Abstract:Human activities, such as tourism and hunting, affect the spatiotemporal behaviour of wildlife. For example, it is well documented that ungulates change their spatiotemporal behaviour as a response to hunting pressure, but less is known about ungulate responses to hunting in areas where human activity is common throughout the year and ungulates are constrained by fences. In this camera-trap study, we analysed the change in spatiotemporal behaviour of wild ungulates (elk, Cervus canadensis (3519 events), moose, Alces alces (1153 events), and white-tailed deer, Odocoileus virginianus (2708 events)) in response to the hunting period in a recreational and fenced park, the Cooking Lake–Blackfoot Provincial Area, Canada. We used general linear models to compare species-specific patterns of intensity of use, calculated as events per week, in response to changes in the nature of human disturbance, namely a shift from recreation to hunting activity. In particular, we compared intensity of use in and out of the hunting season to determine whether species engaged in spatial patterns of avoidance with respect to hunting. We used daily and seasonal patterns of activity to determine how ungulates shifted their temporal use in response to hunting activity and whether they became more nocturnal as a result. We found that ungulates responded temporally to the hunting period by generally shifting their activity to more nocturnal hours, with white-tailed deer showing the biggest temporal shift, suggesting that the ungulates distinguish between consumptive and non-consumptive human activities. Nevertheless, temporal overlap between humans and all ungulate species increased during the hunting period as humans targeted times of increased ungulate activity. Spatially, the response was less distinctive and was species-specific. Elk showed little change in spatial behaviour in response to the hunting period. In contrast, moose decreased the use of trail areas and other areas frequented by humans, whereas deer, counterintuitively, increased the use of trail areas, albeit their use became much more nocturnal. We have shown that responses of ungulates to hunting exceed those to non-consumptive recreational use, and whereas temporal responses (increased nocturnality) were consistent across ungulate species, spatial responses were species-specific. Management in small fenced multi-use areas needs to account for shifts in the intensity of disturbance resulting from a change in human disturbance from recreational activity to hunting. Providing spatial opportunities for avoidance of humans is key for most species if hours of operation in these areas already limit the timing of human activity.

The impact of seasonal cattle grazing on ungulate spatiotemporal behavior in a multiuse recreational area in central Alberta

Spatiotemporal responses of ungulates to hunting in a fenced multi-use area

Understanding an ecological tug of war: Disentangling competition between native and domesticated ungulates

Variable spatiotemporal ungulate behavioral response to predation risk

Spatial and temporal occurrences of prairie moose across an urban to rural gradient in Saskatoon, Canada

Anthropogenic activities influence spatiotemporal patterns of predator-prey interactions

The role of human outdoor recreation in shaping patterns of grizzly bear-black bear co-occurrence

Quantifying impacts of recreation on elk (Cervus canadensis) using novel modeling approaches

Influences of landscape change and winter severity on invasive ungulate persistence in the Nearctic boreal forest

Land cover preferences and spatiotemporal associations of ungulates within a Scottish mammal community

Mammal responses to human recreation depend on landscape context

Bison and bighorns: Assessing the potential impacts of reintroducing a large herbivore to a mountainous landscape

A Grazer in a Browser's Habitat: Resource Selection of Foraging Cattle in Productive Boreal Forest

A taste of space: Remote animal observations and discrete‐choice models provide new insights into foraging and density dynamics for a large subarctic herbivore

Weekend warriors: contrasting temporal patterns in the harvest of three species of boreal ungulates

Temporal niche partitioning among sympatric wild and domestic ungulates between warm and cold seasons

Effects of humans on behaviour of wildlife exceed those of natural predators in a landscape of fear

On-animal acoustic monitoring provides insight to ungulate foraging behavior

Comparing the impact of a grazing regime with European bison versus one with free-ranging cattle on coastal dune vegetation in the Netherlands

Influence of wildfire and feral horse use on mule deer summer range occupancy

Long-term cattle grazing shifts the ecological state of forest soils