"I know when to stop": Sentinels and counter-strategies against drowsy driving in narcolepsy and idiopathic hypersomnia
Elsa Beguin,Jean Baptiste Maranci,Smaranda Leu-Semenescu,Pauline Dodet,Ana Gales,Delphine Oudiette,Thomas Andrillon,Isabelle Arnulf
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/sleep/zsae168
IF: 6.313
2024-08-29
SLEEP
Abstract:Study objectives: To collect prodromal symptoms experienced by participants with narcolepsy and idiopathic hypersomnia (considered "hypersomnolence experts") prior to drowsy driving and counter-strategies used to maintain alertness. Methods: Systematic, face-to-face interview (using a semi-structured questionnaire), including clinical measures, frequency of car accidents/near misses, and symptoms experienced before impending drowsy driving episodes and counter-strategies. Results: Among 61 participants (32 with narcolepsy, 29 with idiopathic hypersomnia; 56 drivers), 61% of drivers had at least one lifetime accident/near miss. They had a higher sleepiness score (14 ± 4 vs. 11 ± 5, P<0.04) than those without an accident/near miss, but no other differences in demographics, driving experience, medical conditions, symptoms, sleep tests, and treatment. All but three participants experienced prodromal symptoms of drowsy driving, which included postural and motor changes (86.9%: axial hypotonia - e.g., eyelid droop, stereotyped movements), cognitive impairment (53.3%: automatic steering, difficulty concentrating/shifting, dissociation, mind wandering, dreaming), sensory (65%: paresthesia, pain, stiffness, heaviness, blunted perceptions such as a flat dashboard with loss of 3D, illusions and hallucinations), and autonomic symptoms (10%, altered heart/breath rate, penile erection). Counterstrategies included self-stimulation from external sources (pain, cold air, music, drinks, driving with bare feet), motor changes (upright posture, movements), and surprise (sudden braking). Conclusions: Drowsy driving symptoms can result from "local" NREM, entry in N1 sleep, and hybrid wake/REM sleep states. These rich qualitative insights from participants with narcolepsy and idiopathic hypersomnia, as well as sophisticated counter-strategies, can be gathered to reduce the crash risk in this population, but also in inexperienced healthy drivers.