Abstract:Repeated exposure to information increases its' perceived truth, and this illusory truth effect is often explained by two theoretical frameworks: the fluency account and the referential theory of truth. Whereas the fluency account suggests that prior activation of a single referent within a statement should increase its perceived truth, the referential theory makes no such predictions. The referential theory instead proposes that when a statement is processed, it activates the corresponding memory referents within that statement and strengthens the connection between these referents in the semantic memory network. Because repeated statements will have more coherent corresponding referents than new statements, they are perceived as relatively truer. Experiments 1 and 2 focused on testing the fluency account, with participants exposed to one or two of a statement's referents before evaluating that statement's truth. Experiments 3 and 4 focused on the referential theory by exposing participants to non-critical facts that linked together two of a critical statements' referents before evaluating the truth of the critical statements. We consistently observed a standard illusory truth effect, such that facts that repeated verbatim were rated as truer than new facts. However, perceived truth was not affected by prior exposure to the critical statement's topic (Experiment 1) or by prior exposure to non-critical facts related to the same topic(s) as the critical statement (Experiment 2). There was also no boost in perceived truth following prior exposure to non-critical facts that linked together two of the primary referents of the critical statement but did so in a semantically distinct manner from how those same referents were linked in the critical statement itself (Experiments 3 and 4). However, Experiment 4 demonstrated that perceived truth significantly increased if there was prior exposure to non-critical facts that linked two of the critical statement primary referents in a way that was semantically coherent with how those same referents were linked within the critical statement. Together, these results are consistent with the referential theory, and suggest that semantic consistency across repetitions plays a crucial role in leading to repetition-based illusory truth effects.

Repeated by many versus repeated by one: Examining the role of social consensus in the relationship between repetition and belief.

People underestimate the influence of repetition on truth judgments (and more so for themselves than for others)

Illusions of knowledge due to mere repetition

The illusory truth effect: A review of how repetition increases belief in misinformation

The illusory certainty: Information repetition and impressions of truth enhance subjective confidence in validity judgments independently of the factual truth

The illusory truth effect requires semantic coherence across repetitions

False information is harder to debunk after gist repetitions than verbatim repetitions

Repetition increases belief in climate-skeptical claims, even for climate science endorsers

The moral repetition effect: Bad deeds seem less unethical when repeatedly encountered.

Illusory truth effect across languages and scripts

An ongoing secondary task can reduce the illusory truth effect

The effects of repetition spacing on the illusory truth effect

Subjective Confidence as a Monitor of the Replicability of the Response

Says Who? Credibility Effects in Self-Verification Strivings

Determinants of consensus in person judgments: The joint influence of information overlap, information quantity, cross-situational consistency, and shared meaning.

How explicit warnings reduce the truth effect: A multinomial modeling approach

An Empirical Study on One-sided VS Two-sided Advertising's Repetition Effects

The influence of repetitive thoughts of CS-US pairing on expectancy learning and evaluative conditioning: a fundamental study

Replications are informative, particularly when they fail

The effect of trial repetition and problem size on the consistency of decision making

Will your words become mine? Underlying processes and cowitness intimacy in the memory conformity paradigm.