Air Pollution and Respiratory Infectious Diseases

Sandro Provenzano,Sefi Roth,Lutz Sager

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10640-024-00858-x

2024-04-19

Environmental and Resource Economics

Abstract:Recent research suggests that short-term exposure to air pollution is associated with an elevated prevalence of respiratory infectious disease. In this paper, we examine the relationship between the air quality index and weekly cases of COVID-19 and influenza-like illnesses (ILI) in the United States. We address potential bias from omitted variables and measurement error with an instrumental variable approach using atmospheric temperature inversions. Unlike other recent studies, we find no relationship between air quality and either COVID-19 or ILI cases.

economics,environmental studies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the relationship between air pollution and respiratory infectious diseases (especially COVID - 19 and influenza - like illness). Specifically, the authors explored the short - term association between the Air Quality Index (AQI) and the number of weekly reported COVID - 19 and influenza - like illness (ILI) cases in the United States. By using atmospheric temperature inversion as an instrumental variable to address the problems of omitted variable bias and measurement error, the study aims to evaluate the impact of air pollution on these two major and costly respiratory infectious diseases.

### Background of the Paper
Recent studies have shown that short - term exposure to air pollution is associated with a high incidence of respiratory infectious diseases. However, these studies may be affected by omitted variable bias and measurement error, leading to uncertainty in the results. Therefore, this paper re - evaluates the relationship between air pollution and respiratory infectious diseases by using atmospheric temperature inversion as an instrumental variable.

### Research Methods
1. **Data Sources**:
- **COVID - 19 Data**: Based on the weekly COVID - 19 cases and death data of 1,004 US counties from January 2020 to December 2020 provided by usafacts.org.
- **Influenza - like Illness (ILI) Data**: Based on the weekly ILI case data of each state from 2010/11 to 2018/19 provided by the US Centers for Disease Control (CDC).
- **Air Quality Index (AQI)**: From the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), with data averaged from daily to weekly.
- **Meteorological Data**: Including surface air temperature, precipitation, and relative humidity, based on the North American Regional Reanalysis (NARR) database of NOAA.
- **Atmospheric Temperature Inversion Frequency**: Based on the MERRA - 2 database of NASA.

2. **Model Specification**:
- Use Poisson Pseudo - Maximum Likelihood (PPML) regression to estimate the relationship between air pollution and respiratory infectious diseases.
- To overcome the problems of omitted variables and measurement error, use atmospheric temperature inversion as an instrumental variable and conduct two - stage least squares (2SLS) regression.

### Main Findings
- **Non - Instrumental Variable Estimation**:
- Preliminary analysis shows that for every 1 - point increase in AQI, the number of COVID - 19 cases increases by 1.6%, but this association disappears after controlling for time and regional fixed effects.
- For ILI cases, the preliminary analysis also shows a positive correlation, but after controlling for time and regional fixed effects, this association becomes insignificant.

- **Instrumental Variable Estimation**:
- After using atmospheric temperature inversion as an instrumental variable, it is found that the positive correlation between AQI and COVID - 19 and ILI cases disappears after controlling for region - specific seasonality.
- Whether in the control function method or in the case of using deviation from long - term averages, no significant association between air pollution and respiratory infectious diseases is found.

### Conclusion
Unlike previous literature, this paper fails to find a significant relationship between short - term air pollution fluctuations and the number of COVID - 19 or ILI cases after controlling for region - specific seasonality. This result emphasizes the importance of considering region - specific seasonality when studying the relationship between air pollution and respiratory infectious diseases.