Development and content validation of a financial and functional outcomes tool for diabetes-related foot disease in patients undergoing major lower limb amputation: a prospective observational study from Pakistan

Nadeem Ahmed Siddiqui,Muhammad Anees Khaliq,Muhammad Ammar Pirzada,Ziaur Rehman,Fareed Shaikh,Amna Riaz,Sadaf Khan,Siddiqui,N. A.,Khaliq,M. A.,Pirzada,M. A.,Rehman,Z.,Shaikh,F.,Riaz,A.,Khan,S.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2023-080853
IF: 3.006
2024-03-31
BMJ Open
Abstract:Objective To develop and content validate a questionnaire to assess the financial and functional impact of major lower limb amputation in patients with diabetes-related foot disease. Design Prospective observational study. Setting This study was conducted at a tertiary care centre in Pakistan. Participants We conducted a thorough literature review and a group interview with 10 participants, resulting in domain identification and item generation. The group included seven patients with diabetes-related foot disease who underwent major lower limb amputation and three caregivers. Subsequently, a focused group discussion was held to assess overlap and duplication among the items, and two rounds of content validation were carried out by five content and five lay experts in both English and Urdu. Question items with a Content Validity Index (CVI) score of >0.79 were retained, items with a CVI score between 0.70 and 0.79 were revised and items with a CVI score of <0.70 were excluded. Results The initial literature review and group interview resulted in 61 items in the financial and functional domains. After the focused group discussion, the questionnaire was reduced to 37 items. Following two rounds of content validation, the English questionnaire achieved the Scale-Content Validity Index/Average (S-CVI/Ave) of 0.92 and 0.89 on relevance and clarity, respectively. Similarly, the Urdu questionnaire achieved the S-CVI-Ave of 0.92 and 0.95, respectively. Conclusion A 37-item multidimensional questionnaire was developed and rigorously content-validated to assess the financial and functional impact of major lower limb amputation in patients with diabetes-related foot disease. The questionnaire used in this study has shown robust content validity specifically for our population.
medicine, general & internal
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to develop and validate a questionnaire tool for assessing the financial and functional impacts on patients who have undergone major lower - limb amputation due to diabetic foot disease. Specifically: 1. **Financial Impact**: The paper explores the direct and indirect financial burdens on patients and their families caused by major lower - limb amputation. These burdens include medical expenses, the cost of purchasing prostheses or crutches, unemployment, selling assets to make up for economic losses, etc. 2. **Functional Impact**: The paper also focuses on the functional changes after amputation, including changes in patients' activities of daily living, social functions, religious activities, recreational activities, and marital relationships. ### Background - **Diabetic Foot Disease**: Diabetic foot disease is one of the main causes of major lower - limb amputation, especially in low - and middle - income countries such as Pakistan, where the prevalence of diabetes is on the rise, leading to an increase in related complications. - **Economic and Social Impact**: Major lower - limb amputation not only affects the patients' physical and mental health but also brings significant economic and functional challenges to patients and their families, seriously affecting the quality of life. ### Research Objectives - **Develop Questionnaire Tool**: The research aims to develop a multi - dimensional questionnaire tool covering the two main areas of finance and function to assess the financial and functional impacts on patients who have undergone major lower - limb amputation due to diabetic foot disease. - **Content Validation**: Through expert panels and patient feedback, conduct content validation on the questionnaire to ensure its validity and reliability in terms of content. ### Methods - **Literature Review and Interviews**: Identify key issues in the financial and functional areas through literature review and in - depth interviews with patients and their families. - **Focus Group Discussions**: Organize focus group discussions to further optimize questionnaire items and eliminate duplicate and overlapping content. - **Content Validation**: A panel consisting of content experts and patient experts conducts two rounds of content validation on the questionnaire, using the Content Validity Index (CVI) score to assess the relevance and clarity of each item. ### Results - **Final Questionnaire**: After two rounds of content validation, a multi - dimensional questionnaire with 37 items was finally formed, including 19 items in the financial area and 18 items in the functional area. - **Content Validity**: The overall Content Validity Index (S - CVI/Ave) of the questionnaire is 0.92 (relevance) and 0.89 (clarity) in the English version, and 0.92 (relevance) and 0.95 (clarity) in the Urdu version. ### Discussion - **Innovation**: This is the first study to develop and validate a questionnaire on the financial and functional impacts for patients who have undergone major lower - limb amputation due to diabetic foot disease. - **Application Value**: This questionnaire can be used as a tool for clinicians to assess the financial and functional status of patients more than 6 months after surgery, which helps to identify and solve the economic and functional problems faced by patients and their families. Through this research, the researchers hope to provide an effective tool to help medical professionals better understand and support patients who have undergone major lower - limb amputation due to diabetic foot disease and their families.