Prospects for a national health service or for comprehensive health insurance.
B. Towers
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/jme.3.1.42
1977-03-01
Journal of Medical Ethics
Abstract:During the mid-ig4os, when prospects for the British National Health Service were being debated, I was a medical student and house officer, too busy on the whole to pay much attention to the political infighting of the various pressure groups that emerged. I have vivid recollections, though, as I perusedmy special-rate-for-students British Medical Journal and Lancet, of a feeling of deep disappointment with some members of my chosen profession. Being young and idealistic I thought everybodywould want only what was best for patients all patients, regardless of age, race, sex or social status. Trained in the voluntary hospital system, by a group of 'honorary' physicians whose freely given services qualified them for their honourable title and teaching role, and also by their salaried registrars, I found it hard to stomach the letters and articles in the journals of that period from practising doctors whose main, or even only, concern seemed to be what level of compensation they would get on transfer of their privately owned practices to the state. Property rights loomed large, and much wheeling and dealing must have gone on between all the various factions. And yet it all seemed to be resolved quite quickly and with a wealth of enthusiasm and goodwill on all sides. My first few years as a permanent resident in the United States have coincided with a period of intense debate about the prospects for a US national health service. Again, I have found myself too busy with other things to be anything more than a sideline spectator of a scene which is far more complex (not to say bewildering) than anything I remember in Great Britain thirty years ago. By comparison, American football and baseball (which are confusing enough, in all conscience, to a new immigrant) are child's play to follow. The forces pressing for a national health service, or at least for a