Understanding the Barriers to Consumer Purchasing of Electric Vehicles: The Innovation Resistance Theory

Yixi Xue,Xiaoyan Zhang,Yi Zhang,Exiang Luo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16062420

IF: 3.9

2024-03-15

Sustainability

Abstract:In the context of sustainable transition, the factors that impact the decision to purchase electric vehicles (EVs) have garnered significant interest. However, existing research predominantly concentrates on the promotional factors while disregarding an examination of the resistance effects. Drawing on the innovation resistance theory (IRT), this study aims to investigate the influence of three functional barriers (usage, value, and risk) and two psychological barriers (tradition and image) on consumers' intention to purchase EVs. Additionally, we also analyze the moderating effect of environmental concern and incentive policy. Based on a survey of 297 respondents in China, we used SPSS 26.0 and AMOS 24.0 to verify our hypothesis. Our findings indicate that usage, value, risk, and tradition barriers negatively affect EV purchase intentions. Moreover, the negative relationship between functional barriers and EV purchase intentions is weaker for a strong incentive policy. Furthermore, we found that Gen Y and households with private car consumers are more willing to purchase EVs. These findings contribute to extending the applicability of IRT to the sustainable transportation field. They also offer practical guidance for EV enterprises with regard to marketing strategies that effectively mitigate the functional and psychological barriers to enhance profits, and for policymakers to better stimulate the development of the EV market.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the barriers to consumers purchasing electric vehicles (EVs) and conducts research based on Innovation Resistance Theory (IRT). Specifically, the paper aims to address the following two core issues:

1. **Identifying the main barriers affecting the intention to purchase electric vehicles**: The study focuses on functional barriers (including usage barriers, value barriers, and risk barriers) and psychological barriers (tradition barriers and image barriers), investigating how these factors influence consumers' willingness to purchase electric vehicles.

2. **The moderating role of environmental concern and incentive policies**: Further analysis is conducted to determine whether consumers' level of environmental concern and government incentive policies significantly moderate the relationship between the aforementioned barriers and purchase intention.

By analyzing survey data from 297 respondents in China, the study finds that:
- Usage barriers, value barriers, risk barriers, and tradition barriers all negatively impact the intention to purchase electric vehicles.
- Strong incentive policies can weaken the negative relationship between functional barriers and purchase intention.
- Environmental concern also somewhat mitigates the negative association between functional barriers and purchase intention.
- Additionally, the study points out that the younger generation (especially Generation Y) and families with private cars are more inclined to purchase electric vehicles.

In summary, the paper attempts to gain a deeper understanding of consumers' attitudes and behaviors towards electric vehicles by applying Innovation Resistance Theory, particularly focusing on the factors that hinder the adoption of electric vehicles. It also considers the impact of environmental awareness and policy incentives. This helps companies and policymakers better formulate strategies to promote the healthy development of the electric vehicle market.