Feeding selectivity and a functional trade-off in a benthic fish with a continuous morphological variation: an experimental test

Chiharu Endo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s40850-024-00194-z

2024-03-04

BMC Zoology

Abstract:Abstract Background Functional trade-offs through ecological specializations are hypothesized to become causes of adaptive phenotypic divergence under divergent natural selection, where intermediate phenotypes may have the lowest fitness. Evidence of phenotypic divergence in a trade-off between populations experiencing different environmental/ecological conditions is abundant. However, traits in divergent selection sometimes present non-discrete (unimodal) variability, including intermediate phenotypes, although the underlying mechanisms are poorly documented. A benthic cyprinid fish, Pseudogobio esocinus , in Lake Biwa, central Japan, exhibits a large non-discrete/continuous variation in mouthpart morphology (from wide to narrow) within a lake population. The variation is linked with individual diets (i.e., the compositions of two different types of prey) even at a single site, and thus the variability is hypothesized to persist under divergent selection for prey usage. As a first step toward understanding the persistence mechanisms, here I examined the presence of morphology-dependent feeding selectivity and a functional trade-off in a laboratory experiment. Results When each experimental fish was simultaneously provided the different types of prey (chironomid larvae and amphipods), the fish mostly utilized chironomid larvae as primary prey. However, compared with the wider-mouthed fish, the narrower-mouthed fish took a larger proportion of amphipods as secondary prey by changing feeding (attacking) behavior. The intermediate-mouthed fish had lower feeding efficiency than the extreme-mouthed fish, indicating potential disadvantage of the intermediate phenotype. Conclusions This experimental result supports the presence of morphology-dependent feeding performance and a functional trade-off with potential impacts on trait variability, which may favor specializations rather than generalizations. In the wild, however, there may be some situations for relaxing the trade-off, such as temporally fluctuating prey availability that could also favor generalizations depending on the conditions, and thus, both extreme and intermediate phenotypes may persist/coexist in a single habitat. Although further examinations, especially focusing on feeding efficiency for each prey type separated from the effects of prey selectivity, are needed, this case represents an opportunity to consider the possible mechanisms of the persistence of phenotypic variation that is maintained without divergence even in a trade-off.

zoology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how functional trade - offs affect the feeding selectivity and efficiency of individuals in a fish population with continuous morphological variation, and whether such functional trade - offs lead to the disadvantageous position of intermediate phenotypes under natural selection. Specifically, the study focuses on whether there are differences in the feeding behavior and efficiency of benthic Cyprinidae fish (Pseudogobio esocinus) in Lake Biwa, Japan, with different mouth morphologies towards two main prey items (chironomid larvae and water lice), especially whether individuals with intermediate morphologies are at a disadvantage.

### Research Background
- **Functional Trade - offs**: Under different ecological environmental conditions, the functional trade - offs generated by species to adapt to specific resources may lead to adaptive phenotypic differentiation. In this case, intermediate phenotypes may have the lowest fitness.
- **Research Object**: Pseudogobio esocinus shows continuous mouth morphological variation from wide to narrow in Lake Biwa. This variation is related to the diet composition of individuals, that is, wide - mouthed individuals mainly prey on chironomid larvae buried in the sandy bottom, while narrow - mouthed individuals prey more on water lice in the water column.
- **Research Purpose**: Verify the differences in feeding selectivity and efficiency of individuals with different mouth morphologies through experiments, and explore the functional trade - offs of intermediate phenotypes and their disadvantageous positions under natural selection.

### Experimental Design
- **Sample Collection**: 22 adult fish were captured from a sampling site in Lake Biwa. The body lengths of these fish ranged from 81.5 to 196.7 millimeters.
- **Experimental Setup**: Each fish was simultaneously provided with 100 chironomid larvae buried in the sandy bottom and 100 water lice moving in the water column within the same 45 minutes.
- **Data Collection**: Record the number of attacks of each fish, the number of prey of each type captured, the total food intake, and the efficiency per attack.

### Experimental Results
- **Attack Behavior**: The attack frequency of narrow - mouthed individuals was significantly higher than that of wide - mouthed individuals.
- **Feeding Selectivity**: Narrow - mouthed individuals were more inclined to prey on water lice, while wide - mouthed individuals mainly preyed on chironomid larvae.
- **Feeding Efficiency**: Individuals with intermediate morphologies had lower attack efficiency than those with extreme morphologies, indicating that there may be functional trade - offs in intermediate phenotypes.

### Discussion
- **Functional Trade - offs**: The experimental results support the existence of functional trade - offs in feeding selectivity and efficiency among individuals with different mouth morphologies, especially the disadvantageous position of intermediate phenotypes in attack efficiency.
- **Maintenance Mechanism of Intermediate Phenotypes**: Although intermediate phenotypes perform poorly under laboratory conditions, in the natural environment, due to seasonal fluctuations in prey resources and the influence of other ecological factors, intermediate phenotypes may still be able to coexist with extreme phenotypes.
- **Further Research**: Further research is needed to separate the effects of prey selectivity and attack success rate on feeding efficiency in order to more comprehensively understand the mechanism of functional trade - offs.

### Conclusion
This study experimentally verified the existence of feeding selectivity and functional trade - offs in Pseudogobio esocinus with different mouth morphologies, especially in terms of the functional disadvantage of intermediate phenotypes. This finding helps to understand how phenotypic variation can be maintained without obvious differentiation in the presence of functional trade - offs.