Understanding College Students' Healthcare Avoidance: From Early Maladaptive Schemas, through Healthcare Institutional Betrayal and Betrayal Trauma Appraisal of Worst Healthcare Experiences

Pedram J. Rastegar,Jennifer Langhinrichsen-Rohling
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/healthcare12111126
2024-06-01
Health Care
Abstract:Understanding healthcare avoidance among college students is critical. In this study, we consider two broad cognitive contributors to greater healthcare avoidance: specific early maladaptive schema and negative appraisals of students' prior worst healthcare experiences. From schema theory, we proposed college students holding greater levels of two early maladaptive schema (disconnection/rejection and impaired autonomy/performance EMS) would be more likely to appraise their problematic healthcare experience as both containing healthcare institutional betrayal (HIB) behaviors and as traumatic and betrayal-inducing; both EMS and these appraisals would predict healthcare avoidance. Using a cross-sectional survey in a large, diverse college student sample (n = 1383, 61.1% female, 18.9% African American, 7.2% Asian, 6.4% Hispanic/Latino), as predicted, both EMS were significantly related to healthcare avoidance. Furthermore, a sequential mediation model was supported, indicating students holding greater EMS of disconnection/rejection or impaired autonomy/rejection reported more HIB in their worst healthcare experience, and appraised that experience as more betraying. Taken altogether, this model accounted for 23% of the variance in students' reports of healthcare avoidance. Core beliefs formed early in life may be a foundational lens through which potentially traumatic healthcare experiences are processed in ways that can impact emerging adults' future healthcare engagement. Findings also support the importance of addressing HIB actions and repairing trauma appraisals accrued during problematic healthcare experiences to prevent healthcare avoidance by emerging adults.
health care sciences & services,health policy & services
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper primarily explores the avoidance behavior of college students in healthcare and attempts to understand the psychological mechanisms behind this behavior. The study specifically focuses on how two cognitive factors influence college students' healthcare avoidance behavior: 1. Early Maladaptive Schemas (EMS), and 2. Healthcare Institutional Betrayal (HIB) and Betrayal Trauma Appraisal (BTA) in their worst medical experiences. ### Research Questions The main question the paper aims to address is: How do early maladaptive schemas, healthcare institutional betrayal behavior, and betrayal appraisal of the worst medical experiences jointly predict college students' healthcare avoidance behavior? ### Core Contributions - **Theoretical Framework**: The paper adopts the BITTEN model as its theoretical framework, which emphasizes how patients' historical experiences, psychological trauma, and negative medical experiences influence their future healthcare engagement. - **Cognitive Factors**: The paper focuses on two specific cognitive factors—early maladaptive schemas (including the subdomains of "Disconnection and Rejection" and "Impaired Autonomy and Performance") and how these influence individuals' appraisal of healthcare experiences, which in turn leads to healthcare avoidance behavior. - **Empirical Analysis**: Through a cross-sectional survey of 1,383 college students, the study finds a significant correlation between early maladaptive schemas and healthcare avoidance. Additionally, through sequential mediation model analysis, it demonstrates the process from early maladaptive schemas to healthcare institutional betrayal behavior, then to betrayal appraisal, and finally leading to healthcare avoidance. - **Results Interpretation**: The study reveals that early-formed beliefs may serve as a foundational perspective for dealing with potentially traumatic medical experiences, affecting individuals' future healthcare-seeking behavior. Furthermore, the paper emphasizes the importance of addressing healthcare institutional betrayal behavior and repairing traumatic appraisals to prevent healthcare avoidance behavior among young people. In summary, this research provides important insights into college students' healthcare avoidance behavior and offers a theoretical basis for the design of intervention measures.