Experimental and Computational Analysis of High-Intensity Focused Ultrasound Thermal Ablation in Breast Cancer Cells: Monolayers vs. Spheroids

Heba M. Badawe,Jean Paul Harouz,Petra Raad,Kareem Abu,Anthony Freije,Kamel Ghali,Wassim Abou-Kheir,Massoud L. Khraiche
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/cancers16071274
2024-03-26
Cancers
Abstract:High-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) is a non-invasive therapeutic modality that uses precise acoustic energy to ablate cancerous tissues through coagulative necrosis. In this context, we investigate the efficacy of HIFU ablation in two distinct cellular configurations, namely 2D monolayers and 3D spheroids of epithelial breast cancer cell lines (MDA-MB 231 and MCF7). The primary objective is to compare the response of these two in vitro models to HIFU while measuring their ablation percentages and temperature elevation levels. HIFU was systematically applied to the cell cultures, varying ultrasound intensity and duty cycle during different sonication sessions. The results indicate that the degree of ablation is highly influenced by the duty cycle, with higher duty cycles resulting in greater ablation percentages, while sonication duration has a minimal impact. Numerical simulations validate experimental observations, highlighting a significant disparity in the response of 2D monolayers and 3D spheroids to HIFU treatment. Specifically, tumor spheroids require lower temperature elevations for effective ablation, and their ablation percentage significantly increases with elevated duty cycles. This study contributes to a comprehensive understanding of acoustic energy conversion within the biological system during HIFU treatment for 2D versus 3D ablation targets, holding potential implications for refining and personalizing breast cancer therapeutic strategies.
oncology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to address a critical issue in breast cancer treatment: how to optimize the thermal ablation effect of high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) in breast cancer cells. Specifically, the researchers aim to compare the responses of 2D monolayer cells and 3D spheroid cells to HIFU through experimental and computational analysis, in order to evaluate the impact of different ultrasound parameters (such as acoustic intensity, duty cycle, and duration of ultrasound) on temperature rise and tumor cell ablation. ### Main Issues of the Paper: 1. **Application of HIFU in Breast Cancer Cells**: HIFU, as a non-invasive treatment method, uses precise acoustic energy for targeted tumor ablation, but its efficacy is influenced by various factors and needs further optimization. 2. **Differences Between 2D Monolayer Cells and 3D Spheroid Cells**: The researchers aim to understand whether there are significant differences in the response of these two different cell culture methods to HIFU treatment, particularly in terms of temperature rise and the degree of cell ablation. 3. **Optimization of Ultrasound Parameters**: By systematically varying ultrasound parameters (acoustic intensity, duty cycle, and duration of ultrasound), the researchers hope to find the optimal parameter combination to enhance the therapeutic effect of HIFU. ### Research Methods: - **Experimental Part**: HIFU treatment is applied to 2D monolayer cells and 3D spheroid cells, measuring temperature rise and the degree of cell ablation. - **Computational Part**: Numerical simulations are used to validate the experimental results and further explore the impact of different parameters on cell ablation. ### Expected Contributions: - **In-depth Understanding of the Biological Effects of HIFU**: By comparing the responses of 2D and 3D cell models, the study provides a more comprehensive understanding of HIFU's application in breast cancer treatment. - **Optimization of Treatment Parameters**: Identifying the optimal combination of ultrasound parameters to improve the therapeutic effect of HIFU and reduce damage to surrounding healthy tissues. - **Promotion of Personalized Treatment**: Providing a theoretical basis for future clinical applications, aiding in the development of more personalized breast cancer treatment strategies. In summary, this paper aims to optimize the thermal ablation effect of HIFU in breast cancer cells through experimental and computational analysis, particularly focusing on the differences between 2D monolayer cells and 3D spheroid cells, thereby providing new insights and methods for non-invasive breast cancer treatment.