Abstract:The enormous environmental impact of construction is becoming increasingly apparent and unacceptable to many structural engineers, whose designs typically account for the majority of a building's embodied carbon. It is timely, therefore, that consensus is forming around a methodology for calculating embodied carbon. This encourages the inclusion of all life cycle stages, from material production and construction, through use and eventual demolition, disposal and reuse. In practice, however, end-of-life processes are fraught with uncertainty and often ignored, despite the potentially large associated carbon fluxes. Further uncertainty exists when considering bio-based construction materials, which store carbon during use. There are no widely-accepted means of accounting for timing of these carbon fluxes, despite the long service life of most buildings. Could we consider whole-life carbon in a more holistic and climate-focused way?This article uses dynamic life cycle assessment to convert greenhouse gas emission histories to key climate impacts using a simple dynamic model. The implications for structural design decisions are explored by comparing concrete, steel and timber options for a typical medium-rise building structure. Concrete is found to have a higher impact than steel, with the climate response of both options dominated by the large initial emissions of material production and construction. Timber has the smallest impact, for this example, under a typical scenario with sustainable forest management and re-emission of sequestered carbon at end-of-life. The analysis takes a forward-looking approach to sequestration, with timing corresponding to the growth of replanted trees. An optimistic timber scenario, whereby future carbon-capture technology avoids most end-of-life emissions, demonstrates the possibility of structures with small long-term climate cooling effects. Conversely, in a hypothetical worst-case scenario where no replanting or subsequent sequestration occurs, the long-term warming effect of the timber structure is increased by the net emission of biogenic carbon.Although end-of-life processes are important in the long-term, particularly for timber, the analysis also highlights the importance of the initial emissions from material production and construction. These cause high rates of short-term temperature increase and prolonged accumulation of radiative heat for all the buildings, but the impacts are again lowest for timber.Most importantly, the investigation shows how dynamic life cycle assessment can be used to explore climate impacts in a comprehensive, graphical and unbiased way. As a simple extension to established methodologies for calculating embodied carbon, it is a powerful decision making tool in the climate emergency.

Carbon fractions in wood for estimating embodied carbon in the built environment

Improving wood carbon fractions for multiscale forest carbon estimation

Wood product carbon substitution benefits: a critical review of assumptions

Estimation of carbon stocks in wood products for private building companies

The carbon costs of global wood harvests

Life Cycle Analysis of Carbon Flow and Carbon Footprint of Harvested Wood Products of Larix Principis-Rupprechtii in China

Inter- and intra-growth ring variations of wood carbon fractions in Pinus tabuliformis

Contribution of forest wood products to negative emissions: historical comparative analysis from 1960 to 2015 in Norway, Sweden and Finland

Biogenic carbon in buildings: a critical overview of LCA methods

Review of carbon storage function of harvested wood products and the potential of wood substitution in greenhouse gas mitigation

Life Cycle Assessment of the Environmental Benefits of Using Wood Products and Planting Trees at an All-Electric University Laboratory

The Present Net Impact Value for the Atmospheric Emission of Forest Carbon from Harvested Wood Products

Variations of Carbon Allocation and Turnover Time Across Tropical Forests

The economic and emissions benefits of engineered wood products in a low-carbon future

Quantifying the greenhouse benefits of the use of wood products in two popular house designs in Sydney, Australia

Life-cycle impact assessment of hardwood forest resources in the eastern United States

Cities as carbon sinks—classification of wooden buildings

Embodied carbon assessment using a dynamic climate model: Case-study comparison of a concrete, steel and timber building structure

Downsizing and the use of timber as embodied carbon reduction strategies for new-build housing: A partial life cycle assessment

Measuring carbon in forests: current status and future challenges

Life Cycle Assessment of the Construction Process in a Mass Timber Structure