Efficiency difference of electric grid utilities considering heterogeneity factor: Empirical analysis between China and Japan

Biao Li,Bai-Chen Xie,Hong-Zhou Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15567249.2024.2361769
2024-06-08
Energy Sources Part B Economics Planning and Policy
Abstract:Different economic development models, resource endowment conditions, and reform and regulatory strategies in China and Japan affect the performance of electric grid utilities significantly. This study combined the meta-frontier model with the four-component SFA model to investigate the sources of efficiency bias for electric grid utilities in China and Japan from 2006 to 2020. The results indicated significant differences between the efficiencies of utilities in China and Japan. China's average technical efficiency was 58%, while Japan's was 75%. Japan's efficiency is higher than that of China. Although largely caused by long-term and structural issues, the factors underlying the inefficiency of grid companies vary between China and Japan. After China implemented electricity reform in 2015, the efficiency gap between China and Japan has been gradually narrowing. By dividing the grid firms in China and Japan into eight groups, we found significant variations in efficiency between regions. These findings suggest that the reform of the power system should be carried out according to local conditions and there is a need for continued deepening of the electricity reform.
energy & fuels
What problem does this paper attempt to address?