Abstract:People use various behaviors to cope with stressful events. These behaviors are mostly adaptive, as they allow a successful release of stress without impacting other aspects of life: How nice is it to have a break with a few spoons of that favorite ice cream during a hectic working day? However, when excessive consumption of high-sugar/salt ultra-processed food becomes the gateway to find relief from stress, eating loses this adaptive function and may escalate to binge eating, lead to obesity, and other medical conditions linked to overweight. Several etiological models attempt to explain stress-induced eating and excessive overeating behaviors characterizing these clinical conditions. The popular Emotional Eating Theory proposes that stress-related (over-)eating, a major predictor of obesity and diagnosed binge eating disorders, develops based on negative reinforcement learning since food consumption regulates the negative affective state associated with stressful circumstances. Differently, the prominent Incentive Sensitization Theory explains overeating, binge eating disorders (including bulimia), and obesity in terms of excessive amplification of reward 'wanting', which is thought to emerge from overexposure to obesogenic (food)cues. The several studies oriented by these theories have paved the way to better understand stress-related (over-)eating and its clinical excesses. However, a deep mechanistic understanding of how and why stress-induced (over-)eating can escalate till clinical forms of overeating remain elusive. A well-funded connection of the mechanisms proposed by the Emotional Eating Theory and the Incentive Sensitization Theory might address this etiological open question. To avoid erroneous arguments, it is however essential to first address the internal theoretical and methodological shortcomings of each theory and connected studies. These shortcomings stem from conceptual fallacies and poorly implemented designs, which might partially explain the 'high variability and low replicability' problem of empirical findings. Next, the formulation of a new integrative model could provide fresh insight into the deep learning and biological mechanisms of this escalation. A successful formalization of this model could then create the much-needed impact in clinical and preventive research since excessive overeating is a behavior hard to change once established. In this opinion paper, I propose to apply recent insights we gathered on the role of relief from the field of safety learning to stress (over-)eating. I will present a new relief-based model that, as a starting point, has the potential to connect the Emotional Eating Theory with the Incentive Sensitization Theory, setting the base for more integrative science.

Understanding Loss of Control Eating Through the Lens of Expectancies and Reinforcement Sensitization

Perception of control during episodes of eating: relationships with quality of life and eating psychopathology

Neural underpinnings of threat bias in relation to loss-of-control eating behaviors among adolescent girls with high weight

Examining the roles of reward sensitivity and difficulties in emotion regulation in relation to low-restraint binge eating

Loss of Control Eating in Adults With Impulsive and/or Inattentive Tendencies

Loss of Control over Eating, Inhibitory Control, and Reward Sensitivity in Children and Adolescents: A Systematic Review

A systematic review and meta-analysis of loss-of-control eating in relation to cardiometabolic health components and inflammatory markers

Attention-deficit/hyperactivity symptoms and loss of control eating in emerging adults: Role of psychological resilience

Examining neural responses to anticipating or receiving monetary rewards and the development of binge eating in youth. A registered report using data from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) study

Loss of control eating in children is associated with altered cortical and subcortical brain structure

A balance of activity in brain control and reward systems predicts self-regulatory outcomes

Executive function and probabilities of engaging in long-term sedentary and high calorie/low nutrition eating behaviors in early adolescence

The association between distress tolerance and eating expectancies among trauma-exposed college students with obesity

A pilot study of attachment style and emotional experience in adolescent girls with loss of control eating

Associations between affect dynamics and eating regulation in daily life: a preliminary ecological momentary assessment study

Affect and disordered eating behaviours in women's daily lives: The comparative explanatory roles of distinct momentary emotion dysregulation dimensions

Changes in functional connectivity and structural covariance between the fronto-parietal network and medial orbitofrontal cortex are associated with disinhibition in restrained eaters

Stress-induced overeating behaviors explained from a (transitory) relief-learning perspective

Adverse childhood experiences, low self‐esteem, and salient stimulus response in eating disorders

Risk-Taking in Disorders of Natural and Drug Rewards: Neural Correlates and Effects of Probability, Valence, and Magnitude

Anticipatory and Consummatory Responses Across Reward Domains in Adolescents With Anorexia Nervosa