Abstract:Because the sophistication of tool use is vastly enhanced in humans compared with other species, a rich understanding of its neural substrates requires neuroscientific experiments in humans. Although functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) has enabled many studies of tool-related neural processing, surprisingly few studies have examined real tool use. Rather, because of the many constraints of fMRI, past research has typically used proxies such as pantomiming despite neuropsychological dissociations between pantomimed and real tool use. We compared univariate activation levels, multivariate activation patterns, and functional connectivity when participants used real tools (a plastic knife or fork) to act on a target object (scoring or poking a piece of putty) or pantomimed the same actions with similar movements and timing. During the Execute phase, we found higher activation for real versus pantomimed tool use in sensorimotor regions and the anterior supramarginal gyrus, and higher activation for pantomimed than real tool use in classic tool-selective areas. Although no regions showed significant differences in activation magnitude during the Plan phase, activation patterns differed between real versus pantomimed tool use and motor cortex showed differential functional connectivity. These results reflect important differences between real tool use, a closed-loop process constrained by real consequences, and pantomimed tool use, a symbolic gesture that requires conceptual knowledge of tools but with limited consequences. These results highlight the feasibility and added value of employing natural tool use tasks in functional imaging, inform neuropsychological dissociations, and advance our theoretical understanding of the neural substrates of natural tool use.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT The study of tool use offers unique insights into how the human brain synthesizes perceptual, cognitive, and sensorimotor functions to accomplish a goal. We suggest that the reliance on proxies, such as pantomiming, for real tool use has (1) overestimated the contribution of cognitive networks, because of the indirect, symbolic nature of pantomiming; and (2) underestimated the contribution of sensorimotor networks necessary for predicting and monitoring the consequences of real interactions between hand, tool, and the target object. These results enhance our theoretical understanding of the full range of human tool functions and inform our understanding of neuropsychological dissociations between real and pantomimed tool use.

Differences in Neural Activation between Actual Tool Use and Pantomime: Evidence for Two Different Streams?

Human Neuroimaging Reveals Differences in Activation and Connectivity Between Real and Pantomimed Tool Use.

Critical brain regions for tool-related and imitative actions: a componential analysis

Differences Between Actual and Imagined Usage of Chopsticks: an FMRI Study

fNIRS-Based Differences in Cortical Activation during Tool Use, Pantomimed Actions, and Meaningless Actions between Children with and without Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD)

Distinct Contributions of Dorsal and Ventral Streams to Imitation of Tool-Use and Communicative Gestures

Left anterior supramarginal gyrus activity during tool use action observation after extensive tool use training

Is there a left hemispheric asymmetry for tool affordance processing?

Dissociation and Association of the Embodied Representation of Tool-Use Verbs and Hand Verbs: an Fmri Study.

Disentangling representations of shape and action components in the tool network.

Imagined and Executed Actions in the Human Motor System: Testing Neural Similarity Between Execution and Imagery of Actions with a Multivariate Approach

Neural networks active during tactile form perception: common and differential activity during macrospatial and microspatial tasks

Praxis and Language Are Linked: Evidence from Co-Lateralization in Individuals with Atypical Language Dominance.

Different roles of lateral anterior temporal lobe and inferior parietal lobule in coding function and manipulation tool knowledge: Evidence from an rTMS study

Distributed and convergent representations of tools in human parietal and anterior temporal regions revealed by fMRI-RSA

Differential Representation of “toolness” and the Elongated Shape of Tools Revealed by Continuous Flash Suppression and Backward Masking

The "What" and "How" of Pantomime Actions

Shared and differential neural substrates of copying versus drawing: a functional magnetic resonance imaging study

The White-Matter Structural Network Underlying Human Tool Use And Tool Understanding

The functional brain networks that underlie Early Stone Age tool manufacture

Behavioral performance and visual strategies during skill acquisition using a novel tool use motor learning task