Advancing Conservation Strategies for Native Eastern Highlands-Strain Walleye Sander vitreus in West Virginia: Insights from Genomic Investigations and Broodstock Screening

Andrew Johnson,Katherine Zipfel,Amy Welsh
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/d16070371
2024-06-27
Diversity
Abstract:Walleye, Sander vitreus, has several distinct genetic lineages throughout North America as a consequence of Pleistocene glaciation. Stocking walleye across genetic boundaries in the mid-20th century has led to the introduction of non-native strains that persist to this day. In West Virginia, the identification of the native Eastern Highlands strain led the West Virginia Division of Natural Resources (WVDNR) to employ broodstock screening to assist in the conservation of the native strain. To develop a baseline native ancestry prevalence in walleye populations throughout the state, 1532 broodstock were sampled across 17 sampling locations over a 6-year period. To evaluate the effectiveness of the current broodstock two-SNP qPCR assay protocol and identify whether more SNPs need to be implemented, 284 walleye were sequenced and ancestry-genotyped across 42 fixed SNPs between the two strains. When comparing the current protocol to the older microsatellite protocol, advancement in the ability to identify native-strain individuals was observed. Genotyping previously assigned walleye broodstock across multiple fixed SNPs revealed that the current ancestry assignment protocol, on average, assigned individuals that display 96% Eastern Highlands native ancestry to the native strain and accurately identified >93% of all pure Eastern Highlands walleye. Throughout the state of West Virginia, the New and Kanawha River systems contained a high prevalence of native ancestry, with the Ohio River and sampled impoundments displaying varying levels of ancestry. SNPs with >98% prevalence in individuals assigned to the Eastern Highlands strain were identified during the course of the study and can be implemented in future screening protocols. Our results highlight the utility of genomic approaches as tools to assist fisheries management goals and their capability to accurately identify native ancestry to assist in conservation efforts.
ecology,biodiversity conservation
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the following aspects: 1. **Comparing the effectiveness of different gene identification methods**: The research aims to compare the effectiveness of the recently developed dual - SNP qPCR detection method with the previously used microsatellite diagnostic protocol in identifying the Eastern Highlands strain and the Great Lakes strain as well as their F1 hybrids. Specifically, the researchers hope to evaluate whether the new method can more accurately identify purebred Eastern Highlands strain individuals. 2. **Evaluating the effectiveness of the current dual - SNP qPCR panel**: By comparing the results of the dual - SNP qPCR panel with the complete panel of 57 diagnostic SNPs determined by Johnson et al. (2023), the researchers hope to verify whether the two currently used SNPs are effective enough or whether more SNPs need to be added to improve the identification accuracy, especially in the ability to detect backcross individuals and high - level ancestral assignment. 3. **Establishing the genetic composition baseline of Walleye populations across West Virginia**: By analyzing Walleye broodstock samples collected in West Virginia over a period of 6 years, the researchers hope to calculate the proportion of purebred Eastern Highlands strain Walleye in different populations, observe the changes in the proportion of purebred Walleye in these populations over time, and provide genetic - information - based guidance for future management directions. ### Specific problems - **Comparing microsatellite and SNP detection results**: The research found that in 2019 and 2020, the microsatellite detection protocol was less effective than the dual - SNP qPCR detection method in identifying Eastern Highlands strain Walleye. The microsatellite protocol could only identify 58% of the total Eastern Highlands strain broodstock, while the dual - SNP qPCR detection method could identify more purebred Eastern Highlands strain individuals. - **Evaluating the accuracy of the dual - SNP qPCR detection method**: Through further ancestral assignment analysis of 239 Walleye samples, the research found that the dual - SNP qPCR detection method could accurately identify purebred Eastern Highlands strain Walleye in most cases, with an average identification accuracy rate of 93.06%. - **Establishing a genetic baseline**: The research results show that the proportion of purebred Eastern Highlands strain Walleye in the New River and Kanawha River basins in West Virginia is relatively high, while the proportion in the Ohio River basin and other reservoirs is relatively low. This provides an important genetic information basis for future conservation and management. ### Conclusion The research results emphasize the importance of genomics methods in fishery management, especially their ability to accurately identify purebred Eastern Highlands strain Walleye. These findings are helpful for formulating more effective conservation strategies to maintain and restore the native Walleye populations in West Virginia.