Abstract:Background: Evaluating outcome reliability is critical in real-world evidence studies. Overall survival is a common outcome in these studies; however, its capture in real-world data (RWD) sources is often incomplete and supplemented with linked mortality information from external sources. Conflicting recommendations exist for censoring overall survival in real-world evidence studies. This simulation study aimed to understand the impact of different censoring methods on estimating median survival and log hazard ratios when external mortality information is partially captured. Methods: We used Monte Carlo simulation to emulate a non-randomized comparative effectiveness study of two treatments with RWD from electronic health records and linked external mortality data. We simulated the time to death, the time to last database activity, and the time to data cutoff. Death events after the last database activity were attributed to linked external mortality data and randomly set to missing to reflect the sensitivity of contemporary real-world data sources. Two censoring schemes were evaluated: (1) censoring at the last activity date and (2) censoring at the end of data availability (data cutoff) without an observed death. We assessed the performance of each method in estimating median survival and log hazard ratios using bias, coverage, variance, and rejection rate under varying amounts of incomplete mortality information and varying treatment effects, length of follow-up, and sample size. Results: When mortality information was fully captured, median survival estimates were unbiased when censoring at data cutoff and underestimated when censoring at the last activity. When linked mortality information was missing, censoring at the last activity date underestimated the median survival, while censoring at the data cutoff overestimated it. As missing linked mortality information increased, bias decreased when censoring at the last activity date and increased when censoring at data cutoff. Conclusions: Researchers should consider the completeness of linked external mortality information when choosing how to censor the analysis of overall survival using RWD. Substantial bias in median survival estimates can occur if an inappropriate censoring scheme is selected. We advocate for RWD providers to perform validation studies of their mortality data and publish their findings to inform methodological decisions better.

Survival analysis under imperfect record linkage using historic census data

The impact of different censoring methods for analyzing survival using real-world data with linked mortality information: a simulation study

Linkage of Administrative Datasets: Enhancing Longitudinal Epidemiological Studies in the Era of “Big Data”

CASE-CONTROL SURVIVAL ANALYSIS WITH A GENERAL SEMIPARAMETRIC SHARED FRAILTY MODEL - A PSEUDO FULL LIKELIHOOD APPROACH

Long-term effect estimation when combining clinical trial and observational follow-up datasets

Non-parametric cure rate estimation under insufficient follow-up using extremes

Vital Status Ascertainment for a Historic Diverse Cohort of U.S. Women

The Reliability of Multi‐source Data Linkage for Population‐based Cancer Survival Estimates: A Study in a Metropolitan Cancer Registry of China

Landscape analysis of environmental data sources for linkage with SEER cancer patients database

Improving our understanding of the social determinants of mental health: a data linkage study of mental health records and the 2011 UK census

Impact of linkage level on inferences from big data analyses in health and medical research: an empirical study

Using Geographic Location-based Public Health Features in Survival Analysis

Temporal graph-based clustering for historical record linkage

An Introduction to Probabilistic Record Linkage with a Focus on Linkage Processing for WTC Registries

Advances in statistical methods for cancer surveillance research: an age-period-cohort perspective

A Bayesian Approach to Graphical Record Linkage and De-duplication

SURVIVAL ANALYSIS IN PUBLIC HEALTH RESEARCH

Addressing an Idiosyncrasy in Estimating Survival Curves Using Double Sampling in the Presence of Self‐Selected Right Censoring

Risk-Adjusted Incidence Modeling on Hierarchical Survival Data with Recurrent Events

Advancement of Statistical Theory and Methods for Survival Analysis, Longitudinal Data Analysis, and Missing Data Problems in United Kingdom

Left-censored recurrent event analysis in epidemiological studies: a proposal when the number of previous episodes is unknown