Abstract:We examine two aspects of the mathematical basis for two-tier voting systems, such as that of the Council of the European Union. These aspects concern the use of square-root weights and the choice of quota.Square-root weights originate in the Penrose square-root system, which assumes that votes are cast independently and uniformly at random, and is based around the concept of equality of influence of the voters across the Union. There are (at least) two distinct definitions of influence in current use in probability theory, namely, absolute and conditional influence. These are in agreement when the underlying random variables are independent, but not generally. We review their possible implications for two-tier voting systems, especially in the context of the so-called collective bias model. We show that the two square-root laws invoked by Penrose are unified through the use of conditional influence.In an elaboration of the square-root system, Słomczyński and Życzkowskihave proposed an exact value for the quota <math>q=q∗</math> to be achieved in a successful vote of a two-tier system, and they have presented numerical and theoretical evidence in its support. We indicate some numerical and mathematical issues arising in the use of a Gaussian (or normal) approximation in this context, and we propose that other values of <math>q</math> may be as good if not better than <math>q∗</math>. We discuss certain aspects of the relationship between theoreticians and politicians in the design of a two-tier voting system, and we reach the conclusion that the choice of quota in the square-root system is an issue for politicians informed by theory.

Towards a Switching-Algebraic Theory of Weighted Monotone Voting Systems: The Case of Banzhaf Voting Indices

Towards a Switching-Algebraic Theory of Weighted Voting Systems: Exploring Restrictions on Coalition Formation

Switching-Algebraic Calculation of Banzhaf Voting Indices

Analysis and optimization of weighted voting systems consisting of voting units with limited availability

Weighted simple games and the topology of simplicial complexes

Reliability Optimization for Weighted Voting System

Approximation of Banzhaf indices and its application to voting games

Asymmetric weighted voting systems

Axiomatization of some power indices in voting games with abstention

The Art and Beauty of Voting Power

Computation and Bribery of Voting Power in Delegative Simple Games

Reliability evaluation of weighted voting system based on D–S evidence theory

Margin of Victory for Weighted Tournament Solutions

Notes on Equivalence and Minimization of Weighted Automata

Average Consensus with Weighting Matrix Design for Quantized Communication on Directed Switching Graphs

Are Weighted Games Sufficiently Good for Binary Voting?

False-Name Manipulation in Weighted Voting Games is Hard for Probabilistic Polynomial Time

Optimal unit grouping in weighted voting systems

Complexity Dichotomies for Unweighted Scoring Rules

Control by Adding Players to Change or Maintain the Shapley-Shubik or the Penrose-Banzhaf Power Index in Weighted Voting Games Is Complete for NP^PP

On influence and compromise in two-tier voting systems