Abstract:BACKGROUND: Policies and programs that emphasize employment for persons with mental illness are often promoted with the goals of improving economic self-sufficiency and reducing dependence on public welfare programs. At present, there is little empirical evidence about the actual effect of vocational interventions on economic self-sufficiency or on use of public benefits by persons with mental illness. STUDY AIMS: This study provides a preliminary look at how participating in supported employment, a form of vocational rehabilitation emphasizing ongoing support in competitive jobs, affects the amount that participants earn from work and the total amount of income they receive from all sources. Further, we examine the extent to which receiving public benefits affects the amount earned from private employment, taking into consideration other factors that might be associated with benefit status. METHODS: Data are from a randomized trial of supported employment interventions. This analysis followed 137 of those study participants with severe mental illness for 18 months after they enrolled in either of two supported employment programs. Income from various sources was estimated based on interviews with study participants upon study entry and at six-month intervals thereafter. Changes in income from work, government and other sources were analyzed using paired Wilcoxon matched-pairs signed-ranks tests and t-tests. Using ordinary least-squares regression, we analyzed the effect of benefit status on changes in earnings, taking into account diagnosis, work history, education, program type, site of program, psychiatric symptoms, global functioning and previous earnings. RESULTS: Estimated total income increased by an average of $134 (US) per month after enrolling in supported employment. More than three-quarters of this increase was from government sources, such as Social Security and educational grants. The increase in government income was largely due to participants applying for and getting cash benefits for the first time. Social Security payments for those receiving benefits before enrollment did not change significantly. A small group of persons (n = 22) who did not receive Social Security benefits before or after enrolment earned significantly more from competitive employment after enrolling than did those who received benefits. This finding persisted after taking into acount differences in work history, clinical and functional variables and education. LIMITATIONS: Because of the relatively small sample size and the lack of continuous measures of income these results should be considered preliminary. CONCLUSIONS: Supported employment, one of the more effective forms of vocational rehabilitation for persons with mental illness, did not reduce dependence on government support. Receiving government benefits was associated with lower earnings from work. IMPLICATIONS FOR HEALTH CARE PROVISION AND USE: These findings suggest that most persons in treatment for severe mental illness need continued public financial support even after enrolling in vocational rehabilitation programs. IMPLICATIONS FOR HEALTH POLICY FORMULATION: Undoubtedly increased labor force participation can benefit persons with mental illness in a number of ways. However, policy makers should be careful about justifying increased access to vocational programs on the basis of reduced spending for income support. Further, targeting such programs only to persons receiving income support may overlook the clients who can benefit most: those who are not currently receiving benefits. IMPLICATIONS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH: Policy makers need a better understanding of how vocational interventions and income support programs affect the income and well-being of persons with mental illness. Studies similar to this one should be repeated with larger, more diverse samples that will allow use of instrumental variables statistical techniques.

The impact of mental illness on employment: Consumers' perspectives

A Qualitative Study Exploring the Lived Experience of Unemployment Among People with Severe Mental Illness

People Living With Mental Illness Perceptions of Physical Health, Mental Health and Well-Being

Work and Mental Illness

What do employers think about employing people with experience of mental illness in New Zealand workplaces?

Employment experiences of formerly homeless adults with serious mental illness in Housing First versus treatment first supportive housing programs.

Access to mental health in primary care: a qualitative meta-synthesis of evidence from the experience of people from 'hard to reach' groups

Employment of young people with mental health conditions: making it work

Employability of Persons With Mental Disability: Understanding Lived Experiences in Kenya

Mental health nurses' empathy experiences towards consumers with dual diagnosis: A thematic analysis

Psychological problems and work ability in unemployed people diagnosed with a mental illness

Mental health consumer participation in undergraduate occupational therapy student assessment: No negative impact

The Impact of Mental Illness Stigma on Seeking and Participating in Mental Health Care

The impact of co-location employment partnerships within the Australian mental health service and policy context: A systematic review

'I am more than my diagnosis': Amplifying the voice of consumers in the design and delivery of mental health services

Employment Experiences and Employability of People in China Living With Schizophrenia: A Qualitative Study

The economic benefits of supported employment for persons with mental illness

Enabling people with severe mental illness to overcome barriers to access dental treatment: a qualitative study applying COM-B framework analysis

A Study of Employers Concerns About Hiring Individuals with Mental Illness, HIV and Chronic Health Problems

Cognitive impairment and its impact on employment: a qualitative interview-based study involving healthcare professionals and people living with multiple sclerosis

Mental health consumers' perspectives of physical health interventions: An integrative review