Abstract:Abstract The evaluation of probabilistic forecasts plays a central role both in the interpretation and in the use of forecast systems and their development. Probabilistic scores (scoring rules) provide statistical measures to assess the quality of probabilistic forecasts. Often, many probabilistic forecast systems are available while evaluations of their performance are not standardized, with different scoring rules being used to measure different aspects of forecast performance. Even when the discussion is restricted to strictly proper scoring rules, there remains considerable variability between them; indeed strictly proper scoring rules need not rank competing forecast systems in the same order when none of these systems are perfect. The locality property is explored to further distinguish scoring rules. The nonlocal strictly proper scoring rules considered are shown to have a property that can produce “unfortunate” evaluations, particularly the fact that the continuous rank probability score prefers the outcome close to the median of the forecast distribution regardless of the probability mass assigned to the value at/near the median raises concern to its use. The only local strictly proper scoring rule, the logarithmic score, has direct interpretations in terms of probabilities and bits of information. The nonlocal strictly proper scoring rules, on the other hand, lack meaningful direct interpretation for decision support. The logarithmic score is also shown to be invariant under smooth transformation of the forecast variable, while the nonlocal strictly proper scoring rules considered may, however, change their preferences due to the transformation. It is therefore suggested that the logarithmic score always be included in the evaluation of probabilistic forecasts.

Optimization of Scoring Rules

Optimal Scoring Rules for Multi-dimensional Effort

Optimal Scoring Rule Design under Partial Knowledge

Beyond Strictly Proper Scoring Rules: The Importance of Being Local

Incentivizing honest performative predictions with proper scoring rules

Optimizing positional scoring rules for rank aggregation

Eliciting Forecasts from Self-interested Experts: Scoring Rules for Decision Makers

A comparative study of scoring systems by simulations

Compatible Weighted Proper Scoring Rules

A Proper Scoring Rule for Validation of Competing Risks Models

Local scale invariance and robustness of proper scoring rules

Better Short than Greedy: Interpretable Models through Optimal Rule Boosting

Soft Condorcet Optimization for Ranking of General Agents

Weighted scoringRules: Emphasising Particular Outcomes when Evaluating Probabilistic Forecasts

An Objective Improvement Approach to Solving Discounted Payoff Games

A linear transform scheme for building weighted scoring rules

Scoring Rules and Calibration for Imprecise Probabilities

Optimal Prize Allocation in Contests: the Role of Negative Prizes

Proper Scoring Rules for Multivariate Probabilistic Forecasts based on Aggregation and Transformation

On a Class of Objective Priors from Scoring Rules

Superior Scoring Rules for Probabilistic Evaluation of Single-Label Multi-Class Classification Tasks