Alternative Risk Strategies
E. Gil'de
2004-09-01
Abstract:Alternative Risk Strategies, by Morton Lane, 2002, London: Risk Waters Group Ltd. As vividly revealed throughout Morton Lane's edited volume, Alternative Risk Strategies, the market strives incessantly towards greater efficiency. Alternative risk strategies comprise a set of relatively new approaches to risk management that essentially pose new capital market solutions to traditional insurance methods-and, in some cases, new insurance solutions to established capital market mechanisms. Examples include securitization of insurance liabilities (life insurance or property catastrophe risk), risk swaps, private equity capital guarantees, and M&A insurance. As defined in this book, the scope of alternative risk strategies extends to nontraditional investments by insurers, including asset-based securities and hedge funds. In each case, the impetus for developing these new strategies is improved efficiency in transferring or financing risk. Both the wide sweep of alternatives and the details of individual structures provide fascinating evidence of the creative innovation stimulated by market competition. The book is divided into six sections. The first describes different types of alternative risk structures, including reinsurance, CAT bonds, industry loss warranties, risk swaps, contingent capital, finite risk insurance, and captives. The second section includes three papers that focus on determination of market price for CAT bonds and reinsurance. The third section focuses on computer simulation models of catastrophe loss and terrorism risk. The fourth section, entitled "Industry-Specific Practices and Solutions," includes a variety of papers focusing on new developments in management of insurance company assets and liabilities. The fifth section includes essays dealing directly with risk management from a portfolio perspective. Finally, the last section focuses on accounting, legal, and regulatory issues associated with alternative risk transfer. Taken as a whole, the book's essays reveal a tension between the potential efficiency gains from alternative risk strategies and the fact that these so far have gained little foothold in the insurance industry. The reasons why are nearly as interesting as the solutions themselves. In addition, there is a nagging concern, echoed several places throughout the book, that the diversification benefits associated with particular risk strategies may break down in a crisis-exactly when you need them most. Overall, however, the contributors present an objective view of alternative risk strategies that is positive on balance. Although development on the insurance side admittedly has been slow, the authors take the position that alternative risk strategies will continue to grow in importance because they provide improved diversification opportunities compared to traditional mechanisms. The source of efficiency gains associated with these new risk strategies emanates from opportunities for merging and blending traditional insurance functions with activities previously restricted to banking. As Morton Lane states, "All of the contributions involve the intersection of insurance and finance. All the contributions involve transactions that have one party ceding risk and another party assuming it . . . . Sometimes this transfer takes place within insurance markets, sometimes between insurance markets and capital markets." Allen, Bain, Jones, and Shah (Chapter 28) view alternative risk strategies as having two components: (a) securitization of insurance liabilities and (b) "insuratization" of new kinds of risk. As such, the book includes several essays that focus on the most well-known example of insurance securitization: catastrophe bonds. Cummins, Lalonde, and Phillips (Chapter 2) argue that traditional reinsurance is not efficient because the market is subject to price and availability cycles. On the other hand, holding large amounts of capital to protect against catastrophe may not be efficient either. …
Business,Economics