Abstract:Various galaxy merger detection methods have been applied to diverse datasets. However, it is difficult to understand how they compare. Our aim is to benchmark the relative performance of merger detection methods based on machine learning (ML). We explore six leading ML methods using three main datasets. The first dataset consists of mock observations from the IllustrisTNG simulations, which acts as the training data and allows us to quantify the performance metrics of the detection methods. The second dataset consists of mock observations from the Horizon-AGN simulations, introduced to evaluate the performance of classifiers trained on different, but comparable data to those employed for training. The third dataset is composed of real observations from the Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program (HSC-SSP) survey. We also compare mergers and non-mergers detected by the different methods with a subset of HSC-SSP visually identified galaxies. For the simplest binary classification task (i.e. mergers vs. non-mergers), all six methods perform reasonably well in the domain of the training data. At the lowest redshift explored $0.1<z<0.3$, precision and recall generally range between sim 70 and 80 , both of which decrease with increasing $z$ as expected (by sim 5 for precision and sim 10 for recall at the highest $z$ explored $0.76<z<1.0$). When transferred to a different domain, the precision of all classifiers is only slightly reduced, but the recall is significantly worse (by sim 20-40 depending on the method). Zoobot offers the best overall performance in terms of precision and F1 score. When applied to real HSC observations, different methods agree well with visual labels of clear mergers, but can differ by more than an order of magnitude in predicting the overall fraction of major mergers. For the more challenging multi-class classification task to distinguish between pre-mergers, ongoing-mergers, and post-mergers, none of the methods in their current set-ups offer good performance, which could be partly due to the limitations in resolution and the depth of the data. In particular, ongoing-mergers and post-mergers are much more difficult to classify than pre-mergers. With the advent of better quality data (e.g. from JWST and Euclid), it is of great importance to improve our ability to detect mergers and distinguish between merger stages.

Galaxy mergers in UNIONS – I. A simulation-driven hybrid deep learning ensemble for pure galaxy merger classification

Galaxy Mergers in UNIONS -- I: A Simulation-driven Hybrid Deep Learning Ensemble for Pure Galaxy Merger Classification

Identifying Galaxy Mergers in Observations and Simulations with Deep Learning

Galaxy merger challenge: A comparison study between machine learning-based detection methods

Accurate Identification of Galaxy Mergers with Imaging

Galaxy mergers in Subaru HSC-SSP: a deep representation learning approach for identification and the role of environment on merger incidence

Galaxy evolution in the post-merger regime I -- Most merger-induced in-situ stellar mass growth happens post-coalescence

Deep learning predictions of galaxy merger stage and the importance of observational realism

Identifying Mergers in the Legacy Surveys with Few-shot Learning

Identifying Galaxy Cluster Mergers with Deep Neural Networks using Idealized Compton-y and X-ray maps

Automatic quantitative morphological analysis of interacting galaxies

CEERS Key Paper. IX. Identifying Galaxy Mergers in CEERS NIRCam Images Using Random Forests and Convolutional Neural Networks

The effect of image quality on galaxy merger identification with deep learning

Identifying Galaxy Mergers in Simulated CEERS NIRCam Images using Random Forests

Simultaneous derivation of galaxy physical properties with multimodal deep learning

A post-merger enhancement only in star-forming Type 2 Seyfert galaxies: the deep learning view

Unveiling Galaxy Morphology through an Unsupervised-Supervised Hybrid Approach

The limitations (and potential) of non-parametric morphology statistics for post-merger identification