Methodologies for smellwalks and scentwalks—a critical review

Murray Parker,Dirk H R Spennemann,Jennifer Bond
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/chemse/bjae005
2024-02-13
Chemical Senses
Abstract:Abstract Olfactory elements of the human environment are essential with respect to culture, society, and heritage, and robust methodological approaches are necessary to identify and describe aspects of this sensory component. To accurately investigate and advance knowledge of olfactory composition of spaces and places, that is, a smellscape—an olfactory contextualized landscape—innovative methodologies such as smellwalks can be employed as part of the research approach. Despite the increasing use of smellwalks, there is no current standard methodology for this investigative method in practice. We identify major themes including variance of group size, participant versus researcher-led walking techniques, reinvention of smellwalking process, and methodological discussion and theory. Limitations and future research potential are suggested, including that of group dynamics, attribute focus, the extension of smellwalk attribute data beyond traditional hedonic attributes, and avenues for development of future processes and protocols for multisensory sensewalks.
behavioral sciences,food science & technology,physiology,neurosciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the standardization and systematization of research methods regarding "smellwalks" and "scentwalks". Specifically, although these research methods have been increasingly used in recent years, there is currently a lack of a standard methodology to guide their application in practice. By reviewing and analyzing existing literature, the paper aims to identify and discuss the various methods used in different studies, explore their advantages, limitations, and future research potential, thereby promoting further development and discussion in this field. The key topics of the paper include: - **Variation in participant scale**: Different studies have adopted different numbers of participants, ranging from individuals to groups. - **Participant - led and researcher - led walking techniques**: In some studies, participants choose their own routes and stopping points, while in others, they are preset by the researchers. - **Re - creation of the smellwalk process**: Different studies have carried out different degrees of innovation and adjustment to the smellwalk process. - **Methodological discussion and theory**: It explores the effectiveness and applicability of smellwalks as a research tool and how to better integrate multi - sensory experiences. In addition, the paper also points out potential directions for future research, including the influence of group dynamics, the expansion of the attribute focus, odor data collection beyond the traditional pleasantness attribute, and the future development and protocol formulation of multi - sensory perception walks. Through these analyses, the paper hopes to provide a more systematic and standardized methodological framework for smellwalk research to promote in - depth and extensive research in this field.