**: How is the distribution of groundwater pollution and remediation research on a global scale? Which countries and regions are the leading forces in the research? - **Solution**: - Use bibliometric analysis to count 15,416 related literatures published from 1989 to 2017. - The results show that: - The United States is the country with the largest number of research and the greatest influence in this field. - Asia and the Americas are the two continents with the most published articles. - Research hotspots have gradually expanded from the early "groundwater pollution and remediation" to more specific fields, such as pollutant types, remediation materials and methods, etc. #### **(2) Policy - driven: Influence of Laws and Regulations on Research** - **Problem**: Have laws and regulations promoted groundwater pollution and remediation research? - **Solution**: - Collected 77 laws and 2,074 rules related to groundwater in the United States federal laws and regulations (such as the United States Code and the Code of Federal Regulations). - Compare and analyze the time distribution of laws and regulations with the change in the number of research papers. - The results show that: - The promulgation of laws and regulations is highly consistent with the growth in the number of research papers. - Key laws and regulations (such as CERCLA or Superfund Act) directly promoted the formation of research hotspots. #### **(3) Research Hotspots and Trends** - **Problem**: What are the research hotspots in the field of groundwater pollution and remediation? What are the future research directions? - **Solution**: - Extract high - frequency keywords and conduct classification analysis, and obtain the following four major research hotspots: 1. **Groundwater environment**: such as "hydrology", "transport", "soil", etc. 2. **Pollutants and water quality**: such as "arsenic", "nitrate", "heavy metals", etc. 3. **Remediation materials**: such as "zero - valent iron", "permeable reactive barrier", "wetland", etc. 4. **Remediation methods**: such as "modeling", "bioremediation", "adsorption", etc. - The results show that: - Chemical and physical remediation methods (such as zero - valent iron, adsorption) are still the research focus. - The research enthusiasm for bioremediation and mathematical modeling has declined. - Prevention of water quality and heavy metal pollution has become a new research hotspot. --- ### **3. Methods and Tools** - **Bibliometric analysis**: Used to count and visualize the spatio - temporal distribution of research papers. - **Social network analysis (SNA)**: Reveal the cooperation relationships among countries, institutions, and keywords. - **Gephi software**: Used to draw cooperation network diagrams and conduct cluster analysis. - **ArcGIS**: Combine geographical information and social network analysis to express spatial variables. --- ### **4. Conclusions** - **Spatio - temporal changes**: Groundwater pollution and remediation research has experienced explosive growth in the past three decades, and research hotspots have shifted from basic theories to specific applications. - **Policy - driven**: The promulgation of laws and regulations has significantly promoted the development of research, especially in key years (such as 199...