Abstract:Abstract Agile methods and the related concepts of employee empowerment, self-management, and autonomy have reached large-scale software organizations and raise questions about commonly adopted principles for authority distribution. However, the optimum mechanism to balance the need for alignment, quality, and process control with the need or willingness of teams to be autonomous remains an unresolved issue. In this paper, we report our findings from a multiple-case study in two large-scale software development organizations in the telecom industry. We analysed the autonomy of the agile teams in the organizations using Hackman’s classification of unit authority and found that the teams were partly self-managing. Further, we found that alignment across teams can be achieved top-down by management and bottom-up through membership in communities or through dialogue between the team and management. However, the degree of team autonomy was limited by the need for organizational alignment. Top-down alignment and control were maintained through centralized decision-making for certain areas, the use of supervisory roles, mandatory processes, and checklists. One case employed a bottom-up approach to alignment through the formation of a community composed of all teams, experts, and supporting roles, but excluding managers. This community-based alignment involved teams in decision-making and engaged them in alignment initiatives. We conclude that implementation of such bottom-up structures seems to provide one possible mechanism for balancing organizational control and team autonomy in large-scale software development.

Team performance and large scale agile software development

Team Learning, Transactive Memory System and Team Performance: A Longitudinal Study Based on the IMOI Approach

Attaining High-performing Software Teams with Agile and Lean Practices: An Empirical Case Study

Using Social Network Analysis to Investigate the Collaboration Between Architects and Agile Teams: A Case Study of a Large-Scale Agile Development Program in a German Consumer Electronics Company

A survey on agile practices and challenges of a global software development team

Social Identity in Software Development

Evaluation of team dynamic in Norwegian projects for IT students

Fireteam: a Small-Team Development Practice in Industry

A Perspective on the Role of Human Behaviors in Software Development: Voice and Silence

Understanding Work Practices of Autonomous Agile Teams: A Social-psychological Review

The perceived effects of group developmental psychology training on agile software development teams

From Group Psychology to Software Engineering Research to Automotive R&D: Measuring Team Development at Volvo Cars

An Empirical Study on Leanness and Flexibility in Distributed Software Development

Finding the sweet spot for organizational control and team autonomy in large-scale agile software development

Effect of sociability and curiosity of senior developers in building agile scrum team competency

Seamless Long Term Learning in Agile Teams for Sustainable Leadership

Attitudes, Beliefs, and Development Data Concerning Agile Software Development Practices

Exploring software development at the very large-scale: a revelatory case study and research agenda for agile method adaptation

Agile Information System Development Organizations Transforming to Large-Scale Collaboration

Revealing the State of the Art of Large-Scale Agile Development Research: A Systematic Mapping Study

Large-Scale Agile Transformations for Software Quality Assurance: An Empirical Case Study from Pakistan