Abstract:Large uncertainties in future climate change necessitate understanding of decadal-centennial variability in past climate. Speleothems, which capture changes in the stable isotope composition (i.e., δ18O values) of rainfall, have been widely employed to constrain hydroclimate variability in the past due to their continuous growth and potential for high temporal resolution. However, the interpretation of speleothem proxies (i.e., geochemical and growth rate records) is still imperfectly constrained. One challenge involves understanding the transformation from rainfall δ18O to calcite δ18O. A recent advance to address this challenge is the development of proxy system models (PSMs), which translate climate variables to speleothem calcite δ18O values. However, the complexity and applicability of each model varies. In order to assess which speleothem PSMs are most suitable for simulating speleothem records, we evaluate four commonly applied PSMs, which span a range of complexity (one simple, two intermediate-complexity, and one complex model). The evaluation is based on a given model's ability to simulate observed drip δ18O time series using multi-year long cave dripwater and rainfall data sets from semi-arid central Texas and tropical Borneo. The models are based on the running mean of rainfall δ18O (RM model), dripwater transit time (PRYSM model), StorAge Selection (SAS model), and combination of flow paths in karst systems (Karstolution model). We explore the parameter settings of these models and evaluate them employing the Root Mean Square Errors (RMSEs) metric. We find that for drip sites in semi-arid climates with long residence times, model complexity of at least intermediate levels is required to simulate cave dripwater δ18O variability. The RMSEs of intermediate-complexity PSMs (PRYSM, SAS, and Karstolution) are close to the range of analytical errors, while the RMSE of the simple RM model is far larger. For drip sites in wet climates with short residence times, all four models, including the RM model, are capable of simulating cave dripwater δ18O well. In practice, we assert that the use of models of intermediate complexity such as PRYSM may be required when detailed knowledge of variables such as groundwater residence time for a given cave setting is unknown. Such PSMs are useful for global-scale studies due to their broad applicability and simplicity. We also illustrate the use of comprehensive physical models, such as Karstolution, for understanding cave processes like fractionation due to epikarst evaporation. The poorer performance of the PSMs in semi-arid environments than their performance in humid environments suggests that additional in-situ process studies are needed to improve simulations of relatively dry cave systems and provide enhanced interpretations of speleothem reconstructions from these environments.

Characterisation of infiltration in the cave of Villars (Dordogne) by geophysical and isotopic methods: Importance for paleo-climatic studies based on speleothems and for the conservation of heritage sites

Data-model comparisons of isotopic and hydrological variabilities of the karstic vadose zone above Villars Cave, SW-France based on 20 years' monitoring record

Responses of underground air and drip water geochemistry to meteorological factors: A multi-parameter approach in the Rull Cave (Spain)

Ventilation regime in a karstic system (Milandre Cave, Switzerland)

Climate monitoring in the Caumont cave and quarry system (northern France) reveal near oxygen isotopic equilibrium conditions for carbonate deposition

Investigating stable oxygen and carbon isotopic variability in speleothem records over the last millennium using multiple isotope-enabled climate models

Spatiotemporal variation in cave percolation waters: A functional approach

Assessing proxy system models of cave dripwater δ18O variability

The transport mechanism of carbon isotopes based on 10 years of cave monitoring: Implications for paleoclimate reconstruction

Deciphering the hydroclimatic significance of dripwater δ13CDIC variations in monsoonal China based on modern cave monitoring

The effect of cave ventilation on carbon and oxygen isotopic fractionation between calcite and drip water

Significance of active speleothem δ18O at annual-decadal timescale——A case study from monitoring in Furong Cave

A Multimodal Research Approach to Assessing the Karst Structural Conditions of the Ceiling of a Cave with Palaeolithic Cave Art Paintings: Polychrome Hall at Altamira Cave (Spain)

Response of drip water Mg/Ca and Sr/Ca variations in ventilated caves to hydroclimate

Mesoscale permeability variations estimated from natural airflows in the decorated Cosquer Cave (southeastern France)

Imaging hydrological dynamics in karst unsaturated zones by time-lapse electrical resistivity tomography

Conservation of oxygen and hydrogen seasonal isotopic signals in meteoric precipitation in groundwater: An experimental tank study of the effects of land cover in a summer monsoon climate

Constraints for precise and accurate fluid inclusion stable isotope analysis using water-vapour saturated CRDS techniques

A Comparative Study of Cave System Calcium Isotope Ratios: Implications for Quantitative Reconstruction of Paleorainfall From Speleothems

Sources and transport of CO 2 in the karst system of Jiguan Cave, Funiu Mountains, China

Seasonal Variability of Oxygen and Hydrogen Stable Isotopes in Precipitation and Cave Drip Water at Guilin, Southwest China