Abstract:Market-based approaches to environmental management are all the rage. Claims that market mechanisms can encourage environmental protection and promote greater economic efficiency while saving taxpayers' money are tantalizing. In the forestry sector, policy makers are widely heeding this advice and shrinking command-and-control systems in favour of incentive mechanisms that seek to align private enthusiasm with the public good. In some cases, governments are even promoting the creation of markets where none existed before. In others, markets are evolving of their own accord. In such times of change, it is difficult to stand back and take stock. Yet, it is during such times that guidance is most needed. In the rush to introduce market-based solutions to environmental problems, a particular concern is how markets are impacting on the poor. In this paper an effort is made to draw on a recent review of markets for four forest environmental services (biodiversity conservation, carbon sequestration, watershed protection and landscape beauty) to draw out preliminary insights into how markets are performing with respect to their impacts on the poor. The evidence suggests a need for caution. While the potential benefits are significant, the poor face an uphill battle in realizing them. Key constraints facing the poor include a lack of property rights over forest resources and their environmental services; inadequate skills and education; poor market information; lack of market contacts; inadequate communication infrastructure; inappropriate contract design; and lack of access to financial resources. To tackle these, four potential ways forward are highlighted: (1) assign property rights to forest assets and their related environmental services in ways that respect customary arrangements and poor people's tenure; (2) strengthen capacity for market participation, e.g. through training and education; (3) invest in the provision of market information, advice and, essentially, a contact point for buyers and sellers, perhaps through the establishment of a 'market support centre'; and (4) improve access to finance so that poor individuals can make necessary up-front investments in market participation.

Contracting, market access and deforestation

Taking Account of Governance: Implications for Land-Use Dynamics, Food Prices, and Trade Patterns

Trading forests: land-use change and carbon emissions embodied in production and exports of forest-risk commodities

Deforestation, certification, and transnational palm oil supply chains: Linking Guatemala to global consumer markets

Palm Oil and the Politics of Deforestation in Indonesia

Assessing the Implications of Deforestation and Climate Change on Rural Livelihood in Ghana: a Multidimensional Analysis and Solution-Based Approach

Smallholder participation in zero-deforestation supply chain initiatives in the Indonesian palm oil sector: Challenges, opportunities, and limitations

How well does the implementation of corporate zero-deforestation commitments in Indonesia align with aims to halt deforestation and include smallholders?

Large differences between observed and expected Ecuadorian deforestation from 2001 to 2009: a counterfactual simulation approach

Forest law compliance and enforcement: the case of on-farm timber extraction in Ghana

Post-reform Forestland Markets in China

Impacts of commodity prices and governance on the expansion of tropical agricultural frontiers

Developing markets for forest environmental services: an opportunity for promoting equity while securing efficiency?

Global economic trade-offs between wild nature and tropical agriculture

Logging alters tropical forest structure, while conversion to agriculture reduces biodiversity and functioning

Smallholders and timber extraction in the Ecuadorian Amazon: amidst market opportunities and regulatory constraints

Impacts of Deforestation and Land Use/Land Cover Change on Carbon Stock and Dynamics in the Jomoro District, Ghana

Reducing Deforestation and Trading Emissions: Economic Implications for the Post-Kyoto Carbon Market

The Effectiveness of Environmental Provisions in Regional Trade Agreements

Mixing carrots and sticks to conserve forests in the Brazilian Amazon: a spatial probabilistic modeling approach

Does investment in palm oil trade alleviate smallholders from poverty in Africa? Investigating profitability from a biodiversity hotspot, Cameroon