Abstract:The presence of bivalves and bivalve aquaculture can have positive and negative impacts on seagrass and associated benthic communities. Some oyster (Crassostrea gigas) aquaculture methods recently have been restricted to reduce benthic disturbance and protect native eelgrass (Zostera manna) in West coast (USA) estuaries. We argue that aquaculture, like all food production systems, involves tradeoffs with natural systems, but that the magnitude of those tradeoffs depends on the ecological details of the production system. Capitalizing on oyster aquaculture farms as large scale manipulations in Willapa Bay, WA (USA), we explored three different oyster aquaculture methods (mechanical harvest or dredged on-bottom, hand-picked on-bottom and long line off-bottom). We found that both the biological (oyster-eelgrass interactions) and physical (disturbance or structure) components of aquaculture led to changes in the eelgrass population. Eelgrass density declined with oyster density in all aquaculture areas, likely as a result of direct competition for space. Eelgrass relative growth rate, plant size, and production did not change with oyster density. However, all eelgrass measures were affected by aquaculture, and the type and magnitude of impacts varied among eelgrass measures and aquaculture methods. Throughout the bay, eelgrass in long line areas occurred at densities indistinguishable from nearby uncultivated areas, but in 2004, eelgrass in long line areas was smaller (32%) and had lower production per area (70%). Cultivating oysters in dredged or hand picked beds increased eelgrass growth rates slightly, but led to lower eelgrass density (70% and 30%, respectively), plant size (32%, both cases), and production (70%, both cases). In a large scale simulated mechanical harvest experiment, the temporal response of eelgrass density varied dramatically by site, ranging from 1 to >4 y. If eelgrass impact reduction, rather than avoidance, is identified as the management goal, the degree of tradeoff between eelgrass habitat and oyster production can be minimized by managing aquaculture methods or oyster planting densities, depending on the eelgrass measure of interest. Explicit management goals and appropriate eelgrass habitat indicators must be developed before our findings can be used to suggest best management practices for intertidal aquaculture in the Pacific Northwest.

Economic analysis of off-bottom oyster culture

Production economics and profitability analysis of horizontal rack culture and horizontal rack culture coupled with raft-string culture methods: a case study of Pacific oyster (Crassostrea gigas) farming in Chiayi and Yunlin Counties, Taiwan

Clam aquaculture profitability under changing environmental risks

The business of oyster restoration: using traditional market‐based approaches to estimate the oyster restoration economy

The effects of the oyster mortality crisis on the economics of the shellfish farming sector: Preliminary review and prospects from a case study in Marennes-Oleron Bay (France)

North American Oyster Fisheries

Regulatory costs on Pacific coast shellfish farms

Comparative Description and Analysis of Oyster Aquaculture in Selected Atlantic Regions: Production, Market Dynamics, and Consumption Patterns

Barriers to Eastern Oyster Aquaculture Expansion in Virginia

Remote Sensing-Driven Pacific Oyster (Crassostrea gigas) Growth Modeling to Inform Offshore Aquaculture Site Selection

Nutrient reduction by eastern oysters exhibits low variability associated with reproduction, ploidy, and farm location

Production Characteristics and Optimization of Mitigation Mussel Culture

Growth of Oyster (Crassostrea virginica) Larvae in Small-Scale Systems Using an Algae Concentrate Food Source

Oysters and Aquaculture Practices Affect Eelgrass Density and Productivity in a Pacific Northwest Estuary

A comparative study on the nursery culture of hatchery-reared sub-adult cupped oyster, Crassostrea iredalei (Faustino, 1932), in an earthen pond and a mangrove canal

Comparison of Oyster Aquaculture Methods and Their Potential to Enhance Microbial Nitrogen Removal From Coastal Ecosystems

Maine seaweed benchmarking: Economically assessing the growth of an emerging sector

Modeling Oyster Reef Reproductive Sustainability: Analyzing Gamete Viability, Hydrodynamics, and Reef Structure to Facilitate Restoration of $\textit{Crassostrea virginica}$

Development and application of an online tool to quantify nitrogen removal associated with harvest of cultivated eastern oysters

Engineering design and economic analysis of offshore seaweed farm

Combined Effects of Local and Regional Drivers on Oyster Spat Density and Growth in Eastern Australia